It's a very "Cape Cpd" influences 1-story on the outside, with that salt-box shape garage. Just painting a contrast trim (pale cream to match a cream I see in the bricks?) and painting the garage door to match house would do a lot with the yellow, if it's in good dhape You really need to be there in person or have a trusted person do the paint selections to enhance the brick center section. SW Foggy Day - or a paler version of it - could look very good with that brick, but it takes an in-person color check. I'd do part of the house in and the garage portion something else to enhance the "we built this over time as the camily crew" look.

Thanks for your response! I find this color of brick very hard to work with. I can see the black, or perhaps, medium charcoal, working. The front now looks like it does in the top picture. That is wrought iron fencing around the plantings. Do you think it would, visually, work, if just the window trim was painted, which would leave the white window. Or just leave the windows unpainted? The sliders would remain white. Can you visualize everything across painted black, and then all the brick...would that be too dark? Perhaps I could add color in the door area ( painting entrance door and switching to a full view storm door??

Hi everyone, we are going ahead with this paint job next week and I still don't have my color finalized. So I'm bumping it. I'm testing some samples now; here are a few I like: https://www.houzz.com/photos/custom-craftsman-home-exterior-craftsman-exterior-chicago-phvw-vp~624882 https://www.houzz.com/photos/green-lake-classic-craftsman-craftsman-exterior-seattle-phvw-vp~334232 Any thoughts on why this will/won't work for my house? I like the combo of colors but realize my house is a bit different.

May be odd man out but I like the version of Rockport she got and that's on the garage door with the stone. Don't love the current color of the stucco. Of course color online is never accurate but IME with stone on exteriors... If you can do colors that skew greenish it's always a good thing vs. a near neutral from the YR hue family. Or as some people might call it, taupe. IMO. And OP said she likes Rockport with the stone. So I vote more Rockport.