skip to main content

House siding preferences besides vinyl?

13 years ago

We will need to re-side our house. Take off the old siding. Maybe even replace the sheeting beneath. Definitely flash the whole house better.

It was built cheaply in the '70s with masonite-like siding over fiberboard sheeting - that fuzzy siding coated with tar on one side. Enough with the horror story...

Any preferences on siding materials? My prejudice is that vinyl is not "green" and is really bad in a fire.

Cement board? Cedar? Bark? other?

Featured Answer

izzie

13 years ago

A few houses in my neighborhood had aluminum siding, it looks really nice. One thing good about it was that it came on a large roll so there are no overlapping/seams, whatever it's called, one continuous piece. Of course not a do it yourself project. My sister has major problems with some vinyl siding after a few years it starting getting brittle. You could run your fingernails across it and gouge it, also color faded. They tried to get them to honor lifetime warrenty, no luck. The state couldn't help because the Corp office was out of state. This was a big name siding company, no honor. Probably has since closed up moved and changed name.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

User
13 years ago
Hardie-plank, installed over 1" or 2" thick rigid foam.

But, the sheathing needs to be changed to at least 1/2" OSB.
measure_twice
Original Author
13 years ago
Handymac, I had not considered exterior foam. The nails do not sag supporting Hardie-plank through 2 inches of foam?

Replacing with OSB is essentially rebuilding the exterior. OK. Hmm - how to manage the existing doors and windows with the thicker exterior?

But it is a small house with 9 moderate windows. I will price out the materials and see what it runs. There are some zero or low interest loans for certain energy efficiency improvements.
Related Discussions
Budgeted clad, prefer fiberglass, should I settle for vinyl?
Q
Comments (9)
You either have too many windows or you aren't getting good bids on the Marvin Integrity windows. I don't use the Integrity because they don't yet offer a spacer bar between the permanent mullions. Window selection should start with the features you want rather than brands and prices. Will the interior finish be painted white or stained? Do you want permanent mullions... spacers? Any special shapes or sizes? Special glass? Is it on the ocean or a mountain top? What kind of exterior cladding will the house have? Do you want a sloped sill with a drip? (yes you do) So you want a special color on the exterior? So you want a different sash color from the frame? Do you want the interior pre-finished? The answers to these questions will narrow your window options and save you a lot of time. Just give the list to the suppliers and they will tell you if they can meet your needs. The builder should be held responsible for intentionally low-balling the window allowance in his bid. I would tell him to find me some good bids to make up for this unprofessional self-serving practice. I would even explore taking the windows out of his contract if only to give him a hard time.
...See More
stenciling house numbers onto vinyl siding?
Q
Comments (5)
No reason why you couldn't. My first choice would be to use house paint. It's guaranteed to last 15 or so years outside. You can buy a small container or even look for some of the mismatched cans at the paint dept. usually for only a $1 or so per quart. Of course you could also use the Patio Paints which are designed as outdoor paints too. Or you could paint them on a square of wood and attach that to a stake or even one of the small metal flag holders that stick into the ground. Hope your project turns out great. Luvs
...See More
Clad vs wood vs vinyl vs sashes
Q
Comments (1)
The jump from wood to wood clad is not terrible and will eliminate the painting necessity in the future. Wood to fiberglass is also not a huge one and can look very classy and consistent with the architecture. Wood to vinyl is going to be the most stark and especially considering the brands that HD sells. I think you nee to figure on what you are comfortable with and go from there. There are insulated storm glass windows, however, they are probably as aesthetically morphing as a wood clad window would be if not more.
...See More
All vinyl Softlite or Sunrise vs vinyl clad Anderson 200
Q
Comments (17)
Most windows are better than Andersen. They're overpriced garbage living off of their name. I've been installing Softlite windows for over 20 years. I have also installed Marvin, Simonton, Thermal (now out of business), Crestline, Alside and a few other of brand windows. I personally use Alside windows for my business but mainly subcontract for a company that uses Softlite. Softlite would be my second choice out of all of them. Marvin's are probably the best windows of the bunch but definitely not worth the extra cost. Especially if you plan to move in 15 years. New construction type windows are great but can cause a world id issues if not installed 100%correctly. It also adds a major headache and a lot of expense in the future for the new owners or you if you end up staying. If it were me, I would save some cash and have the builders build buck frames and use replacement type windows. Since you're starting with a clean slate you can usually get a better fit and better insulated opening doing it that way.
...See More
User
13 years ago
We used screws to install the siding, nailers were not yet in our budget(working for Habitat for Humanity). OSB sheathing, 1" rigid foam installed with the plastic washered nails, and the planking installed with 2&1/2" screws.

We used 7" wide planks with a 5" reveal.
don92
13 years ago
Being a bit of a traditionalist It took me awhile to except cement board siding but since the late 90's would not use anything else. It holds stain well and is a breese to restain and does not rot.
Hardie hangs like a shingle and in a strong wind there can be some movement. For that reason ridged insulation behind it can, as you said, cause it to move more and a screw, no matter the length, does not have a big enough head on it to adequitly hold the board. 2" roofing nails are what most people use.
chris8796
13 years ago
I replaced our vinyl with fiber cement last year. I also added novabrik to one side. Everything was over 1" foam and housewrap. It is also the perfect time to change the windows, actually last year was the perfect time when they offered a 30% tax credit. So far, I really like the fiber cement.
peteinsonj
13 years ago
Consider what's being done in your neighborhood & community. Where I used to live, vinyl was very popular and considered a plus when selling. But where I live now, most people don't want vinyl. Hardi-plank is used here a lot.

Ask your neighbors & a realtor or two.

Good luck!

Related Stories

REMODELING GUIDES The Case for Linoleum and Vinyl Floors

Have pets, kids and a tight budget? Easy-care resilient floors may be the choice for you

LIFE House Rule: Off With Your Shoes

Do you prefer your guests to go shoeless in your house? Here are some ways to encourage stockinged feet

REMODELING GUIDES 9 Top Siding Materials

By Bud Dietrich, AIA

Everyone knows brick and stucco, but what about fiber cement and metal? Learn about the options in exterior siding before you choose

PATIO OF THE WEEK Keep a Secret Garden on the Side

By Becky Harris

Privacy and plantings are the focus of this Philadelphia side yard, offering a respite from a busy backyard

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Industrial Design’s Softer Side

Dark gray cabinets and stainless steel mix with warm oak accents in a bright, family-friendly London kitchen

HOUSEKEEPING How to Wash Your House

By Laura Gaskill

Avoid damage to siding and plants while getting your home's exterior shining clean, with this guide to using pressure washers and hoses

BATHROOM DESIGN How to Choose the Best Drain for Your Shower

By By Any Design Ltd.

Don't settle for a cheap fix when you can pick a shower drain that suits your style preferences and renovation codes alike

DECORATING GUIDES 11 Shutters to Enhance Every Window

By The Inman Company

Vinyl in the bathroom, café style in the kitchen, clerestory in the living room — today's shutters are terrific for every room in the home

FUN HOUZZ Here's Looking at You: A Mirror Personality Quiz

By Christine Ciarmello

What does your bathroom mirror preference say about you? We offer some speculations to go with 11 very different mirror styles

KITCHEN DESIGN Kitchen of the Week: Drab and Dysfunctional to Radiant in Minnesota

By Vanessa Brunner

Clunky storage and lackluster floors get nixed in favor of open shelves, plaid vinyl and an effective kitchen work triangle

Sponsored

More Discussions

Any idea which shingle this is?

7

Window leak, musty smell?

20

Help regarding a leaking roof

7

Advise on refinishing old wood windows?

13

Any ideas on patching an asphalt shingle roof?

4