I would go for the solid color.

I vote for the solid colour one too, only because I'd be afraid that the whiteness of the second set wouldn't go with the cream of the kitchen cabinets. I also prefer the chairs of the solid set. they go better with your sideboard. Just check that the undertones of the two greys (dining set and wall) are similar - they seem like they would work together at least on my screen.

Thanks! I think i'll go with the solid color too, I love the white but im afraid the finish will bother me... and the solid color is more neutral and I can always accessorize..

:)

The solid color looks much nicer to my eyes and will have longer staying power than the distressed white finish, IMO.

Solid

These types of decisions can be tricky sometimes. Since the walls are already two tone, we would suggest going with a single solid color for your table selection. Good luck!

Flooring is a warm coffee, or red-dish brown? Idk about the white then, as said, with other contrasts and such already there...

The solid color is going to look best next to your orange wall.

I gotta say, I reeeaalllly dislike the "distressed" finish on the two-tone table. There's distressed, and then there's "we just aren't trying," and that one looks like the latter. The solid color one suffers from none of that, and looks like it will look good with the orange wall. Though I like JudyG's suggestions, too.

Thanks all for commenting. I agree the X trestle shape kind of look busy... I found another table but unsure if it would be too big! ahhh decisions! lol. I posted in a new thread: https://www.houzz.com/discussions/would-this-dinning-table-be-too-big-dsvw-vd~5457566

Thanks :)))