I like the Timberline Weathered Wood. I think it will compliment the stone and not compete with the grey. I have Timberline on my roof and am happy with them. But Driftwood would work as well.

You might get a larger sample of the roofing materials and look at it outside with your stone and paint sample. Depending on which way you house faces, there could be a difference. See if there is another house in your area with the same roof.

Thank you so much, I like the texture and pattern of the Timberline, I have concerns about it being more brown. I know things can vary by lots. Good suggestion- about looking for someone in my area.

I am glad you chimed! please chime. Which Architectural shingle do you recommend ?--I am not married to any particular style at this point, I would prefer one with more dimension and a lifetime warranty...and in the right color.

Certainteed also has a service whereby if you open an account, send them a photo of your house and tell them what shingles you are considering. They will superimpose them on your house and email you back the photo. It really helps

Can you post a photo of the house? Or is this a new home?

Here is weathered wood in the Certainteed architectural slate series.

Personally, I went with weathered wood. I thought weathered wood was driftwood, so when it was installed I was confused why it was lighter than I thought! My mistake, but it doesn't look bad at all! My house it a deep tan brick.

Personally I think a darker roof looks better under any circumstances. If I replaced it again, I would 100% go black.

As per manufacturer, I went with IKO Cambridge as I preferred the look of their shingle. My roofer offered GAF Timberline. My neighbors went with GAF. I personally find the GAF shingle to look very fake (take that as you will).

No issues so far, installed summer 2011, this spring in Toronto we had a record breaking wind storm, at least 60% of homes in the subdivision lost shingles, mine as well as my neighbors were luck and sustained no damage (both IKO and GAF).

My neighbor across the road lost half her roof. Took her 3 months to pick a new shingle. She even sent the roofers away when they brought the first set of shingles as she had a change of heart. At the end she went with GAF Timberline in black. This was after months of research and looking at every roof in the neighborhood!

Hi! Curious what your final decision was?! I am going through the same decision.

I have been struggling with a roof color as well have contractors here and under the gun but I believe I have finally decided on Certainteed landmark pro Max Def in “Driftwood”. Driftwood is a darker roof than the other line I was looking at which was Timberline in Weathered wood which was too brown for me. Driftwood is darker but very neutral and softer looking then some roofs that have more black in them. It is not BROWN by any means but has hints of it in the color which I think makes it more neutral and not in your face like a black roof.

*Just a note after looking at and touching the actual shingles from timberline that my neighbor gave me left over from his roof I ultimately decided to go with Certainteed landmark pro, much higher quality. The timberline shingles were cracking just from moving them from one spot to another so having that actual shingle in hand helped a lot. I’m all about quality and will pay more for it.

I’d def do CertainTeed Pro or Premium shingles. Best quality

My roof goes on in 2 weeks and I haven't selected the color! It is a toss up between GAF Timberline Weathered Wood and Certainteed Landmark Driftwood. (just regular Landmark) I was wondering if the Certainteed was DARKER than the Timberline, and I think that "Century 21" might have just answered this? Is it substantially darker? Sometimes it looks nice and dark, other times it seems GRAY...... Is my vision off? I want a black"ish" with cool brown ..... help!!