BORING!!! I'm not a Mariah Carey Fan. I thought David A. and Carley were the best.

Linda

Tonight was Carly's best performance ever. The song was too big for her, but I think she pulled it off extremely well.

Kristy's best night, too.

Poor Brooke got so lost in that song it was obvious she was just rushing trying to get through it. She started out okay and then the second half totally over-powered her.

This is the first time I reeeeaally did not like David A.'s performance. He made it obvious he does not have a developed falsetto. The rest of the song was just so-so.

Syesha did quite well as usual. She has such a pretty voice.

Time for Jason to go. I hope the voters put me out of my misery tonight.

David Cook did the best out of everyone. I love this guy and the way he "Cooks" every song he does.

I'm not a Mariah fan either, but thought most of the contestants did pretty good.

I think Kristy is improving weekly. She is (was) the 'vote for the worst' site's pick. I think they are having a tough time this year cause all of the remaining contestants are good performers.

I'd like to see Brooke or Jason go home. They are both pretty limited in what they can sing (style-wise) IMO.

David Cook is so professional already. He really makes each song his own. I hope he makes it to the final 2. GO DAVID!

I thought David Cook, David A and Jason were the best tonight.

Enjoyed most of the show, but I thought David Cook was awful, but he's never appealed to me. Jason is a bit weird and will most likely go soon.

Brook White was a lost out there even though Simon really likes her.

Brook may just not have the votes this week. A shame that she missed her sister's wedding on Saturday.

I like Jason, but I have to admit, he is not a candidate fo AI.

David A., I thought was best. I was disappointed in David Cook's performance and was surprised that it was well received.

Gayle

All of Jason's songs sound the same to me. I'm not a huge fan of David Cook but I do like David A.

I love the ladies but I didn't think Carly's song was great. But that is only because that song should only be sung by the original artist. (Some songs are like that)

I will be voting for both Kristy and Brooke.

SamKaren
your resident DJ

Karen, I agree there are some songs that should be sung only by the original artist, however, Mariah Carey was NOT the original artist of Without You.

Linda

Here is a link that might be useful: Without You

Linda
I agree. Without You was sung by Nilsson and I think he is the only one that can sing it well. I'm not saying that Mariah did a bad version but I just think that when you hear the original others just don't do it justice.

Granted there are a few exceptions to this but that is another post.....Best or Worst of Remakes.

SamKaren
your resident DJ

I thought the girls were just so-so. Brooke is boring. Cute, but boring.
I just don't get the appeal for Jason.... every week, I keep thinking "oh, he's GOT to go this week for sure", but he keeps hanging on!! LOL!!
Now that my man is out (Michael Johns) I like David. He is really creative at making these not so good songs great!!

I agree with Bestlawn. I love David Cook. At this point he is my pick this season. Even if he leaves this week (which would be crazy) I think his career is just beginning to take off.

I'm not a fan of Jason either & am glad to know I'm not alone, which I am here in my office where they simply love him. I can't get past the dreads plus I just don't care for the singing either so I'm also hoping he goes tonight. My faves are both Davids & Syesha, who I really like.

I just read that David Cook's brother was in the audience and he has brain cancer. They say that is why David started crying after the song.

I loved the guys.....and Kristi did very well tonight I thought. I have always liked her. David Cook did an awesome job...I'm not a Miriah fan at all and don't care for her music....BUT I liked everyone's version better LOL! IMO Syesha should leave tonight, I'm sure she's good but does nothing for me. I really like the people who's left and find it hard to pick a winner.....

Brooke White needs to go home! I'm soooo sick of you "I don't know why you feel that way" stupid look. It is making me nuts!

Yeah, Barb, and almost every week she claims she knows she did badly. Because of her and Jason, I feel like the show is dragging to the end.

I'm not much of a Mariah fan, so knew very few of the songs last night.

I always think Carly is technically the best of the bunch, but she's consistently missing "something" that I need to hear, to connect with a singer. Husband says it's emotion, and possibly that's it. I love that song, and don't agree that it has to be done by the original artist ... but it does need to be done by someone who FEELS it.

David A and Jason both sounded good to me; David Cook was just plain awful. Couldn't understand the words, he was really slurring them, Husband said he sounded drunk and with all the faces he was making at the camera thought he was acting it too. LOL!

Kristy Lee Cook was very very good! Syesha was, for me, good for part of the song but not all of it. She needs some more consistency. Brooke I appreciated because she was stretching herself and trying something totally out of her comfort zone. She didn't sound good, but she wasn't staying 'safe' during a week when I bet she really wanted to!