Houzz Logo Print
jally1

Resolved: Empirical evidence versus "expertise"

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

I once was told about a pre-arranged experiment wherein a college professor (or some such) prepped a number of students as a "control group" all of whom, when told that two lines on the chalkboard were of equal length (even though one line was obviously shorter than the other line) agreed with the professor.

The goal was to see if anyone outside the control group would actually go against the popular tide and disagree, based on his/her own Empirical observation. Sorta like the Emperor's "new" clothes.

With that said, I wonder how many here have experienced numerous disillusioning (but also "serendipitous") experiences which caused them to from that point onward question the "cult of expertise" and also question others' overwhelmingly-impressive testimonials.

...And rather, from then on, prioritize trust in their own real-life observations and experiences (sometimes synergistically sifting their observations with others' feedback.)

Because i myself have had several experiences throughout my life which led me to a 180-degree reversal of sole-trust in "experts" and in "impressive others".

----------------------

...At least one of my experiences was a providential "coincidence" at a desperate time in my life, where someone unwittingly offered me a fairly-accessible refereshing food which later turned out to be a lifesaver for me (as compared to prior experts both conventional & alternative, whose advice proved frustratingly useless or yucky).

...Another of my experiences was trial and error, based on truth that had hype mixed into it. I eventually cut to the truth, discarding the chaff.

...Yet another of my experiences was logical deduction (as per my most recent post elsewhere on the topic of flu).

All the latter were health related, and have led me to my current self-realization, I.E. what works best for me, with the tools i have access to, outside the parameters of what's touted "out there". Because while many may fit "one size" lots of the time - not everyone fits "one size" all of the time. Of course, if i'd had the means and stamina, I'd have attained much more of a self-realization by now, as I'd have had a chance to experience much more.

Comments (14)