troubleshooting electrical line on gas range

13 years ago

We have a 22 year old house, bought it about 5 years ago. I believe the original owners had an electric stove and replaced it with a gas stove at some point. I bought a new gas stove about 3 years ago to replace the gas stove that came with the house. Last week, the stove stopped working (electrically)...there is enough power to light the digital clock but that's about it...the electric ignition on the range and the oven does not work, and the oven light does not work. At first, I thought it was a bad stove, but I plugged it into another 115 outlet with an extension cord and it all works fine, so it seems there's something wrong with the dedicated outlet behind the stove. I've checked the voltage in the outlet and it reads 119.6 volts.

I went under the house to look at the wiring and found a big wire going from the circuit breaker (50 amp double pole) to the stove...it's a 3-wire 240V line with two insulated wires, and one bare wire...thus my belief that there was originally an electric stove. Whoever re-wired the 115 outlet for the gas stove used a wire nut to connect the black and white wires from the 115 outlet to one of the insulated and bare wires, respectively, of the 240 line. The other insulated wire of the 240 line is just wrapped in electrical tape. The ground wire from the 115 line was basically just sitting inside the 115 outlet box (metal) on one end and not connected to anything else on the supply end. There was a small (maybe 20 ga.) green wire that was screwed to the outlet box and then connected to a water line (copper pipe) under the house...I guess that is some type of dedicated ground line since there is no ground wire in the 240 line? I am assuming whoever wired this did it correctly as it has seemingly worked for a long time now, but for whatever reason, it doesn't work any more. Any ideas or suggestions as to how to troubleshoot this? Thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

hendricus
13 years ago
I am assuming whoever wired this did it correctly as it has seemingly worked for a long time now

1. A 240 line does NOT have a neutral, only 2 hots and a ground

2. You are feeding a 15 or 20 amp outlet with a 50 amp breaker, kinda dangerous.

This setup works but is not correct.

What you should do is run a new line of 12/2 wire with a 20 amp breaker, disconnect the 240 line by removing the 50 amp breaker.

Leave the 240 line in place and save the 50 amp breaker in case someone in the future wants an electric stove.
0
mike_kaiser_gw
13 years ago
A proper 120v circuit has a hot, neutral, and a ground. What you describe is a hot and a ground. While such an arrangement will function it's certainly not to code and potentially dangerous.

As suggested your best bet is to run a new 20-amp circuit.

The other alternative and I'm not sure if current code allows this is to remove the existing 50 amp, double pole breaker and replace it with a 20 amp, single pole breaker. Use one of the two insulated wires in the existing cable as your hot and the other as the neutral. The uninsulated wire is the ground. The problem is that the heavier wire typically won't fit in a 20 amp breaker or receptacle. So you need to connect a short length of 12 ga. wire at each end of the two heavy wires, most likely with a split bolt.

I'm sure someone will comment on if such a method meets current code.
0
Related Discussions
Changing from Electric to Gas Range
Q
Comments (21)
We moved from electric cooktop to gas cooktop too a decade ago. We had gas just below in an cement gas furnace room, as well as a gas range so one of those got tapped. Cost: $200. Check your city code: emergency turn off valves may be required, as well as specific code diameter of gas pipe (half inch for us I think). Investigate your range purchase specs for what diameter gas pipe hook up is required and match that. I've seen one require 3/4" gas pipe. This may save you aggravation and money later on. Know where your house gas turn off valve is (black or blue is common) to turn off, as well as your out side gas meter location for access, and put your gas company's number in your cell phone or other in case of emergency as your gas company must have people immediately responsive to their gas customers. A cooktop with drawers underneath allows the emergency shut off valve to be prominent in blue or blue towards the rear of the draw ensemble. Easily accessed. A range is a different story: 400 pounds of range defies emergency pull out alone. Some run an emergency valve to the cabinet above; others run the line out one of the side of the range. If code doesn't require this, some may just rely on shutting the main gas valve off down below. Painting this valve blue or black, and water red and showing family members their location may truly be of benefit to all. I've used my red one once and glad I knew where it was. For gas cooking though, you have less time, and I'm planning the shut off valve near the range. I love to cook on a gas cooktop. I bet I'd like induction too. Lucky we have these choices and regular supply of both gas and electricity.
...See More
Is a gas oven/range better for resale value than electric?
Q
Comments (45)
I have had gas and electric ranges over the years, but for the last 30+ I have cooked on electric until I moved and our new condo had a gas range. Everyone was all agog over it and told me I would LOVE the gas range that it was so much better than electric. For the last 20 years before our move, I cooked on smooth top electric ranges and loved them! But everyone kept telling me gas was better. Turns out, I DO NOT love the gas range. It doesn't boil water as fast as my electric one did and seems to take forever to preheat the oven. And I've had a hard time adjusting to the fact that if I don't use hot pads to remove my pans off the stove top, I'll burn my hands. And don't leave your stirring spoon in the pot for more than a second if you don't want to burn off a finger or two. My cookies don't rise -and they're either not done enough or too done, can't get it just right like before. AND the worst part is cleaning it! That's the main reason I switched to a smooth top all those years ago - they take a little getting used to the different cleaning method, but when you learn the tricks, they're a breeze compared to the old coil or this gas behemoth! It takes me a good hour to clean around all the burners and try to be careful not to get cleaner or food down those little slots around the sides. And even using a degreaser detergent, it still looks greasy after going over it several times. Give me my smooth top back! . . . where I can just scrap off the burnt on food with a razor blade - or if there isn't anything burnt on, I can just wipe on a little cleaner and polish it off with a paper towel. When wiping down the countertops with a little dish soap, I can include the stovetop and keep it sparkling clean on a daily basis. I have severe arthritis in my hands and moving those heavy grates off the top and then the cleaning around all the little places is just a little too much for me (not to mention getting gunk off the grates). That is why, after 2 1/2 years of trying to get used to it, I have decided to replace my gas range with a brand new smooth top electric range. People tell me I must be CRAZY because I'm the only person they know who prefers electric over gas. The only thing I will miss is turning off the heat immediately when something boils over. So I will have to get used to moving the pan off again. But it's worth it to me to clean up a boil over on the smooth top vs. the gas burner-cover-slots thing. AND I'll have my wonderful convection oven back and maybe my cookies too!
...See More
Electric to Gas Range and Ventilation/Hood Question
Q
Comments (8)
We did this. Our 1950s electric range had no ventilation above it (for ~75 years mind you since our house was built in 1939). We converted from oil to natural gas and are currently in the midst of a partial renovation which includes adding an above range hood for our new gas range. We don't have an upstairs so the ventilation is going through the roof. We lost some cabinet space. Didn't want a micro above it. People love their induction cooktops but I am too primal apparently and IMHO it had certain limitations for me regarding canning, so gas was the winner in the end.
...See More
Gas Line in Rural Area - Just for Range?
Q
Comments (28)
It occurs to me that there is more to the power-outage thing than just gas versus induction. Virtually all major-brand gas stoves these days come with microprocessor-driven circuit boards that run the oven(s). Those are as vulnerable to power outages, surges, etc. as on induction stoves. Typically, there will be fewer boards to replace, so repair will be somewhat less expensive when the electronics get toasted on a gas range than on an induction range. Note that I said "somewhat." That's from experience. Several years ago. I discovered that how expensive it can be when the control boards died on my former GE gas range. The cost of the boards was so high that I decided I might as well get a new stove instead. There is a bit of an irony here. If you spend a lot of money to buy a "pro-style" gas range (say, Blue Star, NXR, etc.), you likely get a stove with less electronics that are often easier and less expensive to replace. Pro-style gas stoves have simple electrical-mechanical components for the oven without microprocessor-driven control boards. Of course, you still can't run the ovens without electricity to power the thermostat and oven ignitor, but the parts are less susceptible to power problems and can be relatively inexpensive to replace. With thermostatic oven control valves on virtually all gas ranges, you cannot light the ovens in a power outage because the gas won't flow without electrical power. (To avoid those, you need a vintage/antique range or an obscure off-the-grid model or throw quarry tiles in your gas bbq.) Some of the mid-to-higher priced gas stoves these days also use those boards to control the gas flow to the stovetop burners. That will prevent you from lighting those burners with a match when there are power outages or when the electronics die. Gotta read the manuals to find out which ranges have that limitation. (Basically, verify that there are match-lighting instructions in the owner's manual a/k/a "use and care instructions").
...See More
hydrogeo99
Original Author
13 years ago
OK, thanks so much for the advice. I will definitely abandon the 240V line (removing the 50 amp breaker but leave the line in place for potential future use). Something just didn't look quite right with the way it had been "rigged" to work and I'm glad to know it wasn't done to code.
Is it possible to just tie the stove receptacle into an existing 20 amp line (e.g. the dishwasher, garbage disposal, or the other kitchen outlets) or does the stove need its own dedicated 20 amp circuit?
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
"Is it possible to just tie the stove receptacle into an existing 20 amp line (e.g. the dishwasher, garbage disposal, or the other kitchen outlets) or does the stove need its own dedicated 20 amp circuit?"

This would be fine unless the stove instructions require a seperate citcuit (they rarrly do).

Check the circuit loads (neither DW or GD is usually very large) and a gas stove only needs power for lights, clocks, and ignitors.

Putting a gas stove on the kitchen counter circuits is an allowed exception.
0
hydrogeo99
Original Author
13 years ago
For now, I tied into the dishwasher line. All of the kitchen receptacles must be wired in the walls as I couldn't find any wires going up into the walls from the crawlspace...the closest accessible 120v 20A line under the house was the dishwasher line. Since the stove sits in an island the power had to come under the house in the crawlspace. Not sure why the dishwasher was wired under the house but it was. If you think this is not up to code or unsafe, please let me know and I will have an electrician add a single pole 20A breaker in my panel for a dedicated line to the stove.
0
joed
13 years ago
As long as all the connections are in junction boxes you will be fine.
0
hydrogeo99
Original Author
13 years ago
Yes, the abandoned 240 line ends in a junction box with the wire ends capped off and the tie in to the dishwasher line is also done in a junction box. Thanks to all who posted...your help is much appreciated!
0

troubleshooting electrical line on gas range

Comments (7)

hendricus

mike_kaiser_gw

Related Discussions

hydrogeo99
Original Author

brickeyee

hydrogeo99
Original Author

joed

hydrogeo99
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

troubleshooting electrical line on gas range

Comments (7)

hendricus

mike_kaiser_gw

Related Discussions

hydrogeo99Original Author

brickeyee

hydrogeo99Original Author

joed

hydrogeo99Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

hydrogeo99
Original Author

hydrogeo99
Original Author

hydrogeo99
Original Author