You're hysterical Bestlawn!

I'm not glad. I liked the singer who got voted off. Oh well.

Hahaha! Was that really you?

I knew the contestant wouldn't last too long...but there was another one I would have rather seen go this week.

That was tricky. I couldn't imagine which group was the bottom three.

Bestlawn, you are too funny!! That was a good one!!

Next week will be tough for sure. It's getting down to the wire so it will be tighter and tighter.

Disappointed here! I do not thing America got it right this time. It should have been Syesha, then Jason. I thought Kristy Lee was really good. I bet we will be seeing her somewhere singing.

I agree. Kristy Lee shouldn't have been the one voted off tonight. We definitely will see her in the future.

I thought for sure it would have been Jason. I really liked Kristy and I'm sure she will get a contract for some Country record company. She will go a lot farther then Jason.

If they do Disco songs can you just imagine what Jason would sing?

Samkaren
your resident DJ

IMO, Kristy should have been kicked off when she sang 'Amazing Grace' the second time. I was happy to see her go. It irked me thet she was up there whining about the horse. It sounds to me like she made a business deal. That other guy bought that horse in good faith. He wasn't paid to be a babysitter while she went out for the spotlight. She needs to suck it up and quit harrassing him which is what she basically doing by whining on national television.

Syesha should have gone home. I think all her singing is basically screaming. Can't stand it.

Gayle

I loved Kristy Lee's voice but her stage presence was lacking. In fact I thought every performance of hers looked stiff and wooden until her final song last night which she started by sitting in front of Simon and singing to him. Finally, she appeared to have some comfort on the stage.

With that said, I do wish it had been Syesha that went home.

Jodi-

I was hoping for Jason to leave. Darn! I didn't mind Kristy that much. Anybody's better than Jason Castro IMHO. I just can't see what people see in him. Yes, his eyes are nice but this isn't a contest for nice eyes is it?

I agree with Gayle.....not a fan of Syesha either....kind of tiresome sounding after awhile. I was hoping it was her to be gone this week. I really like Kristy and hope we do hear more from her someday. I tend to lean more to the country sound I guess. I love everyone else that's left though, with the exception of Syesha, so I'm happy with any winner. I think most will go far without winning anyway. I think David Cook will take it all the way...he has more of the sound that makes an American Idol. I loved Daughtry too and he's doing well......

Finally!! LOL!!
She will probably make a record, but I don't think she's as good as Carrie Underwood.
David A. always looks kinda sad. Not sure about that kid.
Still loving David Cook!

Syesha should have been gone earlier IMO. Kristy is cute as a button and I think she is an okay vocalist. David A seems to be overwhelmed by the whole idea. But he has a future waiting for him. Jason obviously appeals to a certain audience, and I am a part of that audience. I could listen to him sing more so than any of the others. I don't care for the dreads, but it is the singing that I like.

No doubt David C will be THE winner.

Sue

I guess I'm alone on this one...I don't care for David Cook at all...I don't think he has good looks and I'm sure not drooling over him. I guess his singing is okay but I would much rather sit and listen to Michael Johns or David A .

As far as the girls I really don't have a pick. I guess I prefer a male voice .

Without a voice having anything to do with it ....(I know that's what it is all about) but I would be doing a happy dance to see Carley go.

I was just dissapointed that she didn't go.

patti

I think the Kristy Lee is a fine singer, but she has NO personality. Syesha and Jason next, IMO.

I thought David Cook would win AI when I saw his auditions in Hollywood. He was a bit creepy looking with his odd haircut but the AI stylists have done a good job cleaning him up and still leaving him with his "look".

My DH doesn't like Cook because he reminds him of one of my not so popular brothers and I have to agree, he does look like him.

I cannot get used to David A's breathing while he sings. Obviously I know it is necessary :-) but it is so loud that it distracts me. He's had vocal cord paralysis in the past and I worry that it may be a liability to him later on. Not sure if a producer wants to pour big bucks into a voice that has a history of medical problems.

Jodi-

I was sorry to see Kristy leave, although you knew it was probably going to be her time to go. I would love to see Sayesha and Carly go home!!! I really believe Brooke will be the next to go, as her singing has been really weak. She has a great personality but IMO, she lacks talent. And YES...I'm so glad David A's nasal issues bother someone else. It's really hard for me to watch him perform or talk without thinking about his problem!!! So, for me, it's David Cook all the way to the top!!!

I didn't know about David A.'s breathing issues but the thing that bothers me when he sings is his mouth/tongue. He has rather large, thick lips & he wets them every so often & for some reason that really turns me off. I like to listen to him but have trouble watching him perform. Guess that wouldn't be an issue when he records but on TV it just doesn't look good. JMHO