Strong structural alternatives to drywall

9 years ago

Is there a dry wall alternative that has some structural integrity? My 1920 pier and beam house has 1x12 pine shiplap over the inside of the studs. This was covered with sheetrock probably 50 years ago. The pine has had insect damage in places over the years, but it is general contributes to the structure like sheeting. In our very small bathroom, replacing the wood and sheetrock with a single layer of something structural that can be taped and floated would add 2" to the length and width of the room. Its a moist environment. Cement tile backer has a number of disadvantages. The MgO boards seem to new in the US. Can you skim coat and float A/C grade plywood? Thank you... long time lurker - first time poster.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

User
9 years ago
What "disadvantages" does cement board have? It would seem to be perfect for your requirements. And why is your bedroom a "moist" environment?
0
snoonyb
9 years ago
"And why is your bedroom a "moist" environment?"

Exuberance and dedication to positive results.
0
Related Discussions
how strong are wall-mount sinks?
Q
Comments (16)
A cast iron sink correctly bolted to framing will stay put with few problems. Many public restrooms still use this type of installation. Lag screws can eventually come loose. Through bolting with large washers against the wood will hold up fine. I usually mount the 2x in the wall, lay the sink plate against it and drill matching holes. The bolts are then put through large washers (or even square of scrap steel about 2x2 inches), then a nut is attached to hold them in position. The bolts stick through the drywall (or cement board and tile) far enough to put nylon self locking bolts to hold the sink to the wall (or the bracket that the sink then attaches to). A couple of 3/8 bolts will hold just about anything you can dish out.
...See More
Alternative decking options
Q
Comments (4)
Thank you for the replies. My lower deck is about 1600 sf and the upper deck is about 400 sf. The cost of material is very important to me. The Silca grates look promising but the grate itself is about $5.5/sf shipped. The pavers are extra. And I need to add more joists to make it 16" OC. From what I read, a NW contractor got the grate for 2.50 /sf. But it is a contractor price... IPE is expensive in my area. It is about $10 /lf. And I will not be routinely staining it. Too much work for me to maintain a wood deck. I want to build a structure that serves me instead of me serving it. I may consider a composite deck if all things fail. Anyone has any experience with AWS joist plate system? The plates are only $1 /sf based on 24" OC. But I need to find the architectural concrete slabs that have a high flexural strength. I really like a hard surface deck. Very low maintainence, extremely durable, and good appeal. Scott
...See More
Alternative(s) to steel?
Q
Comments (5)
The strength of steel allows for the structural integrity required in a window using very narrow structural members. Using wood components would require additional dimensional sizing of the structural components. That steel window style shown in the photo is very aesthetically pleasing. If you are concerned about energy efficiency gains with the older window shown, there is one nice alternative to buying new windows. Many traditional homes in colder climates utilized interior hinged, wooden storm windows for these steel casements and transoms. These storm windows were easy to remove and store during warmer weather. The wooden storm windows kept frost away from the interior room side and also added another layer of protection against air infiltration. Additionally, screens were often of the roll-up or retractible style, with a housing located in the head jamb of the windows. Coincidentally, this is where Pella Roll Screen, or simply Pella, made its way into the window manufacturing business. My recollection is that Pella originally only built screens back in the early 1920's before venturing further into supplying the actual windows.
...See More
Ok to put 1/4" drywall over a pocket door frame?
Q
Comments (43)
If you plan to use a Johnson framing kit, you might take a look at this. https://jhusa.net/1515-ply-34-pocket-door-frame-plywood-clip-set The plywood is 3/4", but it is recessed into the pocket door frame so it doesn't take up additional width space. Then you could put the sheets of drywall over that. One caution: if you put drywall over plywood sheeting, don't make the same mistake I did when I re-did the exterior walls in a room of a mid-1800s house. I covered the interior side of the exterior walls, with 3/8" plywood to give lateral strength, since the original house has no sheathing under the siding, which was nailed directly over the studs. (150 years of lateral movement with wind and ground settling is why the original plaster/lath walls were beyond repair.) I didn't want to rip off the exterior siding and add sheathing, so I installed plywood over the interior side after putting in insulation, and then added sheets of drywall, which came out to identical thickness as the original plaster and lath. My mistake was to smear construction adhesive over the plywood before applying the drywall, because the wall was uneven and the drywall didn't fit snugly against the plywood at many spots. About 6 months after the drywall work was finished, I noticed hair-line cracks developing over some of the drywall joints. Although plywood is supposed to be extremely stable compared to regular wood, there is still a small amount of expansion and contraction under varying temperature and humidity conditions, and the movement was just enough to produce visible cracks. I should have just fastened the drywall at the studs without the glue, as if the plywood sheathing weren't there, allowing some structural movement under the drywall without causing it to shift enough to produce cracks. It's something I live with, since the cracks are very small and hardly noticeable to anyone but me, but I know they are there and they jump out at me every time I look at that wall.
...See More
PRO
Joseph Corlett, LLC
9 years ago
I suppose you could tape and finish plywood like drywall, but why would you? It's a huge waste of money and plywood. Additional structural support is unnecessary.
0
User
9 years ago
The only structural benefit of exterior wall sheathing is lateral bracing to resist wind and earthquake forces. A layer of new 1/2" or 5/8" drywall would add far more lateral stability than the existing shiplapped siding. Even if the siding was structural, the amount of resistance contributed by the exterior wall of your bathroom should be negligible.

If there are a lot of windows and you are concerned about lateral bracing, add diagonal 1x4's or steel straps recessed into the studs.

If you are concerned about vertical gravity loads, add some studs.

Here is a link that might be useful: wall braces
0
davis.partridge
9 years ago
Plywood does have superior structural integrity benefits versus drywall. Yet, drywall offers something that plywood does not: Better fire ratings. I prefer drywall to plywood for indoor applications for that reason.
www.lmmartin.com
0
User
9 years ago
This question is confusing. Does it only involve the exterior wall? Do the interior walls have shiplapped boards and if so why would the boards be structural? Is there no structural panel sheathing on the outside of the exterior studs?

Sheathing provides two structural benefits: 1) resistance to lateral forces parallel to the exterior wall (but only if the sheathing extends to and is properly attached to the face of the first and second floor framing) and 2) resistance to wind forces perpendicular to the exterior wall (but only if the sheathing is attached to the outside face of the exterior studs).

Boards or sheathing on the inside of the exterior studs or on any interior studs will provide little if any structural benefit to the frame of the house.

If the house doesn't have any sheathing or diagonal bracing at the exterior walls, you need to consult an engineer to design a system of interior plywood shear walls bolted to the floor structures above and below to provide adequate structural bracing. These shear walls would not necessarily be located near your bathroom.
0

Strong structural alternatives to drywall

Comments (6)

User

snoonyb

Related Discussions

Joseph Corlett, LLC

User

davis.partridge

User

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US