Painting and re-staining oak staircase

14 years ago

Hi - 1st post - very impressed with the advice in this forum.

I have a typical 80's house with a curved oak staircase (gold stain with varnish) and lovely sea-foam green carpet. We've lived with this look for 21 years - it's finally time to get outta the 80's. What started off as a replace the carpet project has crept into bathroom, staircase and a full blown kitchen reno's.

What we want to accomplish with the staircase project is:

1) paint the risers - spindles - outer and inner stringers

2) stain (with a dye) the hand rail and newels a darker color

Before the diehard, "why are you painting Oak?" activists come out...The answer - we've lived here 21 years, we are going to be here another 21 years....lets try something new - frankly I'm sick of 80's oak.

How do I do this?

I called an experienced painter and he flat out told me "you can't hide the oak grain and pits with paint!"

Sorry, I refuse to believe this - time to DIY.

This is a big staircase, 123 spindles and lots of continuous railing - it's a big job.

I have done some research; however, I really haven't pieced together all the answers.

I am ready to do some testing on some sample pieces.

Here is my plan based - I have thick skin...please tell me what I should really do?

1) use liquid sandpaper to remove the varnish on just the rail and newels

2) Mask the hand rails and newel

3) spray using my airless (don't have a hvlp) with XIM to precoat the spindles, risers and stringers - I know I will waste...Is HVLP the way to go? I have a buddy that owns a couple of them.

4) spray with an enamel undercoat to fill the pits - is this going to do it?

5) spray with an outercoat - suggestions on the type of paint?

6) finish with a polyurethane coat - curious will this possibly crack? Is this wise? I would like to protect the paint from shoe mark scuffs (on the risers) and chips etc.

7) mask the spindles, risers and stringers

8) sand, sand, sand the handrail and newels

9) use a stain equalizer to balance the grain - not really sure of this step.

Stain
add a tint of stain to polyurethane for the first sealer coat - told this will cheat by blending the stain into areas that didn't accept the stain.
finish the final coat with clear polyurethane.

Then...Finish my bathroom project, start on my 1800 sq ft flooring project and complete the nightmare with the kitchen reno which includes opening up a load bearing wall....Nice eh...

Thanks in advance - Regards,

Rob

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

rugbyhead
Original Author
14 years ago
Another question: I need to invest in an HVLP spayer,my buddy has industrial HVLP sprayers worth $3000ea, which are continuously on the job. What is a good HVLP sprayer for this project. Consumerreports has nothing on sprayers. Looking for something in the $200-$300 that will be in the family for years and does a good job. Any suggestions?

Regards,
Rob
0
ron6519
14 years ago
Fuji sprayers.
Ron
0
Related Discussions
Need some opinions on painting stair rises white or staining them
Q
Comments (25)
I much prefer the look of painted risers. I have found that scuff marks seem to depend a lot on the kind of paint you use. In our last house, we pulled up carpet and painted the risers with a latex semi-gloss paint. They scuffed horribly and I was constantly repainting them (because they scuffed so bad I couldn't get them clean). In this house, which was painted with Ben Moore OIL based semi-gloss, the stair risers hardly ever scuff. Same people, same shoes -- only difference is the paint. Now, we can no longer get oil paint in our state and our stair area really needs repainted (the walls are wood paneled and painted in the same paint as the risers) so I started putting Zinsser 123 over the oil paint in preparation for repainting it with latex. I got interrupted, so only a few steps have the 123. They too are scuffing horribly. They're only primer, so I wouldn't expect it to hold up, but still - it's amazing the difference between scuff level after just a few days. I'm planning to repaint with Cabinet Coat by Insul-X, which is the toughest latex trim paint I have found. It has held up well on my baseboards so I'm hoping it will be good on the risers. If not, I guess I could make an out-of-state trip to smuggle in some oil paint, LOL!
...See More
Staining Maple Stair caps to match LVP which is urban oak
Q
Comments (14)
If in doubt go darker. Like 3-5 times darker. When the product is PURPOSEFULLY stained a different colour than the floor, it is used as an ACCENT. That accent can then be 'picked up' in other ways. Such as a dark railing or dark spindles. All it takes is TWO items to create a 'look'. This works with pillows and area rugs or area rugs and drapes. It can work for stair treads and railings/spindles. Simply make the decision that makes TWO items the same colour. Maple is a pain to stain LIGHT...but it is very handsome when worked in a DARK stain. It will look 'almost' painted but not quite. Ask the wood trim company to create a dark charcoal or 'almost' black stain. And then MAKE SURE you get ONE OTHER ITEM in that same colour. The two put TOGETHER make a statement. It's a brilliant way to fix an oopsa.
...See More
Painting Oak Stairs?
Q
Comments (11)
I'd paint it all (and prob replace some items) . You could sand and re-stain the oak handrail to a darker tone if you prefer, but paint everything else . most of the before/afters you see finished they don't paint the bannister. most are stained. let me show you some pics and you see what you like. white/dark w/ wainscot l) if you painted and stained handrail, it would look similar to this one, except w/your carpet. if you left everything as is, painted your spindles, darked the handrail, it would look very close to this one. runner instead of full carpet. everything bright white, newel posts redone. walls a soft grayish white, and runner speaking of runners. your same staircase, dark bannister, new runner, and some trim molding wainscot up the side of the wall. and, if you have other oak trim in your house and want it painted, it looks like this Can you afford to replace the spindles for something else? (this way you could paint them yourself before they get installed and might offset the some of the cost. ) This looks so much better a painter will need to come in and sand off all of that glossy clear coar, prime, and then spray/brush. (and if they don't do these steps, your paint will wear and chip) That's a lot of work. Painting all of it white, with the squared off spindles. (One of the few pictures I found w/a white handrail) dark stained bannister, new newel posts, white updated ballusters. here's how everything looks painted white, grayish/brown bannister stain, and replacing the spindles and the newel posts. This gives you a completely updated look if you can do any of these things yourself, you could save some bucks. But if you have the cash, I'd go ahead and update the whole thing everything replaced, including the oak treads, and wood stained a natural tone black stairs, oak treads, white risers. modern black accent wall
...See More
Staining red oak stairs to match white oak floor?
Q
Comments (4)
Does your floor manufacturer make a matching stair cladding? If you do that, you don’t need to have oak treads. Another option is to do a beautiful contrasting color of stain on the stairs. You could pull the colors together with handrail or baluster or post colors. Adding a runner on the stairs, or painting the risers would give you more options to tie in the floor colors. If you really want to match wood, dark stain is worth a try, but lighter colors are really tough. I matched a red oak transition strip to a dark chocolate brown stone tile once. I had to keep mixing and adding stain. It worked only because it was a dark brown color. It’s hard to neutralize red and yellow tones.
...See More
Related Professionals
Southampton Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Terryville Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Port Angeles Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Phillipsburg Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Plant City Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Eufaula Kitchen & Bathroom Remodelers · Cusseta Interior Designers & Decorators · Linton Hall Interior Designers & Decorators · American Canyon General Contractors · Fremont General Contractors · Lighthouse Point General Contractors · Northfield General Contractors · Roseburg General Contractors · Saginaw General Contractors · San Bruno General Contractors
brickeyee
14 years ago
"you can't hide the oak grain and pits with paint!"

He is correct.

Put paste wood filler WILL fill the oak pores and allow a smooth finish.

Once you get to bare wood you apply paste wood filler (Pore-o-pac by Behlans is one) is than applied to the wood and allowed to start to set before rubbing most of it off with burlap across the grain.
If you are going to paint use natural or a light color filler.
After the filler finishes drying you get to sand once again with fine grit to remove any excess filler on the surface.
If you remove to much filler (or it shrinks excessively from being thinned to much) you may even need a second coat of filler.

You can make ANY wood smooth as glass if you want to work at it.
The prominent pores in oak furniture are a 'style' that omits paste wood filler.
There are also finish styles that use contrasting or colored filler to emphasize the pores while leaving a smoother surface.
0
rugbyhead
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks, this is exactly the advice I need. You mentioned getting down to bare wood...oh boy - does that mean in order for the Pore-o-pac product to work, I need to strip the varnish and sand 123 spindles? Will this product work overtop of the varnish? I have so much work to do - any where I can reduce time for a task is huge.
Regards,
Rob
0
brickeyee
14 years ago
"Will this product work overtop of the varnish?"

Not very well, but it would be worth a try.
It might work depending on the composition of the varnish.
0
brickeyee
14 years ago
I would encourage you to figure out how to remove the spindles if you can.
They will be a real PITA to refinish that many in place.

Depending on ages they often are simply trapped by the blocks of wood nailed between them in the rail, and just sit in pockets in the floor (or between more blocks of wood if a bottom rail is used).
0
weedyacres
14 years ago
Yikes, that sounds like a lot of work! I'm an avid DIY-er, but I'd seriously look into just buying 123 new painted (or paintable) spindles and replacing what you've got.
0
rugbyhead
Original Author
14 years ago
Good suggestion, I thought about that, I priced some out too. Cheap ones were $2 - good ones were $7 - more so, the existing spindles are professionally cut, so each one is custom to the curved staircase rail, I am certain it would be more work to equal the quality of those cuts on the existing oak.
0
rugbyhead
Original Author
14 years ago
I tried posting this so hopefully it doesn't create a double entry...Really Good idea to remove spindles...The spindles are toe-nailed into the treads and rail, the nails are hidden by carpet. My plan is to use a jamb saw and cut them at the base to make clearance for the hardwood going directly on the treads - anyway. I could remove the spindles easy enough. That would make the job much easier...less masking...
Great advice, thanks
Rob
0
jamdar
13 years ago
Hello, I am wanting to redo our Golden Oak (gag) stair railing. I read on some blog to just use mixwax stain and topcoat in one. I have done the first coat but it looks really streaky. Im wanting it a walnut brown. I did lightly sand the railing first. Anyone out there try this technique? if so how did it look in the end? im afraid it will look cheap. HELP. PS im staining rail and posts.
0
brickeyee
13 years ago
"mixwax stain and topcoat in one"

One of the worst products on the market.

It requires constant stirring to keep the pigment suspended, but if you introduce and air bubbles during stirring it messes up the coat.

And if you wait for the bubbles to rise or dissipate the pigment settle out again.
0

Painting and re-staining oak staircase

Comments (11)

rugbyhead
Original Author

ron6519

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

brickeyee

rugbyhead
Original Author

brickeyee

brickeyee

weedyacres

rugbyhead
Original Author

rugbyhead
Original Author

jamdar

brickeyee

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Painting and re-staining oak staircase

Comments (11)

rugbyheadOriginal Author

ron6519

Related Discussions

Related Professionals

brickeyee

rugbyheadOriginal Author

brickeyee

brickeyee

weedyacres

rugbyheadOriginal Author

rugbyheadOriginal Author

jamdar

brickeyee

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

rugbyhead
Original Author

rugbyhead
Original Author

rugbyhead
Original Author

rugbyhead
Original Author