Can I stain butcher block? How do I seal?

12 years ago

We are in the middle of a complete kitchen renovation. In the pantry we have installed butcher block. This will be used for simple food prep (toaster oven will be here). I would like to stain it to match the island in the kitchen. Can I stain it and have it food safe? How do I seal this?

Featured Answer

andersons21

12 years ago

The properties of warping of wood have been thoroughly studied and understood scientifically. Casual observations relating warping to finish (or lack thereof) are faulty.

My mother had a butcherblock portion of counter for over 30 years, never oiled or finished anywhere, that never warped. I've had boards that warped and others that didn't, some finished, some unfinished, some partly finished. It's not the finish.

Wood tabletops, countertops, decks, etc. are exposed to more water on the top than the bottom, causing the top to swell and try to expand. But the wood's thickness remains stable and prevents this. The cells of wood on the top of the board become compressed from their original cylindrical shape (like a soda straw) into an oval shape. As it dries out, the wood cells do not fully regain their original shape, so the top shrinks, pulling the board concave. This is called "compression shrinkage."

Therefore, finishing the bottom of a tabletop or countertop will not prevent warping. Warping will always be cupping of the top due to swelling from wetness of the top and subsequent compression shrinkage. If lack of finish on the bottom caused warping, you would see the tabletop bow, not cup -- but this never happens.

Or think about it another way: what liquid is going to soak into the bottom of your installed butcherblock counter, that a finish is going to block? It's not going to happen. And no finish blocks water vapor (from humidity in the air), only slows it a little bit, so this would make no difference in protection either.

So if you want a tabletop or countertop not to cup over time, there are two things to consider. The most important factor is the quality of wood making up the butcherblock: the size and shape of the wood cells, their density, how the wood was cut in relation to the growth rings, and how it was dried. Butcherblock made up of dense, old-growth, quartersawn boards slowly air dried is going to hold its shape (even when totally unfinished), while strips of young, low-density, plainsawn boards are going to warp easily. Second, keep the top as dry as possible. Don't let liquids soak into it, or use a water-resistant film finish if you expect liquid exposure. It's not the finish on the bottom, it's how dry you can keep the top, that helps prevent cupping.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (8)

millworkman
12 years ago
i do not believe you can stain on it and have it be food safe, and i wood get the sealant. The companies that make the butcherblock usually offer 2 products a penetrating oil and or a sealant. Both can be used as a cutting board surface, however the sealant will show all the cuts and need to be refinished more often where as the penetrating oil just get rubbed in periodically
brickeyee
12 years ago
"i do not believe you can stain on it and have it be food safe, and i wood get the sealant."

Once cured most finishes are safe, but manufacturers are not about to go through the FDA gamut to have them declared 'food safe.'

Behlen salad bowl finish is 'food safe'
Related Discussions
Can I see your ikea butcher block?
Q
Comments (4)
I have the birch Numerer butcher block from IKEA. I love it. The colors are hard to photograph and the lighting makes a big difference, but you can see my blog post on it below, and also check out the photos of the wood when I was trying to find a paint color. (you might have to register) It seemed to me that the birch was lighter and more golden. The beech is also lighter with a slight reddish hue. The oak is darker with more "character". I wanted to have the horizontal lines in my kitchen (floor and counters) have the same color value, so I chose birch to go with my maple floors. What are your cabinets? Here is a link that might be useful: IKEA birch counter top
...See More
Where do I find this butcher block plug?
Q
Comments (7)
It looks like it might be a commercial serving/warming dish that is being used as a built-in compost bin. I think I would start looking at kitchen supply stores for something that might work. I found one but it's not as pretty as your picture; hope it gives you an idea of how to do this. Here is a link that might be useful: Link to warming tray
...See More
Sealing butcher block with floor polyurethane?
Q
Comments (7)
Remember that the Ikea butcherblock is pre-treated with their oil, so if you use an incompatible finish, it won't stick. You'd have to sand them all the way down past the existing oil finish, which might be more work than it's worth. I don't know if they're still selling their Behandla oil -- I mean the linseed-based countertop finish, not the beeswax one they have in the stores now -- but that's what I used and it has held up beautifully. It was sort of a pain to apply, but I haven't had to reapply it. It did not have a strong odor like Waterlox does (I tried a sample of that but couldn't handle the smell). I think the thinner tops have more risk of warping than the thicker ones; I believe that's what they told me at the store when I was buying ours. Still, it sounds as though you've got free countertops (well, already-paid-for countertops), so unless there's something wrong with them, I'd go with them! Just don't put in a tile backsplash yet, if they're thinner than the countertops you intend to install later.
...See More
staining and sealing butcher-block counter
Q
Comments (12)
I hope you have some samples for testing, or can detach and turn the countertop over, because just sealing can darken a finish. Also, if you don't seal the underside, they can warp. My IKEA numerar slab, sealed only on one side, warped when the humidity rose during the rainy season and there was almost an inch of difference between the edges and the center. It eventually straightened out when the humidity went back down, but it's better to prevent it. My alder countertops went from pale blonde to a reddish brown with just untinted tung oil (Waterlox). I saw the color change and canceled plans for staining it. Try the sealant alone. For an eating area, any finish will do, but consider something matte that will not show the inevitable scrapes and nicks as badly as high-gloss does. Then try several stains. You can buy tiny test packets of stain at ACE and perhaps other stores. It's convenient and cheap.
...See More
bobismyuncle
12 years ago
If you are not cutting on the surface, you can use a film-forming finish. Waterlox makes an excellent one. But any varnish would work.

Here is a link that might be useful: Folly of Food-Safe finishes.
jessicaml
12 years ago
On a related note, my husband and I started DIYing our butcher block countertops, but for various reasons are having a contractor finish the installation. I plan on sanding off the factory finish and coating with Waterlox, but do I need to wait for the pocket screws to be routed in? How about the enlarged screw holes (for movement in contraction or expansion)? I heard once that every surface should be coated to prevent warping, but I'm not sure if it meant installation holes, too. It would be nice if I could do the sanding and Waterlox now before turning the rest of the project over, but I'll wait if the router holes will need coated.
andersons21
12 years ago
Why would you sand off a factory finish and then finish with Waterlox? You cannot possibly improve the protection over a factory finish.

Coating every surface makes no difference for warping.

BTW, have you ever sanded off a factory finish? Do you know what that entails? I experimented sanding 20-year-old lacquer off my cabinet doors, to see if it would be a viable alternative to stripping. I have a powerful variable-speed random-orbital sander, and with 100 grit and probably 20 minutes of time I didn't get all the finish off on tiny little door. I have stripped other doors, and that was MUCH quicker and easier, so that's what I'll keep doing. And, my old lacquer is a thin and weak coating compared to a new factory finish of the catalyzed stuff they are using nowadays.
User
12 years ago
"Coating every surface makes no difference for warping."

I beg to differ ... I bought a small chunk of butcherblock for stain and finish testing, and only stained and top-coated on one side.

That thing warped badly, and at its worst was cupped almost an inch. It slowly went back into shape over the next several months as the moisture equilibrated, but it was definitely warped.

The first thing I do with my new butcherblock countertops will be to seal the underside with one quick coat of Waterlox.
lindac
12 years ago
Any uncoated side of wood can absorb or give off moisture and cause warping.
I have never been able to get a butcher block end grain to accept stain.

Can I stain butcher block? How do I seal?

andersons21

Comments (8)

millworkman

brickeyee

Related Discussions

bobismyuncle

jessicaml

andersons21

User

lindac

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US