it's finally happened. i have sticker SHOCK.

13 years ago

i know what things cost. i know the highs and lows, the good, the bad and the extremely ugly. before we did our very first kitchen after my husband and i were first married (18 years ago tomorrow!) i wrote down the amount i thought it would cost on a piece of paper, sealed it in an envelope and gave it to him to hold onto before the bid came in. i was off by $30. he was awed.

but now, all of a sudden i am clueless. i breezed through our appliance selection without batting an eye, interviewed seven cabinet makers and reviewed every bid without surprise. yet now, as we are about to turn the final corner on the kitchen of our new build i am paralyzed. i can't for the life of me figure out WHY WHY WHYYYYY a drawer pull needs to cost over $22! i can intelligently state my case as to why we must have a wall oven that costs over $5K. i can even make my darling husband see the merits of a sink made in the UK that costs four times as much as our old sink in our previous kitchen. hell, i can even talk him into LOVING the stunning polished nickel faucets, soap dispensers and outrageously priced instant-hot dispensers that i HAD to have. but now, here i am wondering how on EARTH i will convince him that we need hardware that will cost over $1200 -when i can't convince MYSELF. i'm thinking this is ridiculous. i'm probably just feeling the stress of the final months of the project ...but i am SICK over the cost of the hardware! i know we all call it the "jewelry" of the kitchen but i have to say, i have some pretty nice jewelry and i STILL can't justify the cost. the majority of the pulls i selected are over $22 each yet the second and third runner up pulls are under $9 each! ok. i think i'm done. i'm supposed to just bite the bullet and get what i want because it's what i want and i've come this far and if i choke now i'll spend every day looking at the drawer pulls i DIDN'T want but instead SETTLED on and forever regret the choice to save some costs. RIGHT??

talk me through this, please. i just need a little push but i need 27 of these ALONE. they're so pretty though ...and weighty and solid ...just like i wanted. i'm rambling now. and if not these, then WHAT?

either tell me it's okay or just someone just pick something else that i will fall in love with. and i can't wait for this chapter in my life to end. i really thought this would be a LOT more fun. sigh.

Here is a link that might be useful: schaub & co. traditional hardware

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (12)

leela4
13 years ago
Oooh-those ARE nice.

It's only money, after all . . . (lol)
bayareafrancy
13 years ago
Well, in a high budget remodel, I'm not sure 1200 is a big deal. (I'm a very low budget remodeler, so I'm just guessing here.)

However, check out this site where they appear to be 14.00

Here is a link that might be useful: beautiful pulls for less
Related Discussions
Cabinet sticker sticker shock
Q
Comments (31)
Old River Cabinets is a custom company like Geppetto is with pricing about the same. Old river does not have a book and is a pain to price on the fly because you have to know every little upcharge that is based in their computer system they only have. Geppetto on the other hand has a book with cabinets every 3" with countless modifcation charges that I can apply to any cabinet to make it what ever size I want as I stated in the original post of modifying depth width or height in any combination. If they do not have a cabinet I can start with I have to fax in what I want and wait for a quote back. 3" increments just gives you an easier way to arrive at an exact cost. I can stack them verticaly, I can join them horizontaly up to 8' long for a custom look when they are installed. I can change the doors add a drawer anything you can think of. I can custom color match the fireplace which we are doing. I can custom color match the door sample which has the perfect color wood she wants which she has looked for 2 years to find. She is very picky when it comes to color. Geppetto will make anything I can dream. They are custom just in a manner that is easier to price as a designer who is not a employee of theirs. My overhead excluding gas is $3,000 a month. This business is about competing with the prices of the next guy. Lowes and Home Depot who's cabinet companies they represent sell approx half of all the cabinets in the US are the largest competition. 50% markups on semi custom products are about what you have to do to compete on price but then you can not compete on being as established as as they are when you are self employed per say. A typical set of semi custom cabinets cost the dealer 4-6k so a mark up would be 2-3k per transaction. Now since most people want to go with the established to big to fail company they will only buy with you if you give them a deal they can not turn down. So you drop your margin to do it if it is possible. Or you have contractors that want to work with you where the end price to customer is close in price to Lowes and Home Depot but they want money the owner is not aware of which makes you cut your margin in half and share it with the contractor. So either way you slice it I sell cabinets for the average kitchen that are all plywood dove tail full overlay soft close full extension for 6k most of the time and make $1,200 if you are lucky! So a custom kitchen which takes about twice as much time to figure out as there are many more ways you can layout the kitchen so you do multiple layouts before you find the perfect one for the customer has 400% more profit in it then the semi custom prices of the big box stores. And according to multiple posts on here the competition in supposed "custom" is 50k and up! Where I would be a total price of half that! I was not trying to make this about me I was more agreeing with the title of the thread of sticker shock shock. I have other people who buy fix and sell condo's and town houses here in the dc area where the cabinets cost me 900 - 1200 and I mark it up the same 50% to stay competitive. That translates to 450 profit. But wait.... that customer comes from a granite company that wants money for referring the business. So when you give them a 15% discount the profit on those kitchens goes to less then 200 including in home delivery costs. The industry forces you to work on percent markups. You spend as much time on a small job like that as you do on a semi custom kitchen which pays 1,200 or a custom one which takes a little longer that I doubled the price like other companies do I would make 25-50k on one kitchen? And people want to say that is the way you stay in business because you have overhead? Sticker Shock Shock. I agree. I must be to practical. I just wanted to give some context to the prices and point out that the orignial poster was correct to be shocked in my opinion and state some facts as to why it is true. Antss is right that it does take money to sustain a showroom. But you do not have to rip off your customer to do it by doubling the price of custom cabinets. How much money do you need to make on one job to stay in business when you are talking about profits upwards of 35k per transaction?
...See More
countertop sticker shock
Q
Comments (16)
I wanted a whiter granite too. Most I saw did not look quite right with my flooring or cabinets unit I found what is called Ibiza or Mirabeles granite. It took quite a search and I did find one that is more white/cream than brown/gold. I also found that most of the granite yards I went to told me that they would price match any granite I found (per square foot) I am in the southern most part of PA and looked at several yards around Baltimore. Get more quotes and keep your options open. I have found most of the whiter granites in this area are under 100.00 per square foot. I paid 75.00 per square foot. The price matching helped bring it down slightly as did the fact that I purchased my own sink off of ebay and was open to an install date. The granite looks beautiful and install went well. It helped that the installers stated that my GChad one of the best and most level cabinet installs he had seen in a long time and the fact that the walls were almost completely square. The counter installers said that having the cabinets installed right makes the biggest difference in how the countertop install goes.
...See More
High-end Kitchen Cabinet Sticker Shock, April 2016
Q
Comments (139)
A month of so ago, I started getting emails from Zillow (have no idea how). They show a picture of a kitchen, the total cost, and then, when one scrolls down, they show a breakdown, by category, of materials and labor. It was a HUGE eye opener for me as I thought cabinets were a MUCH bigger part of the budget than they appear to be. One can subscribe to "budget", "mid-range", and "luxury" kitchens. I think the biggest price I ever saw for cabinets in a HUGE kitchen, was about $30-40,000. Appliances? Often $20,000. Countertops & backsplash were another high ticket area. And labor clearly varied, based on whether there was extensive electrical/plumbing work or blowing out walls. I asked my KD about this (he owns the company and also supplies the labor for most of the work), and he said that in the nearly 40 years he's been doing this, he has seen the cabinet percentage of a kitchen remodel go down substantially. He said this is due to many manufacturers doing semi-custom which cuts cost dramatically. He said it's a rare client who springs for total custom as they rarely need to be able to spec things to the 1/4 inch. He said there are so many ways to work around this and then do NOT involve "filler strips". My own kitchen is going to come in at around $25,000, $13,000 of which is cabinets. But my kitchen is an anomaly as I am reusing my kitchen counters/integrated sink, all the undercounted lighting can be reused, ceiling pot lights were done over a decade ago - only 1 new one added, existing hardwood floors are being used (finished on site 13 years ago), and we're even reusing the Perrin & Rowe faucet - it's still made and now twice the price it was when I bought it. So, in reality, I'm doing a $40,000 kitchen, I just paid for much of the high cost stuff over the years. Did I make some compromises? Of course! I wish the cabinet interiors were wood, not a thin veneer of maple melamine (they will be painted wood on the glass doored cabinets), but it was not worth several thousands more to get this. No one sees them but me and they will be easy to keep and clean. Am I getting every single thing my little heart desired? Again, no! But this is due to the fact that I have an 11 x 15 kitchen and there is simply no room to build in the microwave or get other appliances off the counters (without sacrificing valuable real estate which I was unwilling to do). Is it going to be a show piece? What kitchen that size is! No island, just a $99 Ikea 17" wide cart. I hope this helps you. Try to subscribe to the Zillow kitchen emails - they are invaluable when pricing things.
...See More
HOLY STICKER SHOCK! - What did you pay?
Q
Comments (91)
@sabrown - Thanks! I'm all about trying to make a timeless look. We worked with Superior Woodcraft for our custom cabinets in our kitchen in Philly and had them copy that design for our new home in NYC. I looked at tons of butler pantry pics and got really specific about the width of the styles, inset cabinets, and the molding, which they replicated from a salvaged door I had on my laundry closet in Philly. They are installing a built in bookcase in our living room next week to match. The color is Farrow and Ball White Tie to match the walls in our kitchen and other living space. It was not a great paint for them to work with. Our Philly cabinets were Ben Moore Maritime White and looked great too. Superior is woman owned and run and they work around the East Coast. They've been in business for 60 years. It wasn't the smoothest experience this time around but I chalk it up to Covid. Their customer service is outstanding.
...See More
fabbric
13 years ago
The $14.00 ones are satin nickel, not polished nickel.
kateskouros
Original Author
13 years ago
bayarefrancy: YOU ARE MY HERO. i admit, i haven't had time to shop around but O.M.G. thank you so much! THANK YOU, THANK YOU, THANK YOU!!!
User
13 years ago
OK -- the reason those are expensive is because they're solid brass. My guess is the ones that are half the price are zinc underneath.

Now that you have a logical reason they're so expensive, are you at peace or still apprehensive?

If you're still apprehensive, move on and save the money, but take a few days off before you finalize your selection among your backup choices. Approach the problem next week with a fresh mind (and only look at less expensive materials).
bayareafrancy
13 years ago
Of course, the also come in polished nickel. :-)

Now go shopping RIGHT NOW!
shelayne
13 years ago
Seems to be the same pull--here's the skinny on the less expensive one--

Description
Solid Brass
Center to Center of screw hole = 6"
Overall Length = 7-1/2"
Projection = 1-1/4"
Base Diameter = 1-1/8"

I found a wide range of prices on my pulls as well, from $20 all the way to $10.79, which is where I said, "SOLD!" They were the exact same pulls with a huge variation in price.
dianalo
13 years ago
Not to be a fuddy duddy, but what kinds were your 2nd and 3rd choice pulls? If a search could save you $8 each on your "$22" ones, maybe your $9 ones would be even less with a little research too.
As much as we all want what we want, I don't think one needs to spend more than they want to (despite wanting each favorite item). It is so easy to upgrade here and there and justify spending the extra by saying I don't want to always think about what I'd rather have had. At some point, we all have to pay the piper and all those small decisions can really be a burden. I have seen more houses than I can count that are currently short sales or in foreclosure, where the people put in recent money into new kitchens, bathrooms, expensive fixtures, prof landscaping, stoops, decks, etc... and yet they are now without a house. I looked at a hot tub the other day at one and wondered how many payments that could have covered.
It is very easy to get swept away, especially here where there will always be someone with the latest and best, but that does not mean we need to have everything at the high end of the scale nor even many things to have a wonderful kitchen (and life).
I learned long ago, someone else will always be skinnier and richer, so to appreciate what you have and work for what you need/want. Getting a new house/ new kitchen is a great thing and will not be forever spoiled if you went with cheaper pulls. $1,200 is a big number no matter how you slice it. Saving $8 a pull x 27 = $216 which still leaves $1k to lay out in just pulls and knobs.

If you really want them after tallying up your total expenses, you can always choose them then. I'd sit down with paper and a calculator and your receipts and estimates. If you are where you want to be after adding that all up, then order the now $14 pulls. If not, this is a good time to save some money. You saying that you are losing your joy in this process is a sign you may be off track in your gut.
dianalo
13 years ago
One other thing to keep in mind, it does not matter what the pulls in my current kitchen were made of nor how much they cost. They are going in the garbage (or given on freecycle) as soon as we start work on the house. The seller could have busted their budget to buy them (I doubt it, lol) but they have no value to me. The pulls that you see such a value in may be easily recreated or bought in a lesser format and no one but you would be the wiser.
Now, if you said that you were so careful everywhere else and came in at, or below, budget all along, then I might say to cut loose and splurge. Because you said you went over on your oven, sink, soap dispensers, hot water dispenser, etc... this may be one thing too many. It is easy for everyone here to cheer you on, but it is your money and the bill will be on you.

What does your dh say about it? If you have to do a ton of convincing, then it may not be worth the battle.
caryscott
13 years ago
It seems like self inflicted punishment to me. You don't have to look at the compromise pulls and think "I wish...". The easy answer is don't do that. If that's the way you roll then you better just get them.
kateskouros
Original Author
13 years ago
i feel MUCH better, thanks to bayareafrancy. no problems at all with the cost. these things are heavy and we plan to be in this house for a long time. just going over the final count and i'll order this week. no battles, no punishment. the cost is completely within reason at $14 each. not the cheapest, but could have been a lot worse. and definitely NOT worth going for the second runner up. i have always depended on this forum. it has been a life saver in times of freak-outs!
julie94062
13 years ago
Kate,
I had my "inspiration" pulls picked out soon after I saw them in a kitchen on this site. Then I tried to find something cheaper (spent soooooooo many days/weeks on it). I ended up with what I wanted in the first place (about $12). And I have to say...they are the one thing I LOVE, even after the kitchen has been done almost a year. Every time I open a drawer or cabinet...I think about how good they feel. Seriously...still...love them!

it's finally happened. i have sticker SHOCK.

Comments (12)

leela4

bayareafrancy

Related Discussions

fabbric

kateskouros
Original Author

User

bayareafrancy

shelayne

dianalo

dianalo

caryscott

kateskouros
Original Author

julie94062

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

it's finally happened. i have sticker SHOCK.

Comments (12)

Related Discussions

kateskourosOriginal Author

kateskourosOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

kateskouros
Original Author

kateskouros
Original Author