Fire Insurance. How do you proove value?
11 years ago
last modified: 11 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (10)
- 11 years ago
Related Discussions
Homeowners Insurance & Chimney Fires
Comments (2)Another insurance agent here. This is a tricky one. If it's normal wear and tear then it definately isn't covered. But if an abnormal fire flared up caused it then it definately is covered. Fire is a covered peril, yet we're talking about a fireplace here. It's kind of like a roof. If normal weather wore down your roof over a period of several years then no coverage. But if a large hail storm comes through and damages your roof you get a new roof. And you don't even have to pinpoint a time when the storm came in and did it, if you can see spots where hair dented in or otherwise damaged your roof years from when it happened it's still covered. My suggestion: file a claim. Tell them a fire flared up and cracked and bowed it. Your agent probably sees hundreds of claims a year so when you call in while this is a huge issue that directly affects a big portion of your life, for him it's just another of a dozen people who called in filing claims that week. Also, a portion of his pay is probably affected by how much they lost in claims from his customers that year, if so he has incentive to talk you out of filing a claim. You must also be aware of the negative aspects of filing a claim of this nature: that your deductible will apply, your rate will probably go up a little, switching companies will be a problem if you ever want to do so in the near future (no company wants to take somebody who's filed a big claim recently), and if you file too many claims in a certain period of times your company can non-renew you at your next renewal (depending on state law). But this is a lot more money to fix your fireplace we're talking here so I say file it and see what happens....See MoreHow do you value your old house for insurance?
Comments (15)"Just out of curiosity, who here thinks that you can build an new old house? " You do not have to use old materials, just old techniques in most cases. Plaster instead of drywall, mud beds for tile floors and walls instead of cement board, etc. You neither can use nor want lead plumbing (DWV or supply), but cast iron is still available (though not with poured lead & oakum joints). Electrical wiring has moved a long way since K&T (and the lack of any electricity before that in many houses). Hardwood floors are not going to be as tight a grain as very old stuff (especially if it was virgin timber) but there is no shortage of wood flooring, even in very large widths of you want to pay the cost. Virgin reclaimed (from old buildings or bodies of water) is also available. There is no reason to use full size dimension lumber (though it can be found if you want to look & pay). Joist spans are likely smaller than in very old structures, so extra wood is likely to be needed (I have never considered the bouncy floors of an older structure a 'feature' worth preserving or repeating. I do not think anyone wants to exactly recreate the old house, just the important parts of the surface finishes. I have repaired 18th century townhouses in Alexandria, VA so that you cannot even tell without putting a hole in the wall to see the new framing and wiring....See MoreDetermining insurance value
Comments (46)Thanks again everyone. So here's my update. I had no luck getting In touch with the agent we had used originally, and wasn't willing to drag my two kids along to go to the office. So I passes the issue off to dh who walked into the office without an appointment and asked to speak to someone. ( he makes a good squeaky wheel lol). The agent I had been dealing with was not available so he got someone else. She gave him the same song and dance about "a cabinet is a cabinet, a door is a door" etc. except having looked closely at our policy we knew we were covered for the option of "similar construction" for replacement cost, not standard construction. (It's extra). So, he pulled out receipts and photos etc. finally she agreed to open up the software they use, and spent 20 minutes with him going over the details of the house and the material used. That brought the replacement value up $60,000 (as opposed to the original $17,000). Quite a difference. We will be photographing and storing receipts just in case. So, the moral of the story, your agent should be thou rough, not lazy. Know your policy. And make noise if needed. Thanks again for all the advice!...See MoreHow do you value a pole barn?
Comments (9)In our area (small midwest town) pole barns are not a detractor. In general, they're a plus, especially on acreage and in the country...they're kind of expected. But I wouldn't call them such a plus that they add their retail cost to the home's value. I went and viewed the place yesterday. For the record it's a very nice pole barn: great concrete, sufficient power, large roll-up doors, drain in the center. I'd love to set up shop there, and Mr. Weedy's sorely missing having a garage. But the house was just meh. 70s vintage, low ceilings, no basement (current home has one). I can't see enjoying living there more than where we currently are in town....See More- 11 years ago
- 11 years ago
- 11 years ago
- 11 years agolast modified: 11 years ago
- 11 years ago
Related Stories

DISASTER PREP & RECOVERYHow to Prep for Disaster Insurance Claims
Tools and tips for making an inventory list, documenting damage to your home, and working with your adjuster
Full Story
MOVINGHiring a Home Inspector? Ask These 10 Questions
How to make sure the pro who performs your home inspection is properly qualified and insured, so you can protect your big investment
Full Story
MOST POPULAR9 Real Ways You Can Help After a House Fire
Suggestions from someone who lost her home to fire — and experienced the staggering generosity of community
Full Story
GARDENING AND LANDSCAPINGEco-Friendly Fire Pits: Casting Backyard Campfires in a New Light
Wood burning may be discouraged — even illegal in places — but that needn't mean forsaking the fire pit. Try one of these alternatives
Full Story
PATIO OF THE WEEKWater and Fire Mingle in a Canadian Front Yard
If the illuminated moat winding through this Ontario patio doesn't dazzle you, the 8-foot-wide fireplace will
Full Story
FIREPLACESUpdated Woodstoves Keep Home Fires Burning
Better technology means more efficiency than ever for modern woodstoves
Full Story
HOUZZ TOURSHouzz Tour: From Burned Down to Done Up in Las Vegas
A fire gutted this midcentury home — and laid the groundwork for a beautiful new floor plan
Full Story
MOST POPULARHow to Create an Inventory, Whether You're Naturally Organized or Not
Documenting your home items is essential, even if disaster seems unimaginable. And it may be easier than you think
Full Story
LIFE7 Tips to Get With a New Minimalist Mentality
Feeling overwhelmed by your stuff? Here's how to pare down, simplify and keep just what you need and love at home
Full Story
REMODELING GUIDESYour Floor: An Introduction to Solid-Plank Wood Floors
Get the Pros and Cons of Oak, Ash, Pine, Maple and Solid Bamboo
Full Story
jim_1 (Zone 5B)