Houzz Logo Print
alice_in_wonderland_gw

Question re 'Atonement' - movie vs book

I am wondering something about a certain difference between the book and the movie, both entitled "Atonement". It concerns the sequence of the events as depicted in the book and then in the movie.

My question concerns the scene when Cecilia jumps into the fountain to retrieve the broken parts of the vase. I seem to recall that in the book that scene was shown first. After that, I recall that the book then described Briony observing that the event from the window. My question is:

"Am I recalling this sequence correctly?"

In the movie, the sequence of the events was the opposite of the sequence in the book, as I recall it. In other words, in the movie the scene where Briony observed the event from the window came first. The scene showing the actual event by the fountain came next.

Perhaps it was necessary to show the scenes in this sequence because of the nature of film, as opposed to the written word. The written word can explain so much more. The movie must present the story mostly in pictures (especially in scenes without dialogue) and that necessitates a different

approach.

I suppose that most people wouldn't wonder about these seemingly insignificant matters. But it's details like this that can often make a big difference, especially in a story with such a labyrinthine plot.

Comment (1)