Here are a few more pics of fireplace with existing mirror

I'm going to go in a different direction here and ask if you really need a mirror. You have such gorgeous windows and light already, I would look at a metal sculpture piece or fabulous art work.

I like jlc's suggestions but the more I think about it, the more I agree with Outside. The mirror doesn't really do anything for me there and gets a bit lost since the windows are such a big, beautiful focus. I too think a striking piece of art would really stand out over the mantle and would personalize your room in a way that a mirror simply can't.

I agree on art work or sculpture piece rather than a mirror there.

art work or sculpture, as mentioned above you have enough glass in the room with the windows. I think a mirror looks great over a fireplace in a smaller room to make the room seem bigger, but your room is plenty big already. I would look for a artwork that is visually heavy as your fireplace is really big.

I agree about other artwork instead of a mirror .... or, if you'd really like a mirror, I'd do a round one amid all the square shapes in the room. Beautiful fireplace and room!

I truly appreciate the posts about artwork or a sculpture, but I really prefer a mirror. I change out the accessories on the fireplace for holidays and seasons and the last thing I need is 4 or 5 different pieces of art work to have to change out lol. It's doubtful I would find something I would like to work throughout the year for different holidays and seasons. I just know how I am and that I'd need something to match each time. I actually like the mirror and everyone that comes here it's usually one of the first things they comment on. I agree it looks dwarfed in the pics, but the ceiling is lower in my kitchen area so you don't see the entire top of the fireplace all throughout the first floor so it does not look so small in person.

i like the idea of artwork but know myself and it would have to match all the seasonal decor lol

I think that a more rustic mirror would work better. Something along the lines of what jlc posted.

Time to add some curves to the room with all corners

I do not think I like the first mirror after doing a mock up. I might have made it too large as well.

I like the mirror you have, I would simply get a larger one.

Beverly, I see your point and agree with the curves. However, the piece you showed is not my style. I do appreciate you Photoshopping it to in show me though as it gives me an idea. I agree with aktillery9 as I do like the style mirror I already have, but bigger, I'm liking these ideas those friends as it makes me think of different directions I have not broached before. Keep them coming and thank you.

I have always liked Sunburst mirrors and that is a different shape from all the squared off shapes in that room. However, I don't think I've ever seen a large enough one for over my fireplace.

This is a Neiman Marcus one on eBay that is 64" across.

http://www.ebay.com/itm/Extra-Large-63-Neiman-Marcus-GOLD-SUNBURST-Starburst-Mirror-XL-Modern-Convex-/191672809185?hash=item2ca096f6e1

The mirrors are sold individually on Wayfair. You get to create your own arrangement, as wide or narrow as you like and as tall as you prefer. IMO they are the perfect solution to your stone wall.

gear mirrors

http://www.overstock.com/Home-Garden/Natural-Wood-Finish-Wooden-Wall-Mirror-with-Gear-Inspired-Frame-Set-of-2-Natural-Wood-Finish/9760457/product.html?refccid=DSQ3GQFBFDK3YVCGDLLDWXZNGQ&searchidx=2

small gear mirror

I wouldn't put a rectangle there. I agree with metal artwork without square corners

The gears aren't working for me, either. Maybe in a machine shop, but not in a home. : ) (Sorry Beverly, you share so many wonderful ideas!!!)

This room reminds me a bit of yours:

Estates at Cohasset Elkton · More Info

I think that mirror would look great over your mantel. It is darker with a sort of rustic European feel and it definitely has some lovely curved edges, so it is not all rectangular looking---much softer than the current mirror. It is a good size for your chimney breast and for that size is a FABULOUS deal!

I'd prefer either a round or square mirror in that space, or maybe rectangular going horizontally. The mirror that is mirroring the shape & direction of the windows on either side looks to me to need breaking up.

Laughable moments, I actually have the pic of that room saved you posted because of the drapes lol.

I had that mirror before we moved in that is now over the fireplace. I didn't have the money to buy every single thing brand new when we moved in of course, so I made do with some things I had until I could gradually buy more things.

the gear mirrors are nice, just not my thing. I actually have a beautiful round cocktail table in a metal champagne color with matching end table and a floor lamp I have from Arhaus has some nice curves to it

i will keep looking and eventually find something. One thing I am hesitant about with round is having to get someone to drill a hole in the fireplace!!! The rectangle shape I am just sitting in the fireplace.

What about the arch mirror posted above? I agree to use something a little bit more rustic and less frilly.

Do we like any of these?

I personally like the existing mirror. It echoes the size and shape of the windows and carries through the bit of bling you have in various rooms. Its also subtle enough to let your accessories be noticed.

I like the size in the inspiration room. It is just a bit wider and shorter than your current mirror, so seems stop the eye from going straight up to the ceiling. You can do a cardboard mock-up to get the size you want, then go to a good frame shop, pick your frame and do a custom mirror-not that pricey.

Another I like

I did a mock up of the first mirror before I saw that aktillery did one already. Mines a bit different, I added the reflection from your current mirror to make it look more like it was in your room, so I thought I'd share it anyway. Just in case. I really like it. I think it works very well with the chandelier that you can see in the view I chose to do the virtual with.

I like the first one, of the new choices you posted. It's pretty but simple, and the darker frame will make it stand out and tie in with the rest of your room.

justgotabeme, that looks great! I might really l like that one the best now after seeing it mocked up more accurately.

I'm with jlc or the arched mirror she posted initially.

You have a lot of rectangular shape in that room, so some curves would balance that. Not to mention, that people find curved shapes -- because they are derived from nature --- more relaxing than sharp geometrical angles.

What does the mirror reflect? I used to love to put mirrors just about anywhere until a mirror guy made the point. I was having him measure to install a built in mirror in a fpl surround and he asked that question. I realized it was reflecting something pretty boring and nixed it.

Have you thought about not putting the mirror/art on the mantel but mounting it higher up to draw the eye towards the ceiling?

Seems like something a bit grander is needed in that space.

(sorry if asked earlier)

Thank you Aktillary. I like it better than any of the other mirrors too.
NoSoccorMom, the mirror in my virtual, which is the very first one that ChloeKitty posted, does have quite a few curves in it's design. They just don't stand out much in the virtual.
When I look at all the mirrors that Chloe shared, and at the things in her lovely room, I noticed a feminine theme, so I personally think the first mirror fits quite well.