Houzz Logo Print
petalique

TURNIP - Rutabaga question

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

I have a few questions and comments.

How many here like, love or dislike these vegetables?

While I don't seek it out, I will eat it if it's part of a meal. (Fussy or rude diners can be annoying.)

I have friends that greatly dislike turnip (henceforth I'm saying "turnip" to include rutabaga).

I'm going to a post Thanksgiving pot-luck Thanksgiving and my friend who hosts it says he hates turnip. He's a good cook and seldom picky or fussy (although these days with a large gathering of friends, there are a good many with strong dislikes or dietary rules and restrictions.

This friend has a good sense of humor. Along with some savory and acceptable dishes, I'm feeling like exploring. I bought a 5 to 6" rutabega yesterday and would appreciate some ideas on how to make it acceptable for those who either like it, or who are willing to give an open minded taste to this ancient low carb vegetable.

I can put it on the snack - appetizer table. I'd like to do a preparation beyond the conventional mashed with butter and potato. Any idea?

Maybe combined with ??? In a savory galette?

I spotted a video of a cook making an Indian spiced turnip. Hmm. No one will be pestered into eating the dish.

My family enjoys most food, DH having a few frank dislikes. I enjoy just about everything short of raw brain. I would like to see more people be open to at least RE-Trying foods which they've closed the door to.

Thanks and I wish all of you a happy Thanksgiving and gathering together.

EDIT-- to correct spelling

Re-Edit: Oops! Right the first time -- Rutabaga ((aka Swede))

Comments (18)

  • 8 years ago

    Interesting question :-)) I like rutabagas a lot but do not care for turnips (or parsnips).

    FWIW, I wouldn't do a rutabaga raw. It's hard to begin with and I don't think the flavor is as good as when cooked. Kinda like eating a raw potato - some like 'em; most do not. And preparing them is much the same as you would with a potato as well

    If not as a mash (my favorite method), then I would roast them. A little drizzle of olive oil, S&P, a bit of garlic if you like and some rosemary. Or as a gratin. I've also seen them combined with sweet potatoes in a casserole/gratin. But other than mashed, I usually just include them in soups and stews.

    In my family, we refer to them as neeps........it's that UK background :-)

    petalique thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, gardengal48,

    I am going to explore these two vegetables. I will slice the rutabaga then peel the wax off it. Maybe I'll try your recipe for the 'baga.

    in searching GW Cooking, I came across Plllog's recipe for turnip chips. Maybe I can find some small flat turnips and make chips. If I wanted to make some fried Pringles like chips for the appetizer table, would I par cook before frying?

    Any seasoning of spice to go w that presentation (finger food chip snack)? Thin dusting of garam masala & sea salt?

    I can always fall back on Pumkin Pie Spice Sardines.

  • Related Discussions

    A stupid turnip question.

    Q

    Comments (6)
    I KNEW somebody would call me on that! LOL. They are planted for better or worse, smarter or stupider (more stupid?) I slipped in the mud, landed on my elbow and tore my rotator cuff. I blame all my mistakes on the pain meds today. No excuse for previous.
    ...See More

    Question for GLIB - Hakurei turnips

    Q

    Comments (2)
    In the end I did not have that many, and also in the last few years I have been eating far more root vegetables than in the past. I ate them all in a month, so I can vouch for one month in refrigerator type conditions (my garage, in a plastic tote, close to 100% humidity and below 40F).
    ...See More

    Turnips and rutabagas

    Q

    Comments (11)
    goatster, it depends on the temperature of your crawl space. I have one, but it's far too warm to store vegetables there. My root cellar stays between 45 and 50 degrees, give or take a degree, which frankly is a little warmer than I like it. It's been there before I was born, though, and has always served its purpose so I guess it will be fine. I don't think a simple cover is going to protect them from rats and mice, mice seem to be able to get into, under and over nearly everything. Controlling the rodent problem is a better answer, if you have such a problem. I'm assuming you are freezing the vegetables if you are talking about blanching? To cool quickly after blanching just dunk them into ice water, then let drain and freeze. Good luck, I think turnips and rutabagas, along with cabbage, are some of the most under utilized crops available to us. Annie
    ...See More

    turnips, rutabagas, and pasties redux

    Q

    Comments (2)
    Beef suet is what I have always used (the firm stuff from around the kidneys)and it is really easy to handle. I have never tried lard but since suet is so difficult to come by now, I am going to do it. DH will be so happy. Thanks for the info.
    ...See More
  • 8 years ago

    I dice turnips/rutabagas and cook them in boiling salted water until just tender. Put in a buttered casserole. Make a béchamel sauce, adding cheddar cheese, a pinch of nutmeg (and an optional pinch of cayenne or drops of hot sauce.) - pour over the cooked turnips. Top with buttered crumbs. Bake until brown and bubbly.

    petalique thanked seagrass_gw Cape Cod
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    My favorite way to have turnips is tempura, but they have to be served hot and with a dipping sauce. They do not microwave that well and are better if reheated in an oven.

    You can also make them in a pakora/samosa or pierogi/piroshki.

    petalique thanked Lars
  • 8 years ago

    Just dice a rutabaga large, drizzle a little oil on, and roast as you would potato chunks. Season however you like or leave them plain.

    Use a sharp knife. They're harder and denser than potatoes. People often substitute rutabagas (also called Swedes) for potatoes, but you have to be familiar with the relative differences to make it come out right in most recipes.

    Re fried turnip chips, I've never done that. They're more comparable to carrots than potatoes, though less sweet. That is, hard and not very starchy. I'd slice very fine, and perhaps freeze first, but that's a wild guess. If you try it, do report back.

    BTW, my roasted turnip chips with cheddar are delicious, but they do taste like turnips to a certain extent. If someone really dislikes turnips, rather than turnip dishes grandma made or similar, he probably won't like them. Though, good! More for everyone else. :)

    petalique thanked plllog
  • 8 years ago

    I cut small turnips (NOT rutabagas) into eight wedges and simmer with a little water and a spoonful of sugar until they are tender, the water has evaporated and they are a bit caramelised. Add a little bit of butter, salt and pepper and enjoy!

    petalique thanked colleenoz
  • 8 years ago

    I like them all, the turnips, the rutabaga and the parsnips. Parsnips were usually par boiled then fried in butter, a horrible thing to do to a nice healthy root vegetable, but I still do it. I also add them to stews, I roast them and I have a recipe for parsnip muffins that are a lot like carrot cake muffins.

    I like turnips and rutabaga best boiled and mashed with butter. I also like them in pot roast and it's not a Upper Peninsula pasty without a rutabaga. And no, you can't substitute carrots, it's heresy. (grin)

    I make glazed rutabaga too, just like glazed carrots. Peel, dice and cook the rutabaga, glaze with brown sugar and orange juice, add a little soy sauce if you like, reduce until the sauce is thick and sticky.

    Annie

    petalique thanked annie1992
  • 8 years ago

    Rutabaga is my favourite vegetable. I've been known to eat it on its own and call it dinner but I really only like it one way. It must be boiled in salted water, & mashed with a bit of butter. I'll add fresh ground pepper once it's on my plate. My mother used to add brown sugar, but I don't like the extra sweetness.

    petalique thanked sherri1058
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Oh, well, stews... all kinds of root vegetables are good in stews! I'll put any of them in a regular beef stew, or many others. Peppi's (I think hers) recipe for chicken and dumplings has parsnips. It's very different and the best ever if you like a little kick. I never liked the old carrots and prunes tsimmis, but for Passover I'll make one with celeriac, rutabaga, turnip, parsnip carrot, and onions, plus whatever else is walking by, macerated mixed dried fruit, sautéed in wine. Wonderful! The celeriac, rutabaga, parsnip and turnips stand up really well to the sweetness of the fruit. While they have their own interior sweetness, it's not sugary like carrots, and they all have a lot of actual, distinguishable flavor.

    petalique thanked plllog
  • 8 years ago

    I love rutabega!...my favorite way is roasted with butternut squash and onion. Toss with a very little bit of olive oil....salt and pepper, in a sheet pan, toss often and when they are getting soft, add some butter....and maybe some apple slices!
    Or just cubed and steamed.
    My mother boiled them and mashed them and I hated them....went to a friend's house and her mother serveds teamed and cubed with gravy!!

    petalique thanked lindac92
  • 8 years ago

    Wow! All of you have been so kind to respond with such interesting recipes and information, especially at this very busy time. Wish we could do a sort of "pub crawl" -- a tour of various Cooking forum members' kitchens and dining tables. That would be so interesting and delectable.

    Clearly, I'm going to have to try more than one recipe! They all sound so delicious. I am supposed to not partake of so many yummy foods and additions -- like sodium, saturated fats, oils, carbohydrates, yadda yadda. A few holidays can be exceptions, I hope. I dearly love cheeses, carmelized anything, salt, fats, just about any food (include desserts and drinks).

    I love the idea of cooking the turnips - rutabaga (begge) with apples, cheese, butter and freshly grated nutmeg. And when I hear the descriptor "chips" or "tempura," I melt. Lars, we must talk tempura sometime. A few years ago I played around with trying out tempura-like batters. I could tempura my fingernails and find them delicious.

    There are a few Asian and Vietnamese restaurants around that serve calimari in a sort of rice flour based tempura batter -- fried! Then served with a high sodium sauce or vinaigrette or "salad." I was getting close to being able to duplicate some of these, when some doc put a flea in my ear and suggested I desist. And I'd just discovered an affordable restaurant that served fantastic peppercorn calimari -- salt and pepper tender fried calimari on a fragrant picant salad of shredded greens and tomatoes. I took a photo of it (Yes, I'm one of those). C'mon, I bet a lot of us eat, take photos and notes, run yummy dishes through a yum-spectrometer in an attempt to duplicate it back home.

    I will let you know how I decided to prepare the rutabaga.

    Meanwhile, a household member talked me into making Chinese ravioli - "potstickers" with soy-ginger-green onion dipping sauce for a Thanksgiving appetizer. Personally, I don't think it adds anything and is better for New Years. But the pot luck is a post-Thanksgiving, play it again, Sam event. Always too much food. Yum. I'll have to let out my slacks before I leave home.

    Thanks again, and Happy Stuffing, everyone!

    photos: local turkeys and the rutabaga

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    petalique, I agree, a route where we just stopped at other members houses and ate would be a lot of fun. I've met nearly 30 of the forum members and eaten at several houses and they were, without exception, delicious and I came away with recipes.

    Those turkeys look familiar, I have a flock of them at the farm too.

    We also always called them "beggies", and now I have to go find one in the produce section. It's one of those things I don't grow because I have a big problem with root maggots that I've not been able to overcome. I've never batter dipped and deep fried them......yet.

    Annie

    petalique thanked annie1992
  • 8 years ago

    I cooked the rutabaga. I was so tired out from other T day cooking and dining and traveling, so I overslept and was running out of time. I chefs knife peeled the rutabaga then chopped it into 1 inch dice. Then I cooked it in the pressure cooker for about 6 to 10 minutes. Then I drained it in mashed with good quality butter. I put it into a serving dish with some layers of pepper jack cheese (grated) and topped it with chopped roasted hazelnuts. Oh, I had also added salt and pepper. It tasted pretty mild so maybe I should've put and spice or onions or apples into it, but I was running out of time. It looked good and people at the table said that they really loved rutabaga, but they were quite a lot of people and some of them were vegans. I'm not sure why but I ended up bringing half of the bowl back. That's OK, we. will finish it.

    I took other things such as the Irish soda bread, wine, and a chocolate pie so I wasn't relying holy on the rutabaga experience. Giggle. Thanks everyone for your tremendous help and encouragement.


    Soda Bread not yet done.

  • 8 years ago

    I some times buy a smallish rutabaga, peel it and cut into quarters. Slice as thin as possible on a mandolin. Paint slices with olive oil , salt, pepper and garlic powder. Roast at 425 till crispy like chips. Turn over as necessary

    petalique thanked marcopolo5
  • 8 years ago

    That sounds yummy, marcopolo5. I love salty things, but I have be advised to limit my sodium intake. Maybe a bit of jalepeno would make me not miss the salt. (Trying to fool myself, but it might work.)

  • 8 years ago

    Petalique, how about a bit of low sodium soy brushed on when starting to crisp. Doubt that would be an amount that would make a difference.

    petalique thanked marcopolo5
  • 8 years ago

    Thanks. Maybe. But even low sodium (light) soy sauce is pretty salty. I tend to cook a lot of Thai and Chinese food, and try to give my sodium budget to those things. Even then, I have to cut back more. Thai Fish sauce has a lot of sodium in it, as do many of the other pastes and condiments. There really isn't a satisfactory substitute. I also want to limit fats, saturated fats and carbs.

    Well, at least there's watercress, tomatoes and lemon juice- EVOO <smile>.