Weed or perennial?

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

Or is this going to be a perennial weed!? Sorry it's one of my ignorant questions again! ROTFLOL!

The landscaper planted a number of "unknown" perennials in my front yard last year. So when this guy showed up just now, I just assumed that it's one of them. Well, it has grown very fast and it has lots of nice leaves and buds. Now it's starting to bloom and it is starting to look like a weed... hmm.... so what is it? Should I be getting rid of it!?

Featured Answer

prairie_northrose (3b north of Calgary AB, Canada)

8 years ago

last modified: 8 years ago

Just a guess but it looks like perhaps a type of soapwort to me. If it is, its a perennial, but invasive, can quickly smother other plants. I kinda like the smell of it, but one could say its an acquired smell.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

hykuezone1b
8 years ago
I'm pretty sure that's a weed. We had one here before any perennials were planted, and my MIL identified it as a weed, though I don't remember what she called it.
ostrich thanked hykuezone1b
Related Discussions
Weed or perennial?
Q
Comments (3)
also compare with butterfly weed ... which is a very confusing common name for the plant at the link ... down here in adrian MI ... mine looks at the same growth phase as yours.. but i am not a botanist ... so i could be wildly wrong ... the butterfly WEED is an exceptional plant that is not a weed ... ken Here is a link that might be useful: link
...See More
weed or perennial?
Q
Comments (2)
Yes, perhaps Rudbeckia laciniata.
...See More
weed or perennial? sorry it's sideways :?
Q
Comments (3)
Looks quite a bit like an aster (Symphyotrichum) to me. Maybe S ontarionis. Also looks like Solidago start! Need more info. You'll know when it blooms. Both are very important to insect life.
...See More
Weed or perennial?
Q
Comments (7)
I see both vile Queen Anne's Lace and another (the blue) that I can't remember the name of just now. It's a European native and it's naturalized in many places in the US. It's perennial, and it may or may not be a weed, depending on if you want it or not.
...See More
Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
8 years ago
Get rid of it as fast as you can,..my most hated weed out at the nursery.
ostrich thanked Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
ostrich
Original Author
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
Oh boy, now I am scared!!! What is it?! Does it just spread like crazy otherwise!? Konrad, why do you hate it so much???
hykue Zone 7 Vanc. Island
8 years ago
And I'm super curious. What is it?
FrozeBudd_z3/4
8 years ago
It's a catchfly weed ... I know that it might be tempting to leave, as it almost resembles a garden worthy plant, but believe me it's not and will seed out in profusion.
ostrich thanked FrozeBudd_z3/4
Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago
They choke out everything else and take over,..those seed heads are just about ready to drop seeds! The first one's to come up in spring! If the flowers would attract bees then I would not call it the worst..lol, never seen a bee on these!

http://www.lacombecounty.com/index.php/environmental-services/weed-identification-a-control/noxious/117-white-cockle
ostrich thanked Konrad..just outside of Edmonton Alberta
SouthCountryGuy Zone 4b-5 SE BC
8 years ago
FWIW it is very hardy much like dandelions
ostrich
Original Author
8 years ago
OH MY GOODNESS! I am so glad that I asked you guys - you just saved me 24,000 seeds of this thing!!!!!!! THANK YOU!

I just came home and even though it's getting dark outside, I went out to get it pulled, tout de suite !!! As soon as I pulled it, low and behold, I found the poor little perennial that the landscaper planted last year, and it was suffocated by this fast growing thing!!! Thank goodness I just pulled it...

Guys, you saved me again! Thank you so much!!! :-)
FrozeBudd_z3/4
8 years ago
Ostrich, the other day I had spotted and pulled out a sizable plant of the same type while it was happily growing away undetected among other perennials.
donna_in_sask
8 years ago
Yes, it's Saponaria aka "bouncing bet" - I tried growing it once and it didn't live very long for me. From that experience, I wouldn't have labeled it as invasive as others in this thread, certainly not enough to yank it out completely...but then, I'm a zone colder. If it were creeping/clustered bellflower, lily of the valley, perennial bachelor's button or goutweed, I would have told you to "kill it with fire", lol.
FrozeBudd_z3/4
8 years ago
Many of these plants grow in a neglected area of my yard, the blooms vary in their number of petals and I admit can be rather attractive such as with this particular specimen. This is a real close up shot, blooms are nowhere near as large as they appear.