The faucet selection should be in keeping with the style of your kitchen. (though you didn't indicate if this is for the kitchen or the bathroom.

For cleaning issues, I like a single-lever faucet and an additional hole for a side sprayer, and another hole for a soap dispenser.

I have had the spray hose that pulls out of the faucet end and frankly and I prefer a separate sprayer when I need to use one.

If I didn't want a separate side spray, I would select a hi arc faucet with a coil movable sprayer.

We inherited a stupidly expensive ($1100 from the dicount places) single hole deck mount faucet in the process of buying a used kitchen. As a faucet it's great, but with only a single mounting point it rotates in the hole and loostens, requiring periodic sessions standing on my head under the sink to re-tighten the nut (yes, I bought all new washers and gaskets when installing it). Given the choice I'd have one with at least two mounting points.

I decided on the finish and general style first. Price was a consideration, as was features -- no touchless or electronic features whatsoever, and had to be a single handle pull-out or pull-down. I've always had terrific luck with Delta, so that was my brand preference from the get-go, but I would have been open to other brands if I couldn't find the finish, style, and features I was looking for.

So, start with finish, style, and features and then further narrow it down from there.

I just finally settled on my new kitchen faucet after months of looking. I wanted as few holes as possible (wall mount isn't possible for me). I thought I had landed on a Delta touch faucet and was about to hit Buy when I came across a Kraus faucet with sprayer AND integrated water filter dispenser. It's well reviewed and I can't wait to get it installed. With my Simple Human automatic soap dispenser I hope it willl be mess and clutter free on my new leathered countertop.

Sorry I forgot to mention that it is a kitchen faucet. All the comments are really helpful, thank you! The style does come into play, but unless the kitchen was designed all in one go, there's usually a mix of styles, at least that's the case for us! I'm probably going to steer towards one that would be considered simple or minimal because then you don't have to worry about another style to match...

I selected based on feature. I would have loved a wall mounted faucet but couldn't find one with a single handle. Single handle was more important to me. Then after seeing videos and hearing great things about arbon articulating faucets, wanted one of those but they don't make them anymore. Ended up getting the only articulating faucet I could find (brizio).

Our CKD likes Kohler. He suggested one and I don't think I even looked at the photo. Single handle with integrated sprayer. No batteries or electronics. Same with the sink - no sharp corners for easy cleaning. Didn't look at that photo either.

It's a faucet: the water comes out hot and cold. The maid cleans it every two weeks. Minimal involvement.

Cabinets are another story. To me, those make or break a kitchen. Appliances, too. With any project one has to pick and choose one's battles. a faucet isn't mine.

Kingston Brass appears to be the only manufacturer of wall-mount faucets that include a sprayer and they are ugly. Kingston Brass Concord. No sprayer, no go. And what happens if the faucet leaks, requires repair, or needs replacement? That's easy to do if it is attached to the countertop.

FWIW I have a wall mount in a bathroom and have to clean the wall of drips and bubbles that drop or fling off people’s fingers when they are turning off the water. It’s kind of gross, worse than a regular faucet. 20 years and I’m still not used to it. Whatever you have, you’ll have to clean something.

Also, the pull down styles posted are popular now (and that’s what I have now) but I don’t like using them as much as what I used to have, which had a handle to hold, kind of like this. It was much much more comfortable and useful than aiming a little tube with a tiny button. https://www.build.com/product/summary/1374668?uid=3246175&jmtest=gg-gbav2_3246175&inv2=1&&source=gg-gba-pla_3246175!c1705989067!a65446962166!dm!ng&gclid=EAIaIQobChMIyu204sW19QIV4pJbCh2cyQHqEAQYCCABEgJIR_D_BwE&gclsrc=aw.ds

I chose a Kohler Koi faucet, after extensive research. I love it; no issues! The simple lines go well with my Shaker style cabinets.
A matching soap/lotion dispenser is included.
Single-lever handle is simple to use and makes adjusting water temperature easy.
High-arch swivel spout offers superior clearance for filling pitchers and cleaning.
Two-function pull-down sprayhead with touch-control allows you to switch from stream to Sweep® spray.
KOHLER ceramic disc valves exceed industry longevity standards for a lifetime of durable performance.
Sweep® spray features specially angled nozzles that form a wide, powerful blade of water to sweep your dishes and sink clean.
DockNetik® magnetic docking system securely locks the sprayhead into place when not in use.
MasterClean™ sprayface features an easy-to-clean surface that withstands mineral buildup.
KOHLER finishes featuring ScratchShield® technology withstand even the toughest daily use.

I have never worked with a wall mount faucet, so I cannot comment on that option, however, I see negative comments about motion faucets. I have had a Moen touchless with pull down sprayer for 5 years and really like it! It is a single hole design with optional soap dispenser hole (which I wish I would not have used). The motion took some getting used to, due to its sensitivity. But my absolute favorite thing about it is how sanitary it is. It is easy to clean because it is rarely touched except on the pull down and the lever, so just a quick go over with the dishcloth works great. My hands get greasy or full of flour or whatever I am handling, so just moving my grubby little paw over the sensor gives me the wash I need without getting all of the gunk on the lever. There are two sensor options. One for a quick (about 1/2 c.), and one for continuous flow (which will shut off after awhile). There is also the option of using only the lever. And the option of removing batteries for a standard faucet operation. The only thing that has gone wrong is the pull down spray developed a leak, and the weight control wouldn't retract the hose fully. Moen replaced both without charge. Lifetime warranty!

My current faucet just came with the place I bought, and I haven't changed it, but when I purposely bought a new faucet for a reno, I chose it the instant I saw it on line. I absolutely loved the unique appearance and ergonomic shape that still looked beautiful. OK, I did go find one to test in my hand, to make sure the sizing was right, and it felt as good in my hand as I knew it would. I wanted a pull out, with a sprayer function, and by a manufacturer I trusted (mine was HansGrohe). I miss it:

After over 30 years dealing with disappointing cheap faucets, I finally decided it was time to splurge. Or rather, invest. The faucet gets used countless times each day, so it is a hard working appliance and needs to hold up and perform. I love the long spring-neck faucets in commercial kitchens and tried a cheap one previous to my new one. It disappointed. No reach and shoddy construction. I was ready to actually source a commercial fixture when I found this one. It is a beast. There are hundreds of similar faucets to choose from, but they all have very modern style. That was also important for me and this really was the only one that hit all my needs. It retails for $1000 or so, but I had earned a bonus in an Amazon gift card, and found a seller there who was offering it at a good price. After the discounts I paid about half of retail. For me it was still a big splurge, but I don’t regret it for a second! I opted not to include any other accessories at the sink, so I only have one hole. I also put a slab of my soapstone behind it as a short splash, replacing part of the window frame. It makes clean up much easier. The investment was worth every penny and I’ll never go back to cheap faucets again.

Oh, as for deck mount vs. wall mount. Here in the Midwest we cannot run water lines in outside walls. It’s also much easier to access plumbing for repairs, etc. Under the sink (deck mount) than if it were behind the walls. I do like the idea of not having that post to clean around, but in the end it’s such a small thing. IMO all options weighed, minimal deck mount wins.

https://www.us.kohler.com/us/tournant-semiprofessional-kitchen-sink-faucet/productDetail/kitchen-sink-faucets/1274493.htm?skuId=1274476&brandId=1304794

Whatever kitchen faucet you buy, get it from a reputable plumbing supply showroom and not a big box store. What they don't tell you about buying what looks to be the same Delta or Kohler faucet at Home Depot is that they often replace the ceramic valves for plastic ones to lower the cost. So it it doesn't last as long.

Delta, Kohler, Brizo (hi-end Delta) are all really good options if you don't want to spend an arm and a leg. I'd avoid Grohe--I hear most of their faucets are made in China now and are not made as well as they used to be.

I pored over this super helpful website and purchased the one with the best warranty.

http://starcraftcustombuilders.com/

@Sabrina Alfin Interiors: "Whatever kitchen faucet you buy, get it from a reputable plumbing supply showroom and not a big box store. What they don't tell you about buying what looks to be the same Delta or Kohler faucet at Home Depot is that they often replace the ceramic valves for plastic ones to lower the cost."

This is absolutely NOT TRUE. If the model number is the same then the product is the same regardless of where you buy it: plumbing store, big box store, or online. Stop spreading this nonsense.

@Sabrina Alfin Interiors: "I'd avoid Grohe--I hear most of their faucets are made in China now and are not made as well as they used to be."

More nonsense. Kohler faucets, for example, are also made in China, India, and Mexico.

@wdcruise, you’re correct IF the model number is the same. But many times the body of the faucet will look the same but the innards are not.

"What they don't tell you about buying what looks to be the same Delta or Kohler faucet...."

Don't go by what looks the same, so by the same model number. If the model number is the same, it's the same faucet. If the model number is different, it's not the same faucet, even if it looks the same.

Thank you all for your comments, there has been such helpful insight. Getting comments based on experience is really helpful, who knew that having too many options would be a problem!

I went with the U by Moen. I saw the cool voice command features. What sold me on this model compared to the Delta and Kohler options is that it doesn't require a power outlet, plus the fact that it was less expensive than the Delta VoiceIQ and especially the Kohler Sensate with Konnect were strong selling points for me. We are very happy with it and it gives us minimal problems.

Hi- I'm replacing my counters & backsplash. I currently have an Axor Citerrio Hi Arc [chrome] which is in perfect condition & has performed w/o any issues. When I bought it —about 12 yrs ago—there were no commercial style-faucets under 20" so it wasn't an option but since I'm redoing my counters, I'm considering replacing it now w/the Kraus Bolden. I was astounded to see the current price of the Axor Citterio is ~ $800 [which it wasn't when I purchased it] vs the Kraus at $200. I assume it has to do w/Axor's parts being all brass & the designer name [which I don't care about] vs some of Kraus's parts being plastic. Since so many here have commented on quality, my question is, am I crazy to change faucets, will I be sacrificing quality? Can anyone comment on the quality of the Kraus Bolden, how the plastic pieces hold up & any issues if there are any?

Thx!

@rm101 "I was astounded to see the current price of the Axor Citterio is ~ $800"

Yeah, that Axor faucet is really expensive but the Hansgrohe Talis S 14877 with gooseneck spout is $300 and the Hansgrohe Talis S 04310001 with swivel spout is $332 at Quality Bath.

The problem I have with wall-mounted faucets is they usually (not always, but usually) have two handles. I'd probably get used to it, but it would annoy me endlessly to put down whatever I wanted to either rinse, wash or fill and use two hands to adjust the water temperature.

I feel like I'm the queen at replacing faucets this qtr - two done in the kitchen, two to go in bathrooms. So, I'm wondering how that would work if the faucet was in your tile backsplash and then you had to replace it?

@rmlny

Those two faucets seem quite different to me, I would base a lot of my decision on more than just the quality of the parts (some of which are probably replaceable anyway). The Bolden doesn't seem to have a retractable hose, just a flexible spout. It also has the "support arm" that holds the spout at the end - that seems pretty annoying to have and you lose clearance around the spout. Not to mention how difficult it looks to clean the coil spring.

I would probably keep the Axor, if I am thinking correctly you can always replace it down the road quite easily (as long as the new faucet uses the same hole diameter).

@User

They are different. The Bolden is a commercial-style but are both still modern. I don't want want to sacrifice quality to switch & I definitely do not want to have to replace parts down the road. Just fyi, Bolden does have a retractable hose like the Axor & the support arm swivels to avoid clearance problems

Before I got that semi-commercial Kohler (posted earlier) I tried a similar-looking one I found for about $200. It wasn’t worth it. The hose & spring were really just for looks. It didn’t really have much reach or flexibility, and the sprayer was always troublesome. I’ve always resisted that upper price range, but since getting this one I have now, I can tell the difference in every way. I will never go back to the cheaper stuff. I wish I had learned this lesson years ago. If you like that commercial spring style, definitely upgrade to the better models out there. I was able to find mine for far less than the SRP $. Try this Crue model from Kohler - similar to your choices, but functionally more like my Tournant model.

https://www.us.kohler.com/us/crue-pull-down-single-handle-semiprofessional-kitchen-faucet/productDetail/kitchen-sink-faucets/1782968.htm?skuId=1782882&brandId=1873842

@Therese N

Thx! I think u told me what I wanted to hear or at least confirmed what I was thinking. Love the Kohler but it's too high—I only have 21" clearance —& honestly I don't think i want to spend $500 when I have the Axor that works fine—even tough I like the look of the commercial styles. I picked up the Kraus & immediately noticed the water lines & the hose are much smaller in diameter than the Axor & the the spray nozzle is plastic. I'm not knocking it. It's a nice faucet & gets a lot of good reviews but I will probably stick w/what I have for now

We have a Delta Emmeline and are very happy with it.

Our search parameters...

1) Warranty

2) Looks good

3) Not hard to find parts

4) Reasonable price for our budget (under $400)

3) Matte black

4) Pull-down with spray

5) No deck plate needed

6) Touch activation a plus

7) Matching soap dispenser available (not included in $400)

8) Simple lines

I knew I didn't want a very expensive faucet as my sister had a Rohl and finding parts was a nightmare. This was way before COVID and she lives just outside the NY metro area. If she had trouble there I was going to be out of luck in NH.

It's only been about 7 months but so far so good. We did have an issue with dripping when in the "open" position but touched off and the part arrived within 2 days. The plumber commented that this was the first Delta he'd ever had a problem with. It looks great and is nice and solid.

Interestingly-my sister finally replace her faucet with a Delta and it feels flimsy to me. It's chrome and not touch activated so I'm not sure if that has anything to do with it but thought I'd point that out.Delta Emmeline Faucet-touch

Currently, I have an inexpensive Delta and Elkay. The delta is a single handle pullout with the handle on the top of the spout column. The elkay is a plain, single handle, also with the handle on top.

The Elkay handle is effortless as is rotating the spout. Feels solid and useful.

The Delta does not. It feels plastic, the handle is a little tough and rotating is a little hard, but the annoying part is the pull out notch when you take it out or put back. It get stuck. It feels like it will break in the next year. It's just not well done. Ugit wut Upay.