I like the door style - however the Victorian-style glass (including the arch above) could be replaced. I don't see the "pink" and think the current color complements your exterior.

This house will never be modern farmhouse unless you have $$$$$. One thing you could do is take out all of the brick "terraces" in the front, and add landscape plants to soften the look of the stone on the exterior of your home.

Wood would look nice:

@Sammie J, we did consider only replacing the glass and painting the doors. The problem is that the frame is not the same color as the door and would also have to be painted. Paint is not the most durable (especially here with harsh winters and full sun in the summer). The paint used to be beige but it did turn pinkish (I will try to take another photo the other one is old - I do have tons (need to clean up and trim) of flowers and plants lol). I do like the door style and maybe the squares like in the photos added by Jink but in gray?

@Jilly, thanks I really like the style! I love wood but with the harsh winters i

I would be scared they would not stay nice for years to come. What do you think about that style but steel and dark gray (Iron Ore maybe?) with sandblasted or other private glass (because privacy is not an option for my husband…).

I love the wood. And I think you can do wood and if it gets washed out you’ll paint over it.

I also like your current doors and think you can repaint those as well. And just replace all the glass. - I’d go with this option and remove some of the stonework with the rest of the budget.

The wood doors that Jinx posted would look amazing with your home. I don't think that doing that style in gray, as you suggest, would look even remotely as beautiful. Your home already has enough gray in the stone. I am assuming that it is your garage to the right in the picture, and I think wood garage doors that echo the entry doors would be great, too.

@Sammie J, I like you idea to remove the terraces (I think you mean the big pieces of stone/pavers that make up the flower beds?). Any ideas how to rearrange the look though?

@BeverlyFLADeziner, thanks I like this one (and am not against a side light!). You believe this is better aestheticly? I simply want to make sure I understand 100% where you’re coming from :)

Typically double doors (and who knows why your double doors have a divider?) would be appropriate for a more formal home. If you are trying to move to Farmhouse, I think a single door with sidelights is more appropriate.

You can select double doors, but they might appear like these below.

@BeverlyFLADeziner, I have looked into my options some more and here are two styles (first one my husband prefers and second one I prefer). What do you think? Third photo is how I eventually envision the house (if perhaps I can afford changing the khaki/beige metal to charcoal…). Would one door with sidelights still be the best option or 2 doors?

I would keep the doors. Call a local glass company and see if you can replace the stained-glass look windows in the doors and above with divided light panels. Paint the doors and the surrounding trim a charcoal grey.

Thanks @Keith Dcil that’s actually the first option we looked at. We are concerned that the paint will not last and that it is something we will have to re-do every few years which will become as expensive as changing the doors. Maybe not? We have to paint the doors and frame and devider.