I've been following your experience with interest as I don't like shopping for clothes. Do you think you will continue with the Trunk program based on the two that have been chosen for you thus far?

Fun2B, I will probably keep with it-- at least for a trunk or two more-- it's really no cost to me as long as I find one thing I like in each box. I kept two items from the last box-- including a pair of shoes that I wouldn't have bought on my own. I didn't know the brand and while nice enough, the style was unremarkable. I wore them last week when it was a little warmer here and I ended up loving them--even more than I expected. I call that first trunk a win!

Where I've been disappointed is in the "styling" aspect of it. Some of the outfit pairings were ridiculous-- especially for work-- but that's not really what I am looking for from the program so I laugh it off and move on.

I would definitely recommend giving it a try-- again, you have nothing to lose as long as you like at least one item. And there are a number of ways to ensure you do get at least one item you like.

• I created a pinterest page with looks and items I like. It took a little time to put together but not really too much. I use a pinterest browser plug-in so if I see something I like, I just add it to my page.
• I send her links! I described an item that I wanted to try but complained that it was already sold out in my size on Nordstrom's site-- she told me to send a link because they have their own inventory. Sure enough, she was able to send it to me in this next box!
• Don't feel limited to the initial survey. I use the messaging system to let her know more about my likes and dislikes.
• Give your stylist a few boxes to get to know you-- and if you nix something in the initial review (before it is sent to you) or in your box, give good feedback as to why it didn't work. My own mother can't select clothing for me so I figure I need to give a stranger a few tries lol.
• Oh.. one more. You may want to start out with identifying a broad range of the kind of iems for them to send. I limit my items-- no purses, no jewelry -- but adding a broader range may give you a better selection to choose from. I do get a scarf in each trunk-- and so far, two pairs of shoes in each trunk.

My box was to arrive yesterday but it was delayed due to weather. It should arrive today so I will give you an update. I am not expecting a slam dunk but there are a number of items I am eager to try.

One other thing-- I can't tell you how much I have limited my stylist's reach. I mentioned no purses or jewelry above.. and there's also no dresses, no heels, no red, no yellows. On top of that, I am plus size so the options are already limited.

I guess what I am saying is don't measure your potential trunk based on what was sent to me.

Funky, I have to disagree about plus sizes. I'm a petite and the selection is far less.

I'm not understanding why she isn't listening to your suggestions.

Yes she should offer one or two items to get you out of your comfort zone and possibly something trendy, but the majority should be what YOU want and what you will wear.

The scarf looks close to your inspiration picture, so she nailed that.

To be honest, I think all of us here if assigned the task, could help you find clothing for your wardrobe. HDC loves shopping for our friends on here!

I am not sure what I said to make you think she isn't listening to my suggestions-- there are a number of items that reflect that she's done exactly that. I currently have issues typing/editing (post surgery) so maybe I cut something I meant to keep or such.

I asked for primarily work clothes + 1-2 items leisure wear. I also said I should expand my work wardrobe to include navy. I didn't share all her selections (due to length) but she sent:

• 2 pairs of navy pants
• 2 casual items-- I shirt, 1 sweater
• 1 jacket (I don't like-- but it was an add on after my review)
• 1 shell + 1 work shirt
• a number of items that are either cotton or a cotton blend (I complained about so many man-made fibers)
• 3 items directly off my pinterest page + 4 very similar to something I'd pinned

Again, my only real complaint is that her styling leaves a lot to be desired-- i.e. how she puts the items she selects together into outfits. Black shoes with navy pants.. loungewear with tailored work pants, etc. I find if comical.. not really a problem.

I DO get that petite offerings are limited-- but since I shop for my mom who is a petite size, I'll say that the options are similarly limited for plus size. A LOT of plus size clothing is very matronly-- or so oversized and shapeless. I am not really complaining-- it's my deal to struggle with-- but I shared that to explain that her options are more limited for me than they would be for a normal size range.

hahah .. love the idea of all of you guys shopping for me. But I think you might be discouraged by all the NOs I tell her. She's providing me with a service.. you all would be doing me a favor. I'd have a harder time telling you "no, that's too matronly.. no, that's just ugly" etc. :)

I like the scarf ok — but not for the office. I would wear (anddid order) the blue chevron one below it.

Well, I like the shoes. I actually have a pair of summer sandals similar to the black ones.

I’m not a scarf person, so I won’t comment although I think they are pretty on other people. I do like the one you ordered best. I like the white jacket and the white top, but as a rule, white jackets kind of drive me crazy. It’s usually the first thing I spill coffee on.

I ended up keeping two items… an Eileen Fisher sweater and a tunic length shirt. These were not items I'd expected to keep when I viewed my final trunk. One was just meh.. and the other I didn't expect to fit nicely. Boy was I wrong-- they both fit great and looked great.

THIS is the really benefit of trunk club for me-- it gets me to try on items/brands I wouldn't on my own. So far, all items I've kept (both trunks) were things I wouldn't have selected for myself.

Then it's worth it!

doesn't count if there's not pictures!

LOL ok-- I didn't share photos thinking I might bore you all with each of my purchases!

Also an update: Because I really liked one of the shirts, I asked if she could send me the same in white. She's sending me a "special" trunk with the tunic and also a jacket I had pinned. I've shared photos of the pieces I kept.. as well as the two new items coming next week.

This fits me very differently from the photo-- the neck scoops lower, and it is wider and shorter. I love it, everything falls perfectly and I think I could even make this work for the office with a black floral scarf.

I have been wearing this since 5am this morning-- first just the tunic, then with tights, now with jeans. It's a perfect "easy Saturday" shirt :

and I liked the coral (really orange) tunic so much, she is sending me the white one

And a bonus.. I returned a jacket because it was too casual but mentioned that I needed an easy style light rain/trench -- but I don't like traditional tailored trench coats. She's sending this one that I had pinned. I think it has potential-- It's going to be all about the fit and drape. It could go carefree but stylish -- or it could go dumpy. We'll see.

I'm a sucker for striped t's so the first is a winner for me. I found it interesting that the second is much more appealing for me in the picture of the white one over the coral. Something about it looking longer and more intentional than the coral one. The sleeves not rolled up may also help in my mind. (says the tall gal that feels that rolling up the cuffs is only done because the sleeves are too short!)

I like the coat too but totally get that the fit could make it go either way.

Thanks for sharing!

The first shirt is a lightweight sweater (Eileen Fisher)-- it's really a great transition piece and I could see wearing it on cool summer nights too.

I totally agree about the photos-- I don't like the sleeves rolled up-- but though the color is different than the photo, I really like it.

The tunic tops are cute but I really like the jacket. I hope it works for you.

PS - I am never bored by photos. Post away!

I like everything too! I would never buy a jacket that doesn't close. If it is cool enough to wear one, then I would want it to have a zipper or buttons to close it.

I like sweater in this style though. And I have worn my very thin ones walking to and fro.

oh no-- I am an idiot. I didn't even notice that the front doesn't close! I often wear my coats open-- but I'd like the option to close it!

I loved the back of the jacket which looks almost traditional but not quite... and I happen to know this model is much taller than I am. The jacket is 41`" so it should come just past my knees (I am 5'6")

Thanks all! It's been fun sharing!

Ohh I LOVE that jacket!

If you like the jacket(which I hope is as adorable as the picture,behave a cord loop sewn on the edge, and a good sized shell button on the other side, about where a double breasted button would be!

Or.....a hook and eye clasp.

That jacket looks great! I like the tops too.

Glad I finally spotted this thread. I was intrigued by your experience the first time around. Sounds like such a fun way to upgrade one's wardrobe. I'd totally give it a try if I could. That jacket is fun and I really like the tops she found for you. Cool shoes too! (I'd pair navy and black. Don't see it as a faux pas at all.)

Hope you're mending well, btw.

The new items should arrive tomorrow-- unless the trunk was held up in the snow storms between here and Iowa.

Another benefit of trunk club is that it makes returns soooo easy. Especially since I no longer drive. I simple complete the return online-- and I can schedule a UPS pickup right there too. I have a pile of boxes that need to be sent out with returns-- some from December!

And thanks, Tartan-- I am healing well. Slower than before but it's moving along. (However, I am pretty sure this isn't a 100% fix. It has me down--but maybe it's too early to know?)

Funky, a friend of mine uses Stitchfix. She gets a discount on the items that she keeps. I think there might also be a benefit to keeping all of it.

Do you get any discounts for the amount that you keep?.

She likes getting a surprise box in the mail. I think the majority goes back, but she enjoys what she keeps. And, like you, is is sometimes something that she would never have thought to buy.

I hope your vision is much improved once you're fully healed. Sending you good thoughts. Can imagine the whole thing must be pretty scary. :(

Eld. no extra discounts from Nordstrom-- but I did get an item at a reduced cost because it had gone on sale before it arrived. Also, I do get my fee back if I purchase something. I went with Trunk Club because I buy quite a bit from Nordstrom already-- and based on what I saw from others, Stitch Fix didn't seem to be my style.

Thanks again for your sweet wishes, Tartan! <3 I am to the point that I am not all that scared-- I mean, I have been living with this for a few years. It's frustrating but I know I can survive and manage ok even if it isn't fixed. That said, it IS limiting-- and expensive between ubers and deliveries and surgeries and glasses-- so I hope it IS the fix.

I am so impressed with being able to get clothing so painlessly! I so agree about the 2 tunics. I would never have looked twice at them but seeing the white one, I am really liking it!

I hope you heal well- and I hope all the future boxes are hits!!! Thank you for sharing and definitely we enjoy your photos!

I discovered another perk-- great customer service! I accidentally failed to return one of the items I meant to return. TOTALLY my fault. I got a note today letting me know and adding:

Intended to keep this item?

No problem! We'll automatically bill you on 02/24/19.

Didn't mean to keep this?

Reply to this email by 02/23/19 and we'll take care of you!

I did get the second trunk-- the jacket is darling. I really like the style of it-- but it is very lightweight. Much lighter than your typical trench. I need to decide if I would wear it. When others would use such a light jacket, i'd likely go without.

My stylist just sent my third trunk selections to review-- I did nix 3 of the 12 items but 1 of them was a lovely pair of tory burch flats that I already knew didn't fit me well. I really liked or loved everything else. If it all fits, I'll likely keep them all!