Green or White kitchen, hard decision.
Janet
5 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (48)
lucky998877
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years agoRelated Discussions
Decisions, decisions..Mother of Pearl vs. White Macubas Smackdown
Comments (12)So hard to decide. I love MP. I have MP. I love LdL too, but for me it seemed too cold and modern. I wanted a modern farmhouse vibe, so I needed more warmth which MP provided. I actually did walnut perimeter cabinets and painted island( a flip flop to your plan) which made it easier I think. The MP looks stellar on the walnut cabinets and on the painted(olive) island cabinetry, but IMO walnut countertop wouldn't look good on walnut cabinets so if I had down a walnut cabinetry island I wouldn't have considered wood there. I think that means I don't like your option 1 with the smaller island with wood cabinets and wood countertop-sorry) My original plan was MP on perimeter and walnut bb on island, but because I also have post and beam structural elements it seemed like too much going on so I simplified and went with a single countertop surface, all MP. I am quite happy with that choice- ecstatic actually. You are trying to make a lot of choices and thinking about alot of scenarios. I can tell you what I would do, but it might be better to figure out which stone you love and then, as Tim Gunn says, "Make it work" even if that means re-jiggering some of your other ideas. If you consider all your elements and potential elements and then figure out what you must have then you will know what to do or at least where to start. Now to add to the confusion, some things that popped into my head: Stainless backsplash behind stove would also look great. Where you have stainless countertop next to oven, you could alternatively do walnut butcherblock with embedded stainless steel heat bars. This would put the walnut on the white cabinetry which I think would look lovely. The island eating area and the eating area behind the sink could be butcherblock and everything else could be stone. Definitely go look at more quartz options to go with the MP. Think about which of the tones in the MP you would want to bring out, there is gray green gold, mine has purple streaks too. Would the Pebble go with the MP?...See MoreKitchen Renovation...Decisions, Decisions!!!
Comments (5)I recommend instead a Blanco Silgranit sink over the Americast. You can do a search on this forum and find all the enthusiastic lovers of their Silgranit sinks. Especially those with hard water who dislike the water marks on stainless, have converted to Blanco Silgranit sinks. Americast can chip if you bang a heavy pot on it. Silgranit is granite composite, made up of 80% granite, with the durability of granite. It won't chip or scratch. Silgranit comes in several colors from very light to very dark. Since you are thinking of an enameled cast iron sink also, I am assuming you want a sink in the white family. Check out the Silgranit in biscuit, which is a creamy white. I'll link a thread below with pics. If you want a white-white, there was also a thread just posted of a white silgranit sink which I will link. Silgranit sinks come in many sizes. Also think long and hard about whether you want a single-bowl or double-bowl sink. How wide will your sink be? Last comment - be careful about buying a sink from your contractor, only because contractors usually charge a middle-man markup, which they should, since they are doing the work of ordering, etc. But that may make your sink significantly more expensive than if you bought it yourself, especially if you buy online. I'm not saying your contractor is definitely going to do that, but I would ask him how much he will charge you for the sink, and check his price against what it would cost to buy it yourself at a place like Home Depot, or online. Thread with Pics of Silgranit sink in biscuit Thread about White Silgranit Sink All about Silgranit This post was edited by shannonplus2 on Sun, Feb 10, 13 at 13:24...See MoreI'm back! Living Room decisions - plate rail & green paint!
Comments (13)Hi Nutmegxo. I see why you're attracted to those last pictures. The fresh colors & nice workmanship make those rooms seem very attractive. However, you say that your house is a center hall Colonial, and those wall treatments derive from Mission and Arts & Crafts style house of the early 1900s, where the whole idea was to create a completely different--a more modern--feel than the Colonial houses of the century before. Oh, sure, you can mix styles all up--people do it all the time--but while a mix of different furniture styles in a single house can work out just fine, a mix of architectural feaures cobbled together from different styles in different centuries isn't often a success, especially when, as in a center hall plan, each room is clearly visible from the other. Normal size doorways with doors that close allow you to sneak the odd painted room into a house full of stained wood, or add an Art Deco bathroom to a Tudor manse, but the typical broad doorways in Colonial Revival houses make using different architectural styles in adjacent rooms a dicier proposition. That's the thinking behind some of the posters' suggestion above. Let's take a closer look at that blue room you posted. Pretty colors, that's for sure. But there are a few things that show somebody missed the bus. One of the things that bothers me is that the door looks like a generic six-panel door out of the Big Box store. These days, six-panel doors are as ubiquitous as were hollow-core slab doors when I was growing up in the 196Os, and like those doors, these are often used where they don't belong. A six-panel door in a modern house or contemporary condo is every bit as out-of-place as a slab door in a Federal style house, and just because they're easy to find (and some people see them as 'nicer' than cheap hollow core doors) doesn't make them suitable. Even if we assume that whever combined a door style from 1760 with a wall treatment from 1900 knew exactly what they were doing--and I'm not at all sure that's the case--they still missed an opportunity to do it well. Look at the door's cross-member. Now look at the upper horizontal on the wall. How hard would it have been to raise that wall molding four inches so it would align with the lines of the door? Or, if instead of painting the door all white, they really wanted to feature the [mismatched] door, why didn't they space the wall's moldings to match the panels on the door? Doing that could have allowed the blue to flow unbroken across the door's lower panels, better integrating the door into the overall look of the room. But instead of going to the hassle of finding a more approriate period-style door--either a five-panel model with stacked horizontals, or a three-panel model with one square panel above two vertical panels--or, if this wall treatment is new, adjusting it to match the door's proportions, they just took the easy no-thought middle course, buying & hanging a generic door with little thought given to how to better relate it to the other features in the room. Those kind of details are the things that, thought about early enough in the process, can make a a huge difference in the final results, and they often cost no more than doing things the same way everybody else does them and coming up with the same predictable results. Good design isn't about money, it's about thinking. But these days, all it takes is a pretty coat of paint to make a lot of people think a room is well-designed. M....See MoreMy turn for BS help - White cottage kitchen dark green granite
Comments (19)island, I agree with you. I came to that realization today that I don't have the room for any special treatment behind the range since it has a back to it and there will be a vent hood going in so there is just not that much space available. I was trying to figure out how to get a center medallion of a cat! I know, too taste specific. DH suggested a piece of our granite but enough of that. So today I am trying to determine since the hood is not yet installed how much in height I really need behind the stove and if I can get away with simply raising the pieces behind the stove rather than running behind the stove down to the counter to avoid a seam. I found three different web sites with this type of tile but no selection of just one tile in different heights, just 8x20, 12x24 or the wall height which might work if it is tall enough to allow me to cut it in half because most of the wall I would need 18 high (the space from the counter to the bottom of the wall cabs) except for behind the stove. Silly me, I never considered a grout line, I thought they were just glued to the wall and simply lined up vertically! I have a lot to learn and I have to do more research. And yes, it does look great in that hallway but you know what I thought of when I saw it, it would take DH just one drop of the vacuum to break a tile. Silly me . . I'm still stressed over this whole affair even though I have a working sink finally after 8 weeks and tonight I am making my first home cooked meal - ravioli and meatballs and garlic bread. :-) mpagmom, your kitchen is SO BEAUTIFUL and I saw it today with those gorgeous tiles. What a calming space - I love it! That stove wall is a work of art and I do think the smaller tiles go great with the stove wall tiles. I hope you are enjoying your new space. Thank you for the link. Yes, I am planning on going with the beadboard tile. DH is against subways (although I love them) and I couldn't talk him in to an exposed brick look. I think the plainer backsplash would be very complementary to the granite. I can add more color with window valances or countertop accessories and an area rug. I noticed in SusieQ's beautiful kitchen that there is no top or bottom to the tile but you can buy "caps" or finishing ends on the tile web sites. Does anyone think that is necessary? Probably a picture of my stove wall would help. THANK YOU!...See MoreRita / Bring Back Sophie 4 Real
5 years agoUser
5 years agokelleg69
5 years agoRita / Bring Back Sophie 4 Real
5 years agoLavender Lass
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years agoMiranda33
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agolucky998877
5 years agoJanet
5 years agocatbuilder
5 years agoJennifer K
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years agoAnglophilia
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years agoJanet
5 years agosprtphntc7a
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoMissi (4b IA)
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoMissi (4b IA)
5 years agofriedajune
5 years agolast modified: 5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJules
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years ago1929Spanish-GW
5 years agoaprilneverends
5 years ago1929Spanish-GW
5 years agoJanet
5 years ago1929Spanish-GW
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoH202
5 years agoartemis_ma
5 years agoriverrat1
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoHal Braswell Consulting
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years agoJanet
5 years ago
Related Stories
MOST POPULARIs This the Year Blue and Green Kitchen Cabinets Edge Out White?
Neutrals still dominate cabinet color. But some of the most popular recent kitchens on Houzz tell a different story
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNSeeing Green: Some Kitchens Ditch White for Mother Nature’s Neutral
It’s typically the primary color in gardens. Now green is having a moment in the kitchen
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNHow to Keep Your White Kitchen White
Sure, white kitchens are beautiful — when they’re sparkling clean. Here’s how to keep them that way
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Red Energizes a Functional White Kitchen
A client’s roots in the Netherlands and desire for red countertops drive a unique design
Full StoryKITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: A Storage-Savvy White Kitchen in the Trees
A smart layout and space-saving storage make this Canadian kitchen feel larger than it is
Full StoryKITCHEN OF THE WEEKKitchen of the Week: Graphic Floor Tiles Accent a White Kitchen
Walls come down to open up the room and create better traffic flow
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Oyster Is the New White
A designer whips up a leafy green, celery and off-white palette inspired by garden views
Full StoryKITCHEN CABINETSNew This Week: 4 Not-White Kitchens With Character
See how cabinets in gray, pale green, light wood and inky blue bring character and dimension to their spaces
Full StoryCOLOR14 Ways to Bring Blue-Green Into Your Kitchen
Get ideas for infusing your kitchen with a refreshing shade of teal, aqua or turquoise
Full StoryKITCHEN COUNTERTOPS5 Countertops That Look Beautiful in a Green Kitchen
Get ideas for countertop colors and materials that complement green cabinetry
Full Story
Miranda33