I'm cracking up because of the number of colors you have tried. I'm the same way when it comes to finding the perfect option for just about anything. Maybe you are simply looking to have fun with color and want more than two colors on your house, but I like to make gutters as inconspicuous as possible. So, I would probably paint the fascia the same color as the window trim and gutters and the soffit either the same color as the house or the same color as the fascia. The sandy accent color is nice, though. If you don't mind the gutter being more noticeable (or change them to match the fascia color), you could paint the fascia Ponytail and the soffit Navajo Red.

sorry jeff,,I don't believe that's cathedral on that house. it's very close tho...there is not info on the color of the house w/that picture. grab a sample and try it out. that's not an actual paint color,,its the color of siding. sorry! I posted it for how good it looked w/the coloring you have.

You need to come up with a whole house plan for color. I would find an outdoor rug you really like and pull colors from there. And vinyl takes paint great and it lasts. Since you like the White House color, you could use the colors from the rug for accents.

Paint the walls the same color as the trim in eggshell finish