Strikes me as too many colors - better to rethink even the door trim or do everything darker, plus putting in just one element of 'an older style' may be lost in the overall design if it doesn't naturally flow or make sense in the space. But please remember I can't see your kitchen and I'm only guessing at what you're referring to and its/their relation to other things nearby.

Ok thanks! I realized that boards from one of the big box stores didn't match the rest and the nano white is darker than the others.

Trim and cabinets don't have to match, but matching whites can be very challenging so it's often a smart choice to use the same color. I'd paint them Alabaster as well, it's a nice color

We have an old house. Much of the trim didn't match between the old 1850ish and the addition of 1889. No one ever noticed. If the size of the 2 trims don't compliment each other, that would be more of a giveaway.