New granite, old tile backsplash?

6 years ago

last modified: 6 years ago

Will it look too dated to use the existing Daltile, 4X4 oatmeal colored tile with polished Bordeaux granite? The tiles are a flat glaze. I was thinking of keeping them and grouting them with same colored grout instead of the existing white grout. The new cabinets are a color called "Hazel Maple" and are an olive color. The floor is pretty busy with Cali Bamboo Vinyl Aged Hickory. I know I need to keep the backsplash a solid color, but need some advice.

Featured Answer

PRO

Beth H. :

6 years ago

you're going through all the cost and hassle of replacing everything in that kitchen, but want to keep those old Dal Tiles?

sorry,,,if you like that color, then do a more modern subway or glass tile. that particular tile you have reminds me of shower tile. it will do nothing to enhance your new items.

I'd do a very pale sage glass tile to work w/your olive cabs.

2x8 Loft Sage glass tile

https://tilebar.com/loft-sage-2x8-polished-glass-tiles.html

or something like these longer subways in a vanilla or ivory tone

Lancaster Vanilla ceramic

i even like this herringbone layout w/this Byzantine Blanco yes, it's similar color as yours, but it's a much more up to date look

all of these are on tilebar. they will send you 5 samples for $5

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (16)

PRO
NOMI - Luxury Bathroom Remodel
6 years ago
More details would be a great help, what is the door style? Shaker? Raised panel? flat? What is the house style?

We have a few suggestions to share, but frankly, it's hard to address the question with so many missing factors (BTW - depends on your home style, we wouldn't necessarily use solid colors :)

Backsplash - mint
https://www.glasstileoasis.com/ming-green-light-ds-58-green-diamond-stone-polished-tile-259.html?gclid=EAIaIQobChMI55KrsYvY2gIVWbbACh3tgQpzEAQYCCABEgJkwfD_BwE

https://www.flooranddecor.com/glass-decoratives/sea-island-glass-mosaic-100463231.html#start=25

https://www.flooranddecor.com/glass-decoratives/metallico-glass-and-copper-chevron-mosaic-100287911.html#start=39

Good luck!

Joseph & Berry
Indulge Yourself.
cindycrutsinger thanked NOMI - Luxury Bathroom Remodel
PRO
Carolina Kitchen & Bath
6 years ago
Post pictures so we can get a better idea of what you're working with. My first instinct, however, is to say no. Go with a new backsplash and you'll enjoy your new counters more!
cindycrutsinger thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
Related Discussions
3' granite backsplash needed if plan to tile backsplash kitchen?
Q
Comments (5)
With a granite backsplash, you'll still have a seam so it defeats the purpose stated by that granite guy. Only time I see tile over a 3" granite backsplash is when they are done at different times (change in homeowners or you decide to add tile in the future). Most people getting new counters will just tile from the counter up.
...See More
x-post black granite tiles new backsplash
Q
Comments (8)
The tile guy came and made some suggestions based on the space and the 7 outlets. I then went to a very nice tile showroom. The saleswoman was incredibly helpful. Given the size of the area and more importantly the fact that we keep the toaster, coffee machine etc on the counter (and that won't ever change) she helped me decide on simple is better. So I have decided to go with a 2x4 crema marfil in a bricked pattern. I am still thinking about adding a liner just below the outlets to add something. Any suggestions? TIA, kelly
...See More
Old tile to new subway tile on backsplash
Q
Comments (13)
This is great, thanks so much for the feedback about the soapstone. I think I was worried that it might chop up the space too much, having the tile go all the way to the counter on either side. But the feedback so far seems to really support the idea that it goes well under the window.
...See More
Kitchen refresh: my New DIY matte/glossy backsplash and busy granite
Q
Comments (17)
Someone posted a reveal recently, confessing that she felt a bit unsure about her results, especially her BS. I know the feeling. I feel as if I've betrayed the prime directive when I see my BS paired with the counter. But my DH loves that granite so much, and I decided to get the BS I was going to see from the livingroom couch. And, yes amyfgib, my mare is the color of my lower cabinets and my gelding is white, brown and black. :) Thanks to all for your posts. It really is a kindness to take the time to tell a stranger they have a pretty BS.
...See More
cindycrutsinger
Original Author
6 years ago
PRO
Carolina Kitchen & Bath
6 years ago
There's nothing special about that backsplash and it would be one of the first things I noticed when I came in the room. "Why didn't she go ahead and replace the splash, too?" is what I'd ask myself.
cindycrutsinger thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
cindycrutsinger
Original Author
6 years ago
cindycrutsinger
Original Author
6 years ago
There is a lot of movement in the floor and granite. What would you use?
AC LB
6 years ago
I think your current backsplash blends beautifully with the granite and flooring you’re going with. I didn’t realize it was an option to keep the current backsplash when replacing a countertop. I figured it would ruin the backsplash. Good luck!
kariyava
6 years ago
It looks like the backsplash coordinates well with your other pictures. I would keep it if it isn't damaged when the counters come out. If you decide you don't like it after you get everything else in, you can always replace it.
cindycrutsinger thanked kariyava
PRO
Carolina Kitchen & Bath
6 years ago
Kariyava brings up a good point, the counters might not come out leaving the backsplash undamaged. Build replacing the backsplash into your budget...in case.
cindycrutsinger thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
Susan Church
6 years ago
The color combination seems bland and muddy to me. It would be helpful to know what your cabinets are. I would probably replace with something crispy and contrasting, maybe pick up the lightest cream color from the granite. If you don't replace and there is a gap between counter and backsplash, you can always use pencil tiles. I did this and it solved the problem as well as adding another design element. Pencil tile found on Houzz, but ordered from manufacturer for much less.
cindycrutsinger thanked Susan Church
maree85
6 years ago
I have the same Bordeaux granite. I think your existing tile looks fine with all you have. Love the color of your cabinets. When I put my granite in, I had planned to keep the same backsplash but ended up removing it and putting a new one in because the installer told me the current BS was going to have to be cut at the bottom in order to fit the granite in. It would have looked awful so I decided it had to go.
cindycrutsinger thanked maree85
cindycrutsinger
Original Author
6 years ago
So far, all your ideas have been great. I realized that the present laminate countertop my not be the same thickness of the granite from your posts, Budgeting a backsplash is probably inevitable. However, I like the understated tile look for the backslash, so ideas for a solid color really helps. It is quite dusty out here with dirt roads so texture that will catch the dust may not be helpful. This kitchen is part of a great room so I can brighten it up as I decorate the living room area, right?
User
6 years ago
Penny wise, pound foolish. You’re not doing demo without ripping that out too.
cindycrutsinger thanked User
PRO
Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center
6 years ago
Yes, the advice above is great, go for a solid color for the backsplash (I love subway tile idea) and you can definitely brighten up the look along the way as you decorate. Make sure to love your choices and enjoy your kitchen.
cindycrutsinger thanked Aqua Kitchen and Bath Design Center
PRO
Prime Ohio Real Estate
6 years ago
Yes agree with replacing the backsplash.
I am also going with Typhoon Bordeaux granite (similar to yours). My wife wants a brick lane tiles for backsplash, though I think subway tiles in light green would complement nicely. We have gray/green stained island with dark espresso stained perimeter cabinets. Kitchen Walls will be SW Garden Sage color
cindycrutsinger thanked Prime Ohio Real Estate