Magnolia hypoleuca (also known as obovata)
Mary Shane
7 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (10)
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
7 years agogardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
7 years agoRelated Discussions
Does Magnolia tripetala really smell bad?
Comments (12)Magnolia trees can drop lots of litter. If you have your mind solidly set on planting such a tree, than consider also if you are willing to pay the high price for an automatic retractable pool cover needed to prevent filter cloging problems, or if that cost is not in your budget, then consider what it will mean to you, once you find that you end up having less time to enjoy using the pool; due to all the time and energy it takes to keep the Magnolia's debris out of the pool. Flowers drop petals, from most trees and shrubs. Evergreen magnolia's seem to shed dead leaves throughout the growing season, and the really large flowers that some magnolias produce are dropped from these trees after they have turned brown and have begin to appear like a huge ugly glob of mush and or simply large brown clumps of rotting debris. Is this really what you want to see or to have to make a regular practice of cleaning up every two to three days during the times of the year when your pool will be used? Not to mention that most magnolia trees end up spreading their canopy far beyond what can be easily envisioned when first planting them in their 6 or up to 12 foot tall stage....See MoreMagnolia X 'Butterflies'
Comments (11)bboy, ginkgonut, and, others: Thanks for all the helpful information, and especially, your opinions regarding this Magnolia variety. bboy: What exactly about my climate will cause the flowers to wash-out of color? Is it the cold springtime temp's? Can you explain a little more about how temp's. may affect color? The tree that I have my eye on looks to be at least 10 years old, and, has a nicely tapered trunk, measuring about 1-1/2" diameter above the wide, root base, continuing up the first 4 feet of the trunk, then from there, it gradually tapers down to about 3/4" diameter, over the next 3-4 feet. The tree is very well branched, with a nice shape too. I would guess that the tree is probably either at, or, very near, blooming-size. How old do you think these trees must be to produce a good display of flowers? Can I prune back some of the elongated branches, - after flowering - to induce dormant buds to break along bare wood so that more flowering twigs/branchlets are produced from the older, leaf nodes? Thanks, to all, for sharing your experiences, photos, opinions. I was a great help. Frank...See MoreBig leaf magnolia?
Comments (14)Thanks for all the replies! M. ashei sure seems like a great tree, but I think I've got the patience for the big one, especially since I think their leaves get bigger, which is really what I want. At that price I thought I might try some from seed. The extras would be great for sharing. Only source I could find was B & T World seeds... they're a little lax on nomenclature so I'm worried it would take years before I new for sure what I'm getting from them. Anyone else know of any seed sources? - Tom...See MoreWhats the cool tree of the year going to be?
Comments (43)I wholeheartedly agree with the diversity comments! Of the trees mentioned, I planted my first (2'?) Acer Triflorum in 1998 and then moved it two years later. It’s been a very nice investment. I tried planting another 3’ triflorum four years ago, but it didn’t survive the drought that first year, and my watering probably didn’t help. We have very well drained soil, but it floods along a dry stream from time to time with summertime thunderstorms. Flooding seldom lasts more than a couple of hours. Both triflorums were planted in the area that floods. Planted two more 18” triflorum two years ago and they’re doing fine so far. I planted my first Yellowwood around 1980. It suffered damage in one of the droughts a few years ago. I think nearly 1/3rd of the tree died back, but it has recovered. It has been a great tree to have in the yard. I planted another (2’ tall?) in 2011 in a better area of the yard and it’s off to a very good start. I’ve finally been able to get Chinkapin Oaks established from a nearly 200-year-old specimen in the back yard. The squirrels kept digging them up each spring! I’ve got one that’s now about 20 feet tall. If it has the same great shape of the parent tree, someone’s great-grandchildren will hopefully appreciate it! We've got one started in a neighbor's yard, too! I keep trying to select those seedlings with the reddest leaves, but have little luck getting saplings with very much red color—so far. I highly recommend Chinkapin Oak if you can get it and can deal with the acorns. Unfortunately, the old tree is showing its age and will need to come down before long. It’s been the best looking of the mature oaks in the area and I hate to see it go. Black Gum/Tupelo was mentioned, too. I tried to get two of these (3’ or so?) started in 1979. One died the first year and the other struggled for 6-7 years before I finally gave up on it. I planted another smaller Black Gum in 2011. It’s slow-growing in quite a bit of shade, but seems to be doing fine so far. Parrotia. We planted our little (2’?) Parrotia in 1996. Moved it in 1998 and it has done extraordinarily well ever since. It suffered a little in a drought a few years ago, but recovered nicely. We had to remove our 75+ years old sugar maple 4 years ago after the power company butchered it. I replaced it with a Legacy and planted it farther from the street. It’s doing very nicely. My biggest regret over the years has been planting two River Birch in 1998. Messy trees. One of them goes as soon as the newer Yellowwood gets some size. Maybe in a couple of years. And, help your neighbors choose and plant trees! Future generations will appreciate the effort, anonymous though you may be by then....See MoreEmbothrium
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoMary Shane
7 years agoEmbothrium
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoMary Shane
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agogardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
7 years agoMary Shane
7 years agoEmbothrium
7 years agolast modified: 7 years ago
maackia