skip to main content

Sealing butcher block with floor polyurethane?

9 years ago

We are contemplating redoing our kitchen in order to knock out a wall. Fingers crossed I can sell the current granite counters on craigslist. The kitchen would have to be flipped and the counters could not be reused. I'm thinking about ikea butcher block counters at least for now because solid surface is not in the budget. I have no intention of using the counter as a cutting surface and I don't want to deal with the hassle of taking everything off the counters to oil them constantly. Would I be able to seal them with a few coats of floor poly, probably oil based, and not have to worry about them?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

lazy_gardens
9 years ago
No .... it will crack and flake. Use multiple coats of classic waterlox, following their directions so it soaks in, doing BOTH sides.

No oiling required. Do NOT use ammonia-containing cleaners.

PS: Ikea's butcher block quality is in the tank, and availability is uncertain ... I used alder from perfect plank perfectplank.com
freckles81
Original Author
9 years ago
I have some old discontinued ikea butcher block counters that I was thinking of using. Possibly lagan, it's only 1" thick, not sure if that is not thick enough? I was envisioning the butcher block being a temporary solution until I can afford quartz. Although not sure how long temporary would end up being.

Why would a floor poly crack and flake? I would think floors take more of a beating than counters?
Related Discussions
Refinishing Butcher Block/ Baker's Table
Q
Comments (2)
If you are using this as a table and not as a cutting surface, then you can choose any finish you want. You have all the trade-offs of any selection of finish. Being "food safe" is not a concern, IMO.
...See More
Undermount sink in butcher block island?
Q
Comments (5)
alicia, I did it...I'm not even completely back in my kitchen yet so I can't offer much real life experience yet but I did make the decision after reading a lot on GW about others' experiences and even posting the question once. I got a lot of positive responses that it would work. So far I love it although I am still in the phase of reminding myself I don't have to chase down every drop of water!
...See More
Frustrated with staining butcher block in white and waterlox
Q
Comments (18)
I love the Monocoat finish - gorgeous. It doesn't need a sealer, NC? There's also Osmo, which is Rubio's big competitor. I think they also have a white. No, it is a standalone product, one coat only (it sticks only to raw wood so no point in putting it over itself). What they told me (about using it on stairs) was that it will wear off eventually but that reapplication is simple -- you don't have to refinish the whole piece, just wipe more Monocoat over the center of the treads where it's worn off. And it is supposed to act as a sealer; it is essentially an oil finish. They told me that [major chain restaurant, name withheld because I could be remembering it wrong] uses Monocoat on its countertops. I am of course interested in this conversation, because I have a lot of it left over from the stair treads (a little goes a long way) and it is not cheap and I want something to use it on. :) So I might have to put in wood countertops just to use up my Monocoat. lol. (Mine is the Pure = clear.) What I don't know is how well it would do around a sink, especially an undermounted one. So if someone calls them to ask (or has used it themselves on a countertop), I hope you post about it! There is a thread somewhere around here about Osmo; maybe that poster will see this too. (I don't know anything about it.)
...See More
quartz or butcher block counter (island and wall counter)
Q
Comments (3)
I think butcher block on the island with quartz on perimeter will look and function better. If you use waterlox for it, you cannot cut on it. But it will give it a nice protective furniture finish. If you want to cut on it you need to use mineral oil, which is less permanent but repairable. If you cut on it, you will see marks on it, but you can sand it and re-oil over time. You can also use an oil based finish for the more natural look but not cut on it. That what I would do. If you search here you will see discussions of waterlox versus oil versus other products like osmo for wood island tops. Breezygirl highly recommends an osmo product that I am going to use on my wood island counter once it's installed.
...See More
Vertise
9 years ago
Use appropriate products for their intended use. Use a food safe product intended for butcher block counters.
northcarolina
9 years ago
Remember that the Ikea butcherblock is pre-treated with their oil, so if you use an incompatible finish, it won't stick. You'd have to sand them all the way down past the existing oil finish, which might be more work than it's worth.

I don't know if they're still selling their Behandla oil -- I mean the linseed-based countertop finish, not the beeswax one they have in the stores now -- but that's what I used and it has held up beautifully. It was sort of a pain to apply, but I haven't had to reapply it. It did not have a strong odor like Waterlox does (I tried a sample of that but couldn't handle the smell).

I think the thinner tops have more risk of warping than the thicker ones; I believe that's what they told me at the store when I was buying ours. Still, it sounds as though you've got free countertops (well, already-paid-for countertops), so unless there's something wrong with them, I'd go with them! Just don't put in a tile backsplash yet, if they're thinner than the countertops you intend to install later.
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
9 years ago
freckles81:

Lower your expectations for your granite sale on Craigslist. If you get $300.00, you're doing really well, that's after you've removed them without breakage.
breezygirl
9 years ago
I have a walnut plank island counter that I do not use for cutting. I would never use anything but a food grade and safe substance on it.
freckles81
Original Author
9 years ago
We have been using the lagan counters as a large u shaped desk in our office, so we have gotten our moneys worth out of them.

I already stated that I do not intend on using the counters for cutting. So waterlox is the way to go?

Related Stories

KITCHEN DESIGN Butcher Block Makes the Cut for Holiday Kitchen Prep

Countertops and cutting boards will likely take a beating over the holidays. These butcher blocks have the chops to perform under pressure

HOUZZ TOURS My Houzz: Yard Seals the Deal for an Eichler Home

By Lisa Hallett Taylor

Expansive indoor-outdoor living sold a couple on this midcentury California home, now brimming with vintage finds collected over time

TINY HOUSES Adventure Seekers Hit the Road in a Cozy School Bus Home

By Mitchell Parker

Wood floors, butcher block countertops, custom furnishings and LED lights make life on the road feel like just another stylish day at home

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen Counters: Try an Integrated Cutting Board for Easy Food Prep

By Christine Tusher

Keep knife marks in their place and make dicing and slicing more convenient with an integrated butcher block or cutting board

KITCHEN DESIGN What to Know About Using Reclaimed Wood in the Kitchen

By Becky Harris

One-of-a-kind lumber warms a room and adds age and interest

DECORATING GUIDES Finish Your Floors to Perfection With Parquet

By Elements of Style

Add value and gorgeous detail to your home with timeless and elegant parquet flooring in a classic design

FLOORS Will Cork Float for Your Bathroom Floor?

By Rachel Grace

Get the facts on advantages, disadvantages, costs and installation to see if a cork bathroom floor is right for you

FLOORS 5 Benefits to Concrete Floors for Everyday Living

By Natalie Myers

Get low-maintenance home flooring that creates high impact and works with home styles from traditional to modern

FLOORS 10 Ways to Make the Most of Your Home’s Original Floors

Save yourself the cost of replacing your old floorboards with these tips for a new finish

DECORATING GUIDES Discover the Unstoppable Advantages of Cork for the Home

By Julia Pockett

Look beyond wine stoppers to see cork's ecofriendliness, durability, fire resistance and antimicrobial nature for all kinds of home products

Sponsored

More Discussions

Does anyone have Medallion cabinets in Maple Biscotti?

7

Nuage Quartzite - any water issues?

14

hello , what are your thoughts on two tone countertops?

5

cabinet overlay question

0

contractor chooses kitchen

13