MCM inspired home- Polished concrete? Stone or brick for fireplace?
Tonja
3 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (18)
Indecisiveness
3 years agoRelated Discussions
Fireplace inspiration photos, please!
Comments (30)I found these three pictures online. I'm putting them in order of most favorite to least favorite. Thoughts? Opinions? We've gotten three estimates on our chimney flashing repair and they are all identical in work to be done and price (how often does that happen), so we're fairly certain of exactly what we're getting into there. Once we nail down what we want the fireplace to look like, we'll be on our way to a warm and not fugly living room. :) We're only looking at the mantel and legs, not the style of the firebox on these. Our fireplace contractor's mantel guy would be creating something that replicates the look; we wouldn't be buying the mantel from these original sources. Number 1: Number 2: Number 3: (Problem with this one would be the firewood box -- which I don't care for, and don't have room for anyway. That would leave an asymmetrical appearance, since there would be nothing in the wall area next to the existing firebox.) Always happy for input. I'm very confused and miserable about this stupid fireplace....See Moredesigning a MCM fireplace
Comments (45)I am sure whatever you decide to do it will look good, it will be tasteful and it will be sensitive to the house which is more than a lot of people would do. But I think there were a number of members whose opinions I respect have pretty much not participated in any threads about the renovation since you painted because they were dead set against it. I'm not sensing a lot of support for covering the block except from the camp that thinks one should do whatever you love, and of course there will always be support from the camp that would give Fallingwater a cottage makeover to "update" it. Remember that in a house that is so "specific" in design such as yours that any chipping away at what makes it so specific becomes rather "non-specific" and it takes away from the essential character and turns it into something blander. You've already said you have no problem diluting the original design intent of the house, and with some of it I agree with. But that may be also why you aren't getting a ton of positive feedback on the stone selections you've made, and that's what makes me also have trouble remembering what was compelling *for you* about this house. It may be different than what is compelling about it to most people and to most people those may be the things you are mostly changing. I live in one of four houses of a particular design by a modernist architect. For the most part, I think what has made them compelling to buyers in the location, and outdoor space on two levels which rare. They are quirky and odd to begin with but every single thing that has been done to one of them (and it's a lot, by different owners) has made it blander and blander, and now it's just ugly. I don't think you are going to do *that* but you may end up with the attractive woman who's had way too much plastic surgery syndrome. There is a point of diminishing returns or even negative returns....See MoreWhat kind of home finishes are distinctly mcm?
Comments (18)Very cool. I would argue for the screen to be the same body colour as the house. Here are some things I think about depending on your area as MCM style can be very regional: very simple and or minimal trim Slab interior doors and cabinet doors (plain). White or light Wood OK, Colour would be OK for kitchen cabinets if you are feeling bold. Wood panelled accent walls Light narrow wood flooring. very plain wall-to-wall carpeting would be contemporaneous but I just don't like it as much. brick or stone fireplaces Square tile in the bathrooms. I like colour in the bathroom. you can see a lot of great bathrooms on retro renovation and you can see people doing a lot of great things with liner/trim tiles. I think a good substitute for vintage Formica is solid surface counters. I really like the speckle kinds personally. I like simple modern light fixtures and I really like the globes on your exterior. You'll see globe fixtures showing up in all kinds of interiors, they are both classic and cheap which is a great combo in my books. if you have the budget linoleum or marmoleum are really neat flooring choices that can go well in a mcm home. I would veer away from Granite, marble or travertine. Slate or local fieldstone ok. I happen to love the look of terrazzo and I think a neat modern nod to terrazzo is polished concrete with glass chips. all this from a non-expert and slight enthusiast. PS if you're replacing the windows consider brown or black frames....See MoreOrange/Tan brick wall fireplace update
Comments (2)First off I'll say I think this space has great potential. Not sure what your style is or what the style of the house is, but it has some midcentury vibes. 1. Take your time with any decisions, if you just purchased / just moved in, no need to change things right away. The reason people always give this advice is it's easy to change your mind and if you haven't really thought about it for long enough you might do something you no longer like that's not easily reversible, like painting brick. 2. Delete wall paneling if possible. If not, paint white like the upper portion of the walls and ceiling. Or better yet lose that dark trim up top. 3. I would lose the curtains but I don't like window treatments, so... 3. Carpet --> light laminate or wood flooring like you said. In the zone of natural white oak. I know you mentioned this and obviously more $$$ and not a bandaid fix, I'm just affirming it's a good idea down the road :) 4. Get rid of shelving on fireplace, and ALL knick knacks that go with it 5. Put a nice looking set of fireplace tools on display 5. If you DO install light wood flooring in the future, consider a mantel that matches instead of the dark rustic looking one that is there. 6. Find a nice piece of art that speaks to you and elevates the room, larger than what's currently in place, and hang it above the mantel. Right now the art fades into the brick. 7. I don't know what is entailed, but if you can get rid of that hearth / semi-circle, get rid of it. Maybe when you do flooring there will be an opportunity to wrap demo of that in. 8. Splurge on a cool modern fan or interesting pendant light fixture to replace existing fan. Maybe add a table lamp to a side table for some additional light. 9. I would not paint or wash the brick, but I don't like painted brick. If you don't like the brick you might as well drywall over it. Again, just my opinion. I think there are a lot of other things you can address first, and then you might find the brick isn't an issue. Just some ideas. When I first moved into my house I also wanted to paint our brick fireplace, white. I'm soooo glad I didn't. I realize everyone has different styles, but just to show you how the surrounding details can make a difference, here is the listing photo and how it is today:...See MoreTonja
3 years agoTonja
3 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
3 years agoIndecisiveness
3 years agoflopsycat1
3 years agoTonja
3 years agocpartist
3 years agoTonja
3 years agoMark Bischak, Architect
3 years agoTonja
3 years agoIndecisiveness
3 years agodeb s
3 years agojust_janni
3 years agoPatricia Colwell Consulting
3 years agolast modified: 3 years agochispa
3 years agochispa
3 years ago
Related Stories
REMODELING GUIDESSurround Your Fireplace With Tile, Brick or Stone
Freshen up your fireplace with a crisp, colorful or dramatic new look
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMidcentury Case Study Houses Inspire a Desert Home’s Design
An architect blurs the lines between a new home and the vast Arizona landscape around it
Full StoryCONCRETE10 Solid Ways to Feature Concrete in Your Home
See how this versatile material holds up as countertops, fireplace surrounds, floors and more
Full StoryMIDCENTURY STYLE6 Inspiring Midcentury Australian Homes
Avant-garde homes of the '50s helped fuel decades of Australian innovation
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Usonian-Inspired Home With All the Wright Moves
A Chicago couple's weekend retreat fulfills a long-held dream of honoring architect Frank Lloyd Wright
Full StoryWORLD OF DESIGNAround the World in 12 Inspiring Vacation Homes
See beach houses, forest cabins and country cottages across the globe where people go to rest, recharge and enjoy nature
Full StoryECLECTIC HOMESMy Houzz: Colorful, Eclectic Style in an 1890 Kentucky Brick Home
A musician and a designer get creative with the walls, lighting and flooring in their live-work house
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: Redo Stays True to a California Home’s Ranch Roots
Vaulted ceilings, windows galore and a simple white palette make for casual indoor-outdoor living
Full StoryPATIO OF THE WEEKWisconsin Landscape Stays True to Home’s Midcentury Design
A landscape pro looks to this house’s historically significant modern architecture for a whole-yard makeover
Full StoryTRAVEL BY DESIGNHomes Away From Home: 10 Charming U.S. Bed-and-Breakfasts
Looking for a more personal stay on your getaway? These homey bed-and-breakfasts roll out the welcome mat in style
Full Story
elcieg