Should we change our lot lines?

12 years ago

We own a house on a 3.5 acre lot and the neighboring 3.5 acre lot. We're going to be selling at some time in the near future. There are 2 possible scenarios:

1. The buyer of the house wants both lots.

2. The buyer of the house wants just one lot, and we'll sell the spare lot separately.

I have no idea which scenario is more likely. The buyer might really not want a neighbor that "close", or they might say "no way" to keeping an extra few acres mowed. It could go either way. We know that the way to maximize our proceeds is to sell the spare lot at a buildable lot price, not an "extra acreage" price, and that's what we intend to do. We may discount it 10% or so for a combination purchase, but not 50-60%.

Our neighbor the next house over would like to keep the land empty, but they were unwilling to pay buildable lot price for it. They would likely be willing to split the lot with the future buyer of our home, and thus keep it unbuildable forever.

The spare lot is currently for sale, BTW (sign out front) and I get a couple calls a month on it. 1-1.5 acre lots on the same street/lake have sold for $72-78K in the past year; we're asking $85K for our 3.5 acres.

Here's an aerial view of our lots. Lot A has the house, Lot B is the spare one.

As you can see, Lot A is triangle shaped and has ~1500 feet of lakefront. Lot B is a rectangle 150 feet wide and ~1000 feet long, with ~250 feet of lakefront.

We are considering making the spare lot more desirable for a potential build by changing the lot lines to increase the lakefront footage of Lot B in exchange for some "near the house" yard for Lot A, as approximated by the yellow shapes above. The land is pretty flat near the road, and has a gradual slope toward the lake. The swap would increase the options for building a house with a walkout basement on Lot B.

Should we do it?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

cas66ragtop
12 years ago
I would probably leave it alone. If a buyer comes forward and desires the lot lines to be revised, that would be the time to do so. You would be incurring additional expenses by moving the lot lines, and you may not see any return. Your idea of swapping the yellow parcels sounds good, but you are also creating some very irregularly shaped lots in doing so. Some people may not like that. If you were to move the lines at all, I would keep the yellow rectangle to be given to Lot A, and I would strike a line from the upper left corner of the yellow rectangle to the lower right corner of the yellow triangle. That makes a better lot layout. You should talk to someone in your area - possibly a land developer, or a realtor that specializes in vacant lots - to see what they think about it. Good luck!
weedyacres
Original Author
12 years ago
Bump...any other opinions? Would this change make lot B more attractive? Lot A less attractive?
Related Discussions
Should we replace our heat/air if we are moving in 2 years?
Q
Comments (22)
Yes, we use AC here from April through September. This year we even used it some in October. We will need to replace our electric heating system, also. The one we have now is resistance heat and we would go to a heat pump. There is no gas line to my house. Well that stinks. I would call the gas company to see if they have any plans to bring it to your area. At my last house we had electric heat which was a big turn off, we immediately changed it in the spring adding central air. We just replaced our gas furnace 2 weeks ago. The whole job was around $5,000. We called a few places, it was ranging up to $7,000. Be sure to look in the phone book to see if there are any coupons, also call the electric company to see what they offer. We priced cultured marble counters yesterday at Home Depot just to get an idea of price. For the master it would be about $300.00 plus the faucets. For Silestone, which we have in the kitchen, it would be about $600 to $700 plus the cost of two undermount sinks and two faucets. It might be worth it to get Silestone since it certainly is a more WOW look. Even in lower priced homes people like nice kitchens and baths. What do you think? We just did custom counters in the bath & kitchen, the price you got sounds good. Pretty sure it cost us about $3,000 total, we didn't get anything fancy.
...See More
Roof lines mean change in plan...(lots of pics)
Q
Comments (14)
You are both right...and I don't like the fridge or the oven in the aisle. After much sketching last night, I came up with this idea. What if I flipped the dining and kitchen spaces? On the othe forum, there was concern that it would be much nicer to have another access to the sunroom, besides through the laundry/mudroom. This way, I have three 30" french doors, with the left one opening. The sunroom is a few feet bigger, to allow room for the door opening and the clearance around the very small wood stove. What do you think? Any ideas/suggestions? Thanks for looking at yet another plan...I have to finalize things, so I can show our contractor and get a budget pulled together. Oh, and the other thing I like about this plan...the marble work table is back! :)
...See More
What should I change - lots of input requested
Q
Comments (30)
Jillies, the green will be cooler. The yellow is really warm! Do you wear more blues or more earth tones in clothing? Those are probably the colours you are drawn to. I'm a blue green lady personally. Maria Killam can be catty but she really makes you think about the underlying tones in colours. Beware though...once you can see the undertones clashing it will bother you forever! She thinks often if you're dissatisfied with a room and can't figure out why, it's probably undertones like a pinky beige clashing with a greenish beige. The general rule is of the rainbow we learned back in school Red orange yellow green blue purple Red, orange and yellow are warm, with orange being the warmest Green blue purple are cool with blue being the coolest. Green blue is cool but warmer than straight up blue. Yellow green is quite warm but cooler than yellow orange. Bluish (like cherry) red is cooler than orangey (like tomato) red. @davidahn....lets just say I'm more like you in that equation!! But let's weight the votes by good taste, too! Here is a link that might be useful: Maria Killam on undertones This post was edited by robotropolis on Wed, Feb 6, 13 at 17:22
...See More
Should we change our cabinet layout in open kitchen/living room/nook?
Q
Comments (2)
I can't save your screen shot (?), so I did a quick estimation of the kitchen space, using as much of the existing layout as possible. I put the fridge near the dining nook, but that wall could be flipped, with the fridge next to the DR. That would keep the clean-up area completely separate from the prep/cooking areas, but the DW door would open partially against the end of the peninsula: Everything on the clean-up wall flipped: The black arrow is for corner storage that's accessed from the back of the cabinet. Or it could be accessed from the FR side, and since you have a table nearby, the peninsula could be extended over a run of cabinets, to increase storage and make up for the lost pantry and hanging cabs. I gave you a KW mixer. :) Back with one more--if the door to the formal DR could be moved to the hallway, the range wall could be extended, and a wide island with prep sink would work. Except for storage in the middle, drawers in the second run of cabinets in the island would have easy access from the ends. Optional upper cabs beside of range hood. (Contingent on the hood being vented as in the current kitchen.) If anyone else wants to borrow this plan to experiment, please feel free.
...See More
OttawaGardener
12 years ago
If I were the buyer of Lot B, I wouldn't want that big chunk taken out. It reduces options on building closer to the road & I'd be uncomfortable with the potential for the owner of Lot A building a shed or something on that chunk.

So...I'd prefer the regularly shaped lot to what you propose, even with more waterfront. If the existing Lot B is 150' wide, a buyer has lots of room to build a house on the property as is. I doubt they'd put it over on the extended part. But that's just my opinion.
sweet_tea
12 years ago
Leave both lots alone.

Lot B is similar in shape and waterfront linear footage as most other lots in the photo.

The only reason Lot A has more waterfront area is due to the strange shape of the lot.

No reason to make both lots odd shaped.

Leave them alone.

Sell them both separately as you plan, but make note in the comments that the neighboring property is also For Sale(and reference the price and MLS# of it in the comments)
susana_2006
12 years ago
I had a similar situation in Los Angeles about 6 years ago. My mother had bought an adjacent lot from the county in 1977 and the property was zoned as horse property. It was adjacent to a riding trail, but the lot was landlocked. At that time, it was a desirable situation to have land in Los Angeles and at that time, the banks were lending money to anyone (with no down payments). The problem I found was that the potential buyers could not get financing for the raw land parcel (and they all wanted no money down financing at that time). So, in order to make the property sellable, I had to get the lot line removed. The city made it very difficult & expensive -- needed a survey and lots of visits to city hall to get the job done. Luckily, I did get it done and the property sold before LA property values plummeted. So the question to ask is, whether the property would be more vaulable divided or combined. Find out about raw land financing in your area. Good luck
Susan
weedyacres
Original Author
12 years ago
I was thinking the change in lot lines would make Lot B more attractive, but it sounds like the consensus is no. We'll save ourselves the trouble of making the changes. Thanks to everyone for the input.

Should we change our lot lines?

Comments (6)

cas66ragtop

weedyacres
Original Author

Related Discussions

OttawaGardener

sweet_tea

susana_2006

weedyacres
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Should we change our lot lines?

Comments (6)

cas66ragtop

weedyacresOriginal Author

Related Discussions

OttawaGardener

sweet_tea

susana_2006

weedyacresOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

weedyacres
Original Author

weedyacres
Original Author