I would use one of the lighter colors from the stone (greyish?) and possibly a dark slate for trim. I would also remove the shutters. Could we see a closer pic of the porch?

I would take one of the colors in the stone and go with it, with a another color for the shutters. Like the red door. I think one of the paint manufacturers has a website that can show you what your home would look like with your selection.

Shutters vs Shudders

^Brief article written by an architect about shutters

It is common on a house with stone to paint the siding a tone from the stone. I would do that but much darker. Don't worry about the roof color, everything goes with black.

Paint the storm door to match your door.

At the risk of being Miss Boring 2018, if it were really mine I do believe I'd paint it white and put colour on the shutters. No shutters on the bay window.

Thanks everyone! Here are some pictures of the stone up close

If it were mine, I would beef up the posts and get rid of the hedges.

Agree regarding beefing up the posts. Then the darkest grey stone for main house, lightest grey for trim and no shutters. Extending your front porch out a few feet would add more curb appeal.

Nice color choices from kat...and SW. ;-) I kind of like Big Chill for the siding with a darker color (such as Shade-Grown) on the shutters. With the long, low-ish roof I would want a lighter siding color.

Agree...no shutters on the bay window. Just no sense to it.

Very cool @katinparadise!

Good! It may help you narrow down your choices.

I think the siding would be nice in a neutral putty-type color, and a darker slate-type color for the trim. I too would remove the shutters, which I sort of feel badly about because they are so common for the age and style of home and I hate pulling period appropriate details. Those hedges are so appropriate for this house, too. Love them.

JC some people choose the grout color.