I'd go for something different, but I would look for something with different tones to it. Brass maybe or glass.

Do you prefer not to have a coffee table in the center?

I'm not a person who likes to match things especially if the lamps are going to be different. So I would go for a different one. I like what lukkirish said in brass or glass perhaps.

I would do something different, but I don't think I'd do brass or glass. I'd stick with wood.

Something different, but related in some way.

Thanks everyone! I was leaning towards different also (which was why I ordered just 1 table to start). I am playing around with some different configurations. (1) Putting the black skinny table on the other side of the sofa and getting a stool or drum table next to the chair (2) Putting the new end table on the other side of the sofa and getting a square one in the spot that it occupies right now. I will try and find some options to post.

What about something like this? I was thinking it brings in the black metal from the small black side table and the wood from the round end table.

I love the first table above...(the one in the last three tables you posted.)

i would move the little round table to the left of the sofa and

place the new table on the right side. You're on the right track

with not matching tables and lamps.

What I don't like about non matching tables on each side of the sofa is height differerences, than of course if two lamps are used they are different heights. Is it only me that finds this weird?

I think either the lamps of the end table should match, but never both. Personally, I prefer matching lamps and non-matching end tables but it really is a personal preverence.

Thanks everyone! Super helpful input. I haven't purchased lamps yet, but I was contemplating these two:

The first lamp looks too short to be a side table lamp. The second one, style wise, doesn't work as an end table lamp. Before you choose a lamp, you need to purchase your end tables to know what height lamp you'all need. I don't think the 2 tier table works well as an end table in your room. I'm also not crazy about the metal table next to the chair. I'd get a ceramic or metal stool for next to the chair. I'd keep looking for another end table for the sofa or get another of the one you already have and get different lamps of the same height.

Thanks! I thought the first lamp looked short in the picture but it is 25" tall, so that seemed ok. I am definitely considering a stool next to the chair.

This isn't a terribly good picture but it shows different end tables and different lamps, although they are the same height and the lampshades are fairly similar. The end table on the left is an antique two-drawer French lingerie chest and the one on the right is a small table with chair.

Update....I received the small black table and it is all wrong. Sending that one back.

I could do the square end table from the same collection. They are also the same height so that is nice.

I like the square with the round and then two matching lamps.

Yes to the table from the same collection as the round one and 2 matching lamps.

I ordered the square table! Now looking for lamps and a stool to go next to the chair. Thanks for the help!

For lamps I was thinking of something ceramic to contrast with all of the wood and metal. Would any of these look good?

1:

2:

Hmmm. If I did SAME end tables, I'd do different lamps. If I did DIFFERENT end tables, I'd do same lamps. All different would look junky to me regardless of price tag. My inclination would be diff end tables, this is strictly regarding flanking the sofa.

I think any of them could conceivably work, but so much will depend on the height. Will both of the new end tables be the same height? If so, why don't you try some lamps you already have to see what high is best. Then you can narrow down your choices. Also, do you plan to add any window treatments?

I don't have many lamps yet...but this one is 25.5". Both end tables will be the same height.

Hmmmm. It's not too bad height wise, but I think it could maybe be a little taller. Let's see what others think

Have you considered something like this for next to the chair?

Yes, that's super cute! I hadn't found one the right size yet, but that one has great dimensions. Thank you!

Maybe you have already answered this but will you be using a rug and/or coffee table?

BTW, I love all of your rooms you have shown us! Looking forward to seeing how this one turns out.

If you need small martini tables for in front of the sofa to place drinks you could use one or two of these from West Elm. I love mine!

https://www.westelm.com/products/martini-side-tables-metallics-h1420/?pkey=cside-tables

Liking # 1 or 4 for the lamps, although they are all great choices.

I agree Sara, I was just doing that to get some perspective on height, as suggested by k9arlene.

Thanks aktillery! For now, my husband says no on a rug. :( We have older dogs that like to pee on fuzzy things. They are perfect when there is hardwood floor only. I might do an ottoman at some point.

I really like the table in your last picture and the lamp is not bad. The heavy-bodied ones look somehow wrong; I would opt for something with a slim silhouette, which would also give you more room to place other things on the table, decorative or otherwise. The grayish color of the table also looks more stylish than the brown, which seems to darken everything around it.

I definitely think you should do mix matched end tables and the same lamps! I can't wait to see what art you reveal! :) The room is seriously coming together gorgeously!