Painted White Cabinets: Wood Quality-MDF or Maple?
newhomebuyer1
12 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (20)
ladyshadowwalker
12 years agonewhomebuyer1
12 years agoRelated Discussions
Trim...MDF or Painted Maple?
Comments (17)We had MDF in our old home and really liked it. However, we didn't have kids at the time. The thing about MDF is that is can dent easily. With wood you can putty dents and things but I am not sure if you can with MDF, that may be a question to ask. I think the MDF looked really nice, we used an high quality oil based paint on it so the finish was really hard and durable. The paint went on very well. The other consideration is the moisture sensitivity of MDF. If you have it in locations that can get damp like a bathroom you may have some trouble with it if it isn't sealed well and a lot of water gets on it. As far as price...our last home was in a different area and the MDF was considerably less expensive than real wood of any species. The home we are building now the wood is less expensive than MDF since MDF is not commonly used in this area for some reason. We have decided to do real wood trim in our current home since we have two little boys and two dogs. We feel the real wood will hold up better and can be repaired if something happens. I agree that the paint has everything to do with the prep and quailty of paint used, we will go with the crazy expensive oil based paint from Sherwin Williams again since it held up so well with the last home....See MorePainted wood or MDF shaker cabinet doors, we need help making a d
Comments (3)We too wanted painted cabinets and many places suggested paint grade maple rails & stiles with an MDF centre. That allows for some expansion/contraction with less visible cracking as could happen with all wood. We went with a modified shaker style with a mini-V-groove which we were told would give an bit of additional insurance. They were installed in June and we live in a climate with very dry, cold, snowy winters and so far, so good. Interestingly, some of the most expensive painted cabinets we looked at were all MDF which surprised us. We had a bit of a concern about the MDF chipping at the edges....See MorePainted Flat Panel Cabinet doors - MDF or wood panel?
Comments (17)From the attached link: Raised Panel - Solid Even though the panel is called solid, it is not usually made of a single piece of wood. Wood expands and contracts with changes in humidity, and this can cause the door to split and crack. To counteract the problems of natural movement in a solid wood center panel, the panel is usually constructed using several pieces of solid stock lumber glued together. The wood strips used to construct the panel may not all match in graining and color. As in the case of the slab door, the door's strength comes from the manner in which the pieces of solid wood are reversed as they are glued. The panel is then cut on all four sides, so the center is higher than the edges. The face of the panel is usually flush with the front surface of the stiles and rails, with the edges forming a tongue which fits a corresponding groove cut into the door frame. The groove is slightly larger than the panel's edge to allow the panel to float in the frame. This simply means that the panel has room to expand and contract during humidity changes, reducing the risk of the panel cracking or splitting. I gather from the Woodmode site that this is how they construct raised panel doors as they describe their raised panel doors as being constructed from solid wood. How big an issue the movement of the centre panel in a flat panel door will be probably depends on geography (I have seen some dramatic examples here that am sure would not be acceptable to many folks while I tend to think the hairline cracking I have seen is part of the charm and patina of age of painted cabinetry. In terms of Woodmode they do kiln dry all their wood which may in part explain why they have not have felt they would get better performance from an MDF centre panel that some companies are opting for. I also think it is a market issue a lot of Consumer's in the US have a real aversion to composite wood products regardless of the possible benefits (this does not really carry over to Europe or Canada). Cabico and many other Quebec companies offer 100% MDF doors for paint finishes (same opaque finishes are usually available on maple at Cabico). Lots of their MDF door styles are raised panel. Here is a link that might be useful: Explanation of door styles...See MorePainted cabinets- solid wood door or MDF?
Comments (1)MDF is the preferred material for painted cabinets. Solid wood moves around too much, unless you have perfect in home humidity control. Then your coatings crack....See Morecolorfast
12 years agoladyshadowwalker
12 years agoangie_diy
12 years agobreezygirl
12 years agonewhomebuyer1
12 years agoangie_diy
12 years agojillandmatt
12 years agonewhomebuyer1
12 years agowolfgang80
12 years agosuzanne_sl
12 years agobreezygirl
12 years agocolorfast
12 years agoKitchenCabinetKings
12 years agonewhomebuyer1
12 years agoladyshadowwalker
12 years agobreezygirl
12 years agobreezygirl
12 years ago
Related Stories
FURNITUREHolding Out for Quality
Cheap furniture has its place, but more shoppers are waiting to invest for the long haul
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNWhat Goes With Wood Cabinets?
Make those high-quality cabinets look their best by pairing them with the right colors and materials
Full StoryKITCHEN CABINETSNew This Week: 3 Modern Kitchens That Rock Warm Wood Cabinets
Looking for an alternative to bright white? Walnut cabinetry offers the perfect tone to warm things up
Full StoryWHITE KITCHENS4 Dreamy White-and-Wood Kitchens to Learn From
White too bright in your kitchen? Introduce wood beams, countertops, furniture and more
Full StoryMATERIALSWoodipedia: Maple Is a Marvel Around the House
A heavy hardwood with lots of potential, maple appeals to modern sensibilities and won't break your budget
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNCooking With Color: When to Use White in the Kitchen
Make sure your snowy walls, cabinets and counters don't feel cold while you're riding white's popularity peak
Full StoryDECORATING GUIDES8 Qualities of Great Interior Design
We identify some elusive attributes of excellent interiors to get you past "I know it when I see it"
Full StoryKITCHEN DESIGNKitchen of the Week: Brick, Wood and Clean White Lines
A family kitchen retains its original brick but adds an eat-in area and bright new cabinets
Full StoryFURNITURESmart Shopper: How to Judge Antique Furniture Quality
Pick the treasures from the trash without expert experience by learning how to evaluate antiques and what questions to ask
Full StoryHOUZZ TOURSMy Houzz: Quality Shows in a Contemporary Dutch Home
Materials as hard wearing as they are lovely now fill this once-commercial space in the Netherlands
Full Story
newhomebuyer1Original Author