It would be helpful if you were able to post pictures from different vantage points; that way, it would be possible to better understand the mass of the house, what else is around it, and get a more complete overall picture of how it sits on the lot. Right now the house facade reads rather one dimensionally, and the easiest way to change that would be to add a front porch. Can't say from the picture whether the porch should just be at the front door, or whether it should extend across more of the house and help to break up the wall. Removing the stone would definitely be something to consider, along with changing the front door to something more contemporary. Adding some taller trees to the right side of the house could also help to break up the perception of the wall.

We are wanting to paint the side on our house but leave the brick as is for economical reasons. I am stumped on what colors to choose that will also compliment the brown brick and roof. I am wanting to do a darker siding color and a light trim color. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciate!!

Lots of great folks on here can help. If you're looking to hire someone, this is a list of Certified Color Strategists who are taking new clients as of today: https://campchroma.com/certified-color-strategists/

Thank you all! I am really warming up to it now with the second coat and with the front windows revealed with the old trim. The old trim is pure white and seems too stark so I may go a softer white. Thanks for the photo @chloebud. That looks great! Originally I was thinking of doing the mailbox and door in a color called "urbane bronze" by Sherwin Williams but that might be too boring? I think we may want to do a "pop" of color for the new door instead - like a bright coral/terracotta color. It is Hawaii after all :-) Once again - I appreciate all of your feedback and comments. I never knew exterior colors could be so nerve wracking!