Allison - the detail on your mirror is just gorgeous! I'd like to find something similar, but perhaps in an oval shape, given the angles of the vanity. I very much like your sconces also. Thanks so much for posting pics. It helps me visualize my space much better. Thank you, brutuses. This little vanity was purchased on ebay and shipped to me last February! It's been sitting in a crate for most of the year waiting for my much delayed remodel. Was it you who was also converting an antique dresser into a bath vanity? If so, I remember your picture and it was just what I wanted, but unfortunately that style was too big for my space.

It's all great except for the towel ring! (And the roller shade, but you've addressed that!) Very pretty room. I bet my windowless powder room is even smaller than yours ;) If I were you, I'd ditch the towel ring and put a very simple hook centered under the window, and use fingertip towels instead of full-size hand towels. We have little hooks for towels in all of our bathrooms. I wouldn't get too decorative with it, just a simple hook that doesn't come out too far from the wall. I am also a fan of window film. There are lots of options online, from basic etched glass to more decorative patterns. In your case, I'd go simple.

I agree with the suggestions to retain as many of the original fixtures as possible. I love period bathrooms (especially early 1900s) so much that I bought 2 old medicine cabinets off of eBay, very much like yours, when we were having our house built. The mirrors aren't perfect, but that just adds to the charm IMO. And as already noted, in your case it wouldn't be the primary mirror in that bathroom. For above the sink, I think an apothecary mirror would look great. For a small bathroom, one toilet paper storage option is to put extra roles on the handle of a plunger. We keep a plunger in our powder bathroom, and I painted the handle (it used to be bright yellow) the same white as our walls and use that to store extra rolls. It tucks into the corner so kind of disappears unless you're looking for it. Just an idea that might work for some.

@Beth you have given me so many ideas to move forward with, thank you!! :D I think urbane bronze is great, i would looooove a pendant light but I'm not too sure how hard it would be to change from the recessed lighitng that's in there currently. I think it's sort of worth doing the work. As for the celoing, maybe that's where I put my real statement! lots to think about ...:)