Thoughts on revised (again) kitchen?

11 years ago

Summerfield was so wonderful as to do a draft of both floors of my house. (http://ths.gardenweb.com/forums/load/build/msg0713343110459.html?5177). I think the upstairs is absolutely perfect, and the main floor is, with the possible exception of the kitchen. I am in talks with the GC, hoping for a late winter/early spring build, so it's time to get settled on this.

Summerfield's great draft:

I do want a few changes, however. I want a smaller island to give more clearance around it, and I don't want the fridge next to the pantry door, where it won't be able to open fully. So, I was planning on moving the fridge and range both towards the sink. However, this leaves me with about 24" of counterspace and cabinets between the pantry and fridge, fridge and range, and range and corner. Those cabinets are going to be awfully tiny.

I had another idea:

What do you think about putting the fridge next to the desk and the microwave above the range (I forgot to draw it in)? I realize it puts the fridge a long ways from the sink. I would be open to the idea of a prep sink in the counter next to the pantry. This would give acres of open counterspace, great flexibility with cabinets. Plus, I wasn't quite sure what to do with that space next to the desk--I wouldn't want to put much food right next to a computer monitor, so I think it would become a clutter space. We had talked about an oven stack, but its simply not in the budget.

You all had such great thoughts before, I hope you don't mind a few more! Thanks!!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

Cavimum
11 years ago
Friends of ours completely redid their kitchen a few years ago. They put the microwave under the counter of their island. She loves it. They had the cabinet maker make the space a finished shelf (sleeve) so they could slide in any brand of countertop MW. Might that work in your kitchen?
rosie
11 years ago
Regarding moving the stove, seems to me its current position within your L+island has determined the position and dimensions of the island, of the living/dining room and furniture, and of the library. Mess too much with that, and you have to reconfigure everything. The only reason important enough to do that would be to turn the kitchen into a galley across the end (which would mean recentering the stove on the wall, etc., etc.). So, if you are keeping the L+island, then the stove stays pretty much where it is.

And, sure, shorten the island--as long as it still appears to line up with the stove.

OTOH, you're obviously option-rich for refrigerator placement, whichever you prefer. Don't like it next to the pantry door? Move it. Or move the pantry door, another option-rich area. Regarding desk position, less efficient, but my own preference would be to keep it off to the side, somewhere, visually. I'd also wonder if wider refrigerators were going to be common in future and would plan for that now.
Related Discussions
Revision 1 of plans. Thoughts?
Q
Comments (8)
How big is your family? I'm unable to see the first floor so it is hard to say. My first thoughts though, were exactly yours...change 2nd floor laundry to a bathroom, and change the bathroom into 2 closets. Really wish I could see your first floor plan. I'm wondering if, by looking at the 2nd floor, if your plan isn't very similar to ours. I 2nd the suggestions to not have a 2 story great room. Our plan originally had that, and that is the 1st thing I changed. We changed to 9 foot ceilings, and put a family room up there. This also allowed me to change a bedroom up there into a bigger bathroom, and enlarge the bedroom sizes. I too, thought I wanted the high vaulted 2 story great room...until we spent a weekend at my sisters new home. If you are upstairs, you can hear everything going on downstairs, and vice versa. Until then, I was unaware that sound could travel like that! If my kids were older, near the age of leaving the nest, I might have considered keeping the 2 story great room, but they are only 5 and 8...and very noisy, especially when friends or cousins are over! Our Foyer will be 2 story though...so I'm hoping and praying it will be ok! Good luck with your decisions! I'll be looking forward to seeing your 1st floor.
...See More
Doors Again- Revised- Opinions please.. Again :) :)
Q
Comments (41)
Thanks Alison! I actually found a picture in the "where do you put your recycling thread from lolauren that I think was really clever... I love this idea b/c it would make the trash accessible from the sink on the sink wall w/o having to step around the counter... I am going to check w/ our cabinet maker to see if this will work w/ a pull out bin that pulls out towards the front... of course I know it won't be able to pull out in both directions but even so it would be easier I think if there is some way to do it (I'm worried about how the glides would attach of course if that door is operable, but hopefully he can come up w/ something... IF it can work, I'll put a single door cabinet there I guess and then one to match on the other side of the drawers.
...See More
revised kitchen layout
Q
Comments (17)
Re: 48" aisle on sink run...the sink, in Marybeth1's OP is pulled out what looks like 6" so the aisle is really only 42" in front of the sink. Yes, I know about the traffic issue. B/c of the overall layout of her house though, I'm not sure there's much that can be done if she switches from the current peninsula (which does direct traffic away from the work areas) to an island. People being what they are will always go for the perceived shortest route. The main reason I showed the traffic was to demonstrate that the area b/w the Kitchen & FR really isn't a much used traffic area and you could put a table there or extend the island into it w/o an impact on traffic flow. B/c of the traffic issue to the bedrooms, I think the aisles will all need to be at least 42".
...See More
Revised plans #2 back from architect - thoughts appreciated!
Q
Comments (24)
I think it's the shower causing problems in the master bath. If you turn it 90 degrees, look how much more nicely things fit together -- the bathroom no longer has to be so deep -- in fact, if you move the door to the end of the room, this is my plan's bathroom layout. It's a workhorse of a plan: modest in size, keeps everything close, functional. I very much like the connection between the bathroom and the closet -- they're located together, but you don't have to walk through the entire bathroom to reach the closet. Best of both worlds. I agree with the idea of turning the Great Room the other direction -- similar to the shower, its forcing the house to be quite long. Bonus: If you bump the Great Room out, you may be able to have windows on three sides. However, I think you have unnecessary bump-outs in other parts of the house; I'd simplify the exterior shape. Hallways: With a long ranch house, you're going to have to have hallways. It's just part of the package. I don't think yours are outrageous for the size of the house, though pretty much any hallway is wasted space. I like the concept of the Keeping Room (though I don't like the name much -- I'd have to call it something else). However, I note that all the pictures L-Lass shared above -- very nice pictures -- are more of an alcove, a nook, an extension of the kitchen, whereas the one in the picture is an actual ROOM. I think I like the alcove /nook rendition better. I like the concept, but I'm not sold on the execution of this room at all. And I wouldn't want it to be large at all: Just big enough for two easy chairs. I think I'd like the Keeping Room if it were in the spot now occupied by the dining room -- of course, that idea doesn't mesh with the overall design. Absolutely nothing is "killer" about a straight set of stairs. They're the most common type of stairs, and it's rare to hear of an injury, much less a "killing". I like CP's kitchen much better than the original. The original had too much space in the middle, and you'd always be too far from where you needed to be. This galley kitchen is functional and nicely laid out. You have your serious work space in the galley area, and off to the side you have space for beverages and a spot to keep a cake or a fruit basket -- but that's all out of the way. I like the pantry too, though I don't understand the storage between the garage and the pantry. I also wouldn't do two exterior doors into the garage; instead, consider this door arrangement: This allows you to walk into the mudroom, and if you have groceries, the pantry's right there ... but if you don't, you keep walking straight ahead. I'd also go with pocket doors for the pantry. You'd probably keep the doors open most of the time anyway, and this would mean your doors wouldn't cover up a part of the shelving when they're open. Finally, I'd use motion-sensored lights inside the pantry so you'd never enter a dark room with your hands full of groceries.
...See More
bellsmom
11 years ago
Keep in mind that, as I know you realize, suggestions are just to be considered, evaluated, and used or not. Just possibilities.

1. I agree you need the extra aisle width at the ends of the island, especially since, if you move the Fridge, both passages will be interrupted by the opening of doors (fridge and DW).

2. Can you put a MW over a range and still have a good hood? I don't think that would work. And a good exhaust is really important.

3. I agree with rosie that the centered range is pleasing to the eye and I would think hard before shifting it to either side.

4. My solution would be, as you suggest, Fridge by the desk, even though it might crowd the desk. Then put the MW in the island as Cavimum suggested.

5. Even better would be to put a drawer MW in the island (they are SO much easier to access than a regular one when placed below counter) if you can afford it. They do cost a few hundred more than a regular MW.

6. And even on such a small island, I would include a prep sink into one corner. One only 12'' wide and perhaps 15'' deep would fit. Small but invaluable.

The last two suggestions come from my own experience with my kitchen remodel. I didn't really think I would often use the prep sink. WRONG.
I also didn't think I would especially like a drawer MW and my DH was sure he would not. We were both wrong on that.

The prep sink on your island, just a step or two from the range, will be used often. There will be still be more than two feet of space beside it. Not optimal, but useful.

Sandra
lavender_lass
11 years ago
Cam- Your wife has been quite insistent about the desk...and you're crowding her out, bit by bit. First the microwave and now the fridge...it will end up being a landing space for the fridge. Great layout wise, not good for the 'desk space' idea.

If you really want the desk (and it seems she really does) than don't put ANY kitchen appliances or accessories, in that area. Maybe a narrow bookcase/cabinet, where you have the microwave, to divide the desk area from the work area. This could be storage for phone books, paper, supplies, etc. and maybe a small message board above.

For the kitchen, the fridge and range are fine (as is) if you add a small spacer, between the fridge and the pantry. According to GW, if you have a spacer the doors will open all the way and make cleaning much easier.

I think the island would be 4'10" if you added the 8" between the island and sink/dishwasher. Roomy enough for two stools and maybe a good place for the microwave. Otherwise, what about moving the range towards the sink (lose window) and having the microwave, between the fridge and range? I wouldn't put one over the range...it's possible, but not only is the vent normally not as good, but it's a fire hazard, reaching over the burners.

Just my two cents...

Thoughts on revised (again) kitchen?

Comments (4)

Cavimum

rosie

Related Discussions

bellsmom

lavender_lass

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US