We just recently renovated. The trim color we picked is BM Linen White. I also didn't want a stark white and IMO it's a soft, creamy white and we love it. You might even be able to get a sample jar in your paint store. Here's a pic.

That looks very nice. Love the green, too.

I went to BM and got several of their off-white color strips. Looked at where they were placed in relation to each other on their display of off-whites. Picked some strips close together where I liked a lot of them, and some strips farther apart in different directions--just so I could see the whole range more clearly. There are a lot of white! Once home with them, it was easy to see which tended toward gray, which to tan, which to cream, and which to a clearer, lemony yellow.

I'm looking for a creamy white. I held my color strips against other off-white things here at home and that gives a great comparison method, too. Once I pick a couple, I'll go get samples and paint some scraps of drywall.

Right now, I like their color strip that ranges from the lightest/least saturated "Mountain peak white" to the deeper/most saturated "Alpine white". I'm liking "cotton balls" on there awfully much.

I'd love to know what you end up picking.

We went with White Down, and our walls are Natural Linen, and accent colour is Stanley Park. I thought of it as a nice soft white, we had also looked at White Cloud - but it was too white.

A long time ago, I'd taken a decorating class (night class) at our local college, the instructor had held up 7 or so off white colour samples, all looked white to us. Then he held them up with a pure white board as a background and we could see the whites had different bases, yellow, blue, pink, purple, and he stressed how important it was to know the dominant shade in your furniture or flooring, since the off white colour, depending on it's base, would conflict or get along with the other colours in the room. We ended up hiring someone to help us decide what colours we liked!

Let us know what you go with...good luck!

Calming Cream, just a hint of yellow.

BM White Down is my kitchen wall color--a nice, light warm white. Molding and ceiling is a very white color. Looks crisp and clean, while still being warm.

All of our trimwork and insides of closets is BM Timid White. A beautiful, rich soft white.

BM White Dove for me..

BM Sebring White...no yellow undertones. We live in the south (where it is HOT!) and have windows everywhere and tons of natural light. Sunlight gives everything a warm tint. I wanted to a cooler white to make things feel cool even if it was 105 degrees outside. Also, our trim is oil based and I knew it would yellow over time. I really like this trim color for our climate and light intensity.