skip to main content

Woodworking Experts:Please help with a MDF wood question.....

15 years ago

Have my heart set on a bathroom vanity from Vanico-Maronyx Company but can't really afford the ones they do in wood. They also make their vanities in MDF wood and its described on their website as:

"Excel medium density fiberboard (density 32% higher than standard MDF) covered with a slice of wood, grooved and then finshed with clear lacquer; 2 coats of lacquer applied in cross coats,(horizontally and verically; waterproofing and non-yellowing lacquer containing 40% of solid matter; resistant to humidity; final thickness of 4 to 5 mil, which is close to double the industry standard"

I contacted the company about the formaldehyde content of the product and was told:

"The MDF and particle board used in the production are both urea formaldehyde and specs are standing that they are less than 0.30 ppm. The lacquer is solvent base and we see on the tech sheet that "This product has a very low formaldehyde emission and meets the German E1 specification for formaldehyde emission. It does not contain ketones, methanol or aromatics and is also free from D.O.P. and D.B.P. plasticizers. HAPs free solvents."

We have a 5x8 bathroom with a skylight and a vent but no window. Given some of the info I've read on posts, I am thoroughly confused as to whether this is a wise (& healthy!) purchase.

Can anyone out there translate this for me and tell me what you think??

Thanks!!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

Jon1270
15 years ago
I think you're looking for a biochemist rather than a woodworker on this one. I know that I'm thoroughly unqualified to analyze those numbers in anything like an authoritative manner. Nevertheless, my understanding is that formaldehyde is, and has been for a long time, an extremely common presence in all sorts of building materials. Unless your house was specially built by someone who spared no expense and bent over backwards to avoid formaldehyde-laden materials, it seems unlikely that one cabinet, sealed inside a heavy film finish, would have much impact on the overall formaldehyde levels in the house. As to the small size of the room, consider that any given person will not be spending extended periods of time in that room, and that most of the time the door will be open so the air in the room will mix with the air in the rest of the house. Anytime the heat or AC is running, air will be circulated in and out of that room by force.

Unless I knew that I or someone in my family was especially sensitive to the stuff, I wouldn't worry over this for a moment.
User
15 years ago
Agree with jon, with this added. MDF and lacquer are both susceptable to moisture damage, unless the lacquer is of the catalysed variety---which variety it is I have no idea.

I think I'd do some more looking/saving or try replanning to allow for the better material.
Related Discussions
Painted wood or MDF shaker cabinet doors, we need help making a d
Q
Comments (3)
We too wanted painted cabinets and many places suggested paint grade maple rails & stiles with an MDF centre. That allows for some expansion/contraction with less visible cracking as could happen with all wood. We went with a modified shaker style with a mini-V-groove which we were told would give an bit of additional insurance. They were installed in June and we live in a climate with very dry, cold, snowy winters and so far, so good. Interestingly, some of the most expensive painted cabinets we looked at were all MDF which surprised us. We had a bit of a concern about the MDF chipping at the edges.
...See More
Xpost -- woodwork questions for 1905 home
Q
Comments (1)
I grew up in a house with chestnut woodwork....and I believe that's what you have. Mineral spirits and paint thinner are the same thing....neither will remove varnish, paint nor shellac....just wax and grease. it won't even remove a drop of milk or any sugar-ey dirt. I bel;ieve that historically, shellac was what was used in that period....if you don't want shine....hit it with 10 ought steel wool....or 6 ought... Don't wax it....with an open grain like chestnut it will build up in the grain and be awful! I would use a wiping stain.....and mix and test and mix and test.....and when you get it right remember what you did! It can be done! I have done it. Good luck! Linda C
...See More
Painted White Cabinets: Wood Quality-MDF or Maple?
Q
Comments (20)
thank you guys..actually i realized that the granite we liked is not Bianco Antico but a very similar granite called Delicatus. I love it! But no matter how many searches I do online, I dont see it paired with antique brown cabinets. I have seen it with almost every other stained cabinet there is but not the stain we are choosing. DH does not want to go darker or lighter on the cabinet stain and thinks Delicatus will go just fine. Our designer is trying to push a more golden granite on us and thinks that I should stick to all warm tones...although she is the expert I somehow feel that Delicatus just might work. It has so many colors in it that I think it will compliment the brown cabinets pretty nicely. But then is the question of the flooring..Dark brown cabinets, Delicatus granite, and nutmeg stained oak floors scraped lightly. Do you think there are too many different colors going on there?
...See More
MDF or Wood door?
Q
Comments (6)
I really think you should see a door sample in person. I looked at an MDF door from one company versus their wood door with an MDF panel in the middle and the solid MDF door looked plasticy and fake. I thought the same thing about the edges being too rounded, not defined enough, and that the door looked like it was poured into a mold. The photo looks great and then when you see it in person, it looks totally different. I've noticed that about a few other things too. (The knobs on the rangetop I'm considering, for example, looked really huge in person and not what I was expecting.) Especially if you are spending a lot of money on something, it's better to see it in person, even if you have to delay the order. I was told the same thing about painted cabinets and am considering a solid wood door with an MDF panel in the center. It's a world of difference between that and the solid MDF door. Also, some of the laminate counters look very nice, but if you are concerned mainly about your budget, I've read in other posts that the laminate counters can be as expensive as some of the granites. The Caesarstone I was considering was actually more expensive than the granite. You might want to get prices on all of them (if you haven't already). Hope this helps!
...See More
randykap
Original Author
15 years ago
Thank you both for your imput. My husband did find out the company meets stringent German E-1 standards for formaldehyde emissions and those are 7 times lower than is what is allowed under OSHA.

Appreciate your comments- I really have to stop obsessing about this!!!

Related Stories

COLOR Paint-Picking Help and Secrets From a Color Expert

By Tiffany Carboni

Advice for wall and trim colors, what to always do before committing and the one paint feature you should completely ignore

DECORATING GUIDES Ask an Expert: How to Decorate a Long, Narrow Room

Distract attention away from an awkward room shape and create a pleasing design using these pro tips

MOST POPULAR Pros and Cons of 5 Popular Kitchen Flooring Materials

Which kitchen flooring is right for you? An expert gives us the rundown

GARDENING AND LANDSCAPING Expert Talk: Porch Swings Sway Into Sweet Life

By Lawrence Karol

Their lilting rhythms and tastes of the good life beckon. See how professional designers heeded the porch-swing call

HOME OFFICES Quiet, Please! How to Cut Noise Pollution at Home

By Christine Ciarmello

Leaf blowers, trucks or noisy neighbors driving you berserk? These sound-reduction strategies can help you hush things up

WINTER GARDENING Pruning Secrets for Exquisite Roses

By Annie Thornton

Encourage gorgeous blooms year after year with this time-tested advice on how to prune your rosebush in winter for health and shape

HEALTHY HOME How to Childproof Your Home: Expert Advice

By Becky Dietrich, Interior Designer

Safety strategies, Part 1: Get the lowdown from the pros on which areas of the home need locks, lids, gates and more

DECORATING GUIDES Expert Talk: Designers Open Up About Closet Doors

By Lawrence Karol

Closet doors are often an afterthought, but these pros show how they can enrich a home's interior design

BATHROOM DESIGN Expert Talk: Frameless Showers Get Show of Support

By Lawrence Karol

Professional designers explain how frameless shower doors boosted the look or function of 12 bathrooms

TASTEMAKERS A New Decorating Book Celebrates Expert Style Mixing

By Becky Harris

Old-world classic, traditional and modern elements harmonize in Stephen Sills' gift-worthy new decorating book

Sponsored

More Discussions

hall tree hell. HELP!

25

Handrail paint advice needed

5

White Oak Stain Wash Difference

10

custom not so custom floating bunk bed help

33

are these kitchen cabinets worth keeping?

2