Something knawed down my apple tree... help!

8 years ago

We came back from a 5 day vacation to find my Pixie Crunch apple tree knawed or sliced completely off the root. Any ideas what kind of animal or other reason would cause this to happen? I had planted it about 2 years ago, this was the first year that it bore apples; none of them were touched.

Featured Answer

TurkeyCreekTrees Zone 5B

8 years ago

Konrad gets the prize. Graft failure in my book.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (13)

Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
8 years ago
Not sure but it might have broken on that poor looking graft union.
gardenergal24 thanked Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
Related Discussions
Can I help my stripped apple tree?
Q
Comments (3)
Don't worry Rudy, this can happen, trees have a wonderful way of healing themselves after injury. If the bark is gone all the way around, the branch is toast..bad goats! If the main stem is OK you should be fine, it will push out new branches. I would just cut away broken branches and leave it alone, don't cut back new growth, you need all of it for better recovery, I would then just paint the stripped wood with Doc Farwell, if you can't get it, paint with ordinary carpenters glue or a latex paint. Konrad Here is a link that might be useful: Doc Farwell's seal
...See More
Help! My new apple tree is sick already (?)
Q
Comments (3)
Two days since you got it? Your tree has really been whipped around a lot lately. Trucked to the store, maybe too wet or too dry, harsh sun it may not be used to, windblown at some point, transplant shock as Scott notes. It may be disease of some kind, but it also looks like mechanical damage from the above causes. I have an apple tree that acquires a very similar look each May or June on the north side after a howling wind. I would just keep an eye on the new growth that comes out and see if it continues. More than likely it won't.
...See More
Cinnamons Spice Apple Tree- Something is wrong?
Q
Comments (8)
FWIW, I got one apricot tree from Stark Bros. and it was healthy but half the size/caliper of those from Raintree, Dave Wilson Nursery or One Green World but comparable price. I am no expert but I would cut the leader back by half to relieve the burden on the (insufficient) root system (as above so below). It will grow back once the roots get established. I cut all my new trees down to 24" above the graft union. The one I did not, because I want it to provide shade, had a skimpy root system and did not show signs of life for many weeks after all the others were fully leafed out - I should have cut that one back too.
...See More
Help identify the disease/pest affecting my apple tree
Q
Comments (4)
I see nothing wrong with your tree that would require any treatment. There are some blemishes on the leaves but that looks more physiological than any sort of disease or insect problem. There might have been some early aphid activity but don't see any sign of them now - aphids often attract ants. Regardless of the cause, the tree will be fine. FYI, the Bonide sulphur spray is intended to be used as a fungicide. It will have no affect on any insect problems, should they arise. Any apples the tree produces should be fine. You do have a pollination partner for it?
...See More
tcstoehr
8 years ago
I seriously doubt that is a graft union failure. Look at the solid, healthy wood that is exposed. No rotting and no bark inclusions. It also doesn't look like there was an air pocket there. Just clean, severed wood. No peeling and the break goes completely through. I would think a tree falling over from a weak joint would show tearing, peeling or splintering and likely would not have broken all the way through.

I believe I see serrations in there, like a cutting instrument was used. Was there any sawdust or chips laying around indicating that some tool was used to saw, chop or hack the trunk apart? Check down under the grass.

Any beavers in your area?

I admit that someone or something cutting that tree down would have chosen a few inches higher where the trunk is much narrower. But the more I look at those serrations the more I suspect a tool was used. In fact it reminds me of occasions where I have used a bow saw to cut down a small tree and the blade keeps pinching and I have to come in from different angles to struggle through the cut with noone to help me and the tree leaning this way and that way.

Yeah, this was no accident. I think someone did it with a hand saw, maybe attacking from one side and then another. That would account for the multiple cut angles. Look for sawdust or wood bits. And of course let us know what you find.
gardenergal24 thanked tcstoehr
gardenergal24
Original Author
8 years ago
Thank you all for your interest and comments, this is a real puzzle to me. We found no sign of sawdust or wood bits. The tree appeared to be very healthy, had at least 5 nice little apples already starting to get red. No beavers close by that I'm aware of (although last year our neighbor had a persistent one about 1/2 mile down our road that kept damming up a brook & causing flooding damage).

I've had no experience with graft failure. Can a healthy tree just pop off of it's graft? We did have very bad wind and rain around the time that it happened. No sign of animal disturbance in the mulch around the base. Think I need to read up a little on graft failure...
gardenerlorisc_ia
8 years ago
I had the very same thing happen with my 2 year old Honey Crisp apple tree. It was lying down with just a tiny bit of bark attached and I believe the graft failed. This was the first year I had any apples so I was very disappointed but Gurney's gave me a credit to use to replace it. I had never heard of a graft failing but there was a small hollow area as yours appears to have. It very well could have been a failure.

I am in no way affiliated with Gurney's but they do come through if there is a problem.
gardenergal24 thanked gardenerlorisc_ia
fruitnut Z7 4500ft SW TX
8 years ago
Another vote for graft failure. It can be caused by something like a virus infection. The tree snaps off at the union.
gardenergal24 thanked fruitnut Z7 4500ft SW TX
Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
I think someone did it with a hand saw, maybe attacking from one side and then another.

The reason being why it wasn't done by animal or human saw,..look close around the outside of bark,..all looks torn and broken, no entry marks of any teeth, a good gust of wind can bring it down.
gardenergal24 thanked Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
Jeremy Millrood
8 years ago
bummer...it almost certainly is a graft failure..had the same thing happen to my Tropic sweet apple tree.
gardenergal24 thanked Jeremy Millrood
tcstoehr
8 years ago
True, I don't see any very smooth areas where a saw would have moved along. And a saw would have left some some debris.

Yet I have never seen wood snap as cleanly as that, right across the grain no less. No splintering or peeling. Possibly some tearing.
gardenergal24 thanked tcstoehr
lucky_p
8 years ago
+1 for catastrophic graft failure. Have seen it more than a few times.
gardenergal24 thanked lucky_p
gardenergal24
Original Author
8 years ago
Turns out that I had purchased this tree from Gurneys 2 years ago. Sent them an email along with the pictures, will let you know how it turns out.
Jeremy Millrood
8 years ago
My local nursery has a one year guarantee, so luckily I was able to get mine replaced, but I'd be surprised if they did anything after 2 years..guess it can't hurt to ask.
Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
8 years ago
Staking young trees a couple of years is always a good thing, most grafts are vulnerable the first few years. My latest purchase I put in about 2 weeks ago [Superior plum ] has a ugly union, staking it, hopefully it will grow OK..I didn't complain,..seems I'm always a victim for ugly trees.

This one I purchased from another nursery last year, just dug up, barely hung in last year and has died,..ugly graft, was infected with some black thing.