Exterior [or interior] floorplan opinions
Brian 's
7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (21)
Brian 's
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoRelated Discussions
Need opinions of floor plan
Comments (14)DON'T lose your pantry and I agree about the bathroom. I really don't get this idea now that guests can't use an otherwise used bathroom. But, threedoghouse has a good point about jogs and angles...They do add cost that could translate more usefully into square footage. I haven't studied your plan enough to know if you've already considered this, but it's also most efficient, material cost and use wise, to plan your exterior measurements in 4 or 8 ft increments. Some even get down to window placement, but I didn't take it that far. We did try to keep the house as square as possible, and made many of our interior walls run in straight lines for simpler framing. You can create window seats and other more interesting shapes in the house with walls and cabinetry. Where we plan a window seat, the wall is straight, but there'll be taller cabinets at each end to cozy it in. Looking at your plan, I would definitely close off the end of the laundry, not just leave it open to through-traffic coming from the garage. The laundry is something it's nice to close a door on...because of noise and its less-than-gorgeous view. Our last house had a kitchen oriented similarly to the front door, and viewable from the living room. I have to honestly say, I hated it. People would drop by unexpectedly while the kids' mac n' cheese bowls were still on the bfast bar and while a baking project was underway in the kitchen. Not a very gracious impression. Also, we definitely had the problems of food and dishes too easily traveling to the living room, and TV too easily a part of meals and slowing down the dish-doing process. While I'm eating, I don't like to look at kitchen mess, and want to be able to linger as long as I like with family or friends without having the cleanup job staring us in the face. But I know that's the big issue of open kitchen vs closed. I could handle a kitchen open to a more private family space, but would never choose it for the guest area. Just my opinion, though....See MorePlease take a look at our floor plan, opinions needed...
Comments (22)Ok, so if I was to scrap the dining room.... Could I put the basement stairs and a seperate laundry room in that space? Would that be okay and where would you put them? I could shrink up the dining room and bedroom/office closet about 2 feet to line up with the foyer/front door line, so it would be straight across instead of bumped out. Then I could use that square footage to make the breakfast area to be the same width as the family room. Would that free up enough space? So that would make the breakfast area 11'8" X 14'. Is it ok to have it one big space with no breaks in the wall lines? I would then rework the mudroom/garage entrance and bedroom nearest the garage. I guess my main thing would be what do I do for a window beside the front door now? Obviously we wouldnt put a triple there, like it was in the dining room. It would be a window in the laundry room now, so what kind of window should it be to make it look right?...See MoreGeneral Opinions of This Mascord Marlow Floorplan
Comments (13)I'm not crazy about the exterior. I really dislike the garage-in-front thing, but that's personal opinion. I would absolutely build in brick. It's one of those "you get what you pay for" things. As for the plan, I'd simplify the complicated jigs and jogs around the edge. For example, you could chop the master bedroom off "flat" with the back of the house with no loss of usefulness in the room, yet it'd save money to have a simple flat wall. Since you're questioning whether you want two eating areas, you could do the same thing with the nook: Just chop it off flat, and you'd be left with enough space for a small booth or table for two. I don't mind entering the house through the laundry, but I would want another door in that master closet. Why? Because as it is now, you have to tote clean clothes through the bedroom, through the bathroom, and finally into the closet. A door (or even a pass-through) could be placed in such a way that you could go straight into the closet. It'd be worth the loss of those shelves on the end of the closet. The master shower is a very odd shape. Why would you ever want that little weird cubical in the back? I'd chop that off and make it into a tall cabinet or small linen closet. You'd still have a plenty-big shower. You have plenty of space in the kitchen, but it is laid out inefficiently. The sink and refrigerator are very far apart, and the island blocks your way. This could be made much more efficient. The upstairs looks highly adjustable, depending upon how many bedrooms you need and whether you're interested in the bonus room or not. The bathroom towards the front could be built or omitted. You could build as much or as little of this as you want now, and you'd have the space later to expand, if you wish....See MoreNeed Your Opinions & Advice on Custom Home Floor Plan, Please!
Comments (47)I would like to thank everyone who took the time to read through these posts and to post advice and suggestions and constructive criticism. I am taking all of it into consideration and some of it was not what i wanted nor expected to hear, but what I needed to hear. I feel as if a little more explanation is needed. We found a builder that we really like and everyone that he has built for has been really happy. He had several plans that we could look at or if we had any plans he could build whatever we liked. He has a gentleman that could draw and customize a home for us. We thought it was architect at first and the price was so good because we were going through him and he would then be able to have our house plan to use in the future. Upon our first meeting with the gentleman that was going to draw up of dream home so we could make it a reality, we learned that he was not an architect, or designer. He's retired now from 40 years of experience woking on/building homes and is good with the software. He is very kind and has been very patient with the many changes we have made along the way. However, we soon discovered that he really has no design ideas or suggestions. He just draws whatever we ask him to or whatever I draw to send to him. If we wanted something a changed, the standard procedure was to just make part of the house bigger, we had gotten up to almost 4400 square feet! If we didn't like the way something worked and asked for a change, he would fix that issue and cause 2 more. I got so frustrated that we are trying to build our dream home and pretty much the only person I had for design help was myself. Uhm, I really want someone with much more skill and talented and better taste to design my home. I know what I want, I just do't know how to get there. We have been working on this for 8 months. I got so frustrated that I gave up for 3 months. Our neighbors are using the same builder and they had difficulties getting their design as well. However they had found a floor plan that they liked and just had him make changes to it and add a mother in law plan. I firmly believe that we are his first truly start from scratch home. Again, this is the guy the builder sent us to to have plans drawn, not our builder. Giving him credit he has taking my very very basic sketches and turned them into something the builder can build from, but pretty much the design is about 99% me, not that I wanted it that way. Here is where I'm at, so you can see that he is doing all the builder type stuff. We don't want to be difficult, but we want a good design. We don't want the builder to think that we are difficult or indecisive because we just can't get there with his guy. I'm at a loss! Several people wanted to know the lot dimensions. So here they are: It is at the top of a ridge, has some slope to it and has a nice open are in the middle. Of course we want the house to sit about at the arrows part of the lot. There is an utility easement of 20 feet on the right side of the lot, but the utility poles are more like 30 feet inside the property. I really do appreciate all of your insight. It has been eye opening. I'll make another post addressing questions and comments. Sorry to be so long winded....See MoreVirgil Carter Fine Art
7 years agostephja007
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agocpartist
7 years agostephja007
7 years agocpartist
7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agoadkbml
7 years agocpartist
7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoAbbyJoy
7 years agoBT
7 years agostephja007
7 years agoartemis_ma
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoBrian 's
7 years agolast modified: 7 years agoartemis_ma
7 years agocpartist
7 years ago
Related Stories
WALL TREATMENTSExpert Opinion: What’s Next for the Feature Wall?
Designers look beyond painted accent walls to wallpaper, layered artwork, paneling and more
Full StoryARCHITECTUREDark Exterior, Light Interior: 6 Homes That Celebrate Contrast
They claim the best of both worlds and have a distinct wow factor. See if any of these high-contrast homes light a spark of curiosity
Full StoryMODERN ARCHITECTURESaving Facades: Modern Gems Merge Old and New
Restored exteriors full of character wrap light-filled interiors designed for modern life
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Many Styles Meld Handsomely in a Vermont Countryside Home
With a traditional exterior, a contemporary interior and lots of Asian furniture, this home goes for the element of surprise
Full StoryMATERIALSWhat Is Shiplap?
Read how a common exterior siding became so popular for interior paneling
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNNew This Week: 4 Kitchen Design Ideas You Might Not Have Thought Of
A table on wheels? Exterior siding on interior walls? Consider these unique ideas and more from projects recently uploaded to Houzz
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: A Simple Barn House in Rural Wisconsin
This newcomer to a well-established community has an exterior that fits right in, but its interior has a modern edge
Full StoryWORKING WITH AN INTERIOR DESIGNER5 Qualities of a Happy Designer-Client Relationship
Cultivate trust, flexibility and more during a design project, and it could be the beginning of a beautiful alliance
Full StoryARCHITECTUREModern or Contemporary Architecture? The Interiors Edition
See how one expert distinguishes between two popular camps of interior architecture. Do you agree with his choices?
Full StoryREMODELING GUIDESInterior Brick: Paint it or Leave It?
Here's how to know if covering that brick is a sin or solution
Full Story
Mark Bischak, Architect