Dog feeding questions - Bones? Rotation?

14 years ago

Hi everyone,

Right now my 3 year-old Border Collie Layla is on Wellnes Core, and seems to be doing well on it.

I've been reading about raw food and have heard that you should not feed raw and kibble at the same time (same feeding.) Today she had kibble in the morning and I gave her a split knuckebone for a treat late this afternoon.

Anyone know how many calories in marrow? I'm guessing she probably doesn't need kibble for dinner tonight.

I was also reading about kibble rotation. Anyone here rotate protein source foods regularly? Since Wellness core is turkey and chicken, should I switch it up and give her a venison/lamb based food in a month or so for a change? I was thinking Innova EVO Red and then Orijen Fish? (I don't have the time or energy to go all raw, so that's not an option for me.)

Might seem silly, but it makes sense to me to feed from diferent protein sources and I know I would get tired of eating the same thing everyday.

For those of you who rotate and/or supplement with meaty bones, how do you do it and how have your dogs responded?

Thanks, Holly

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

mazer415
14 years ago
Holly there are a thousand ideas and programs out there for dogs, and I suggest you first not worry too much about the calories your dog is taking in unless it has a very sedentary life. Most Aussies are very active and can burn more calories than they take in on a daily basis. Next, I dont know about others, but I shy away from lamb, lamb carries scrapies which is a form of encephalitis and that can not be killed with heat or freezing, and Im just not willing to expose my dog to that. Tho he is more likely to get bit by an infected mosquito.
I use a combination of food, I give my dog Ntural balance meat sticks, which he leaves out for days until they are like jerky before he eats them. I buy Trader Joes canned food, and I cook hamburger and chicken for him. Dogs ccan respond differently to rotation diets, some do well, some dont. Some become very finicky eaters and the change in food can back fire on you since they might get picky, it depends on your dog for the most part.
michael_so_fl
14 years ago
I tried switching my chow to Innova because I read it was one of the most nutritious foods on the market and her stools turned to pudding. I even notified the company and they had me adding cottage cheese to the food and it didn't make any difference.I was always under the belief to not keep changing their diet. They do not get bored with a tasty meal just keep it delicious and they always let you know.
Related Discussions
So what are you feeding your dogs now???
Q
Comments (20)
I found the pet food list forums to be largly made up of a lot of knee-jerk folks. About 99% of the tainted food is canned wet food. That does not mean there is anything wrong with the same brand dry food. I know that Costco removed their Kirkland brand wet food as a precaution. Just as Hills removed their wet food from the market there have been no problems with their Science Diet dry food. The main reason I like the Kirkland dry food is because it contains no corn or wheat gluten. It does contain whole grain brown rice and cracked pearled barley. The product bag also states that it is made in the USA. Most folks don't have the time or interest to especially prepare home cooked food for their pets and have to rely on a quality packaged food. Learn to read labels.
...See More
New dog.....questions
Q
Comments (12)
Lets tackle this one thing at a time. It is quite possible that your dog is not food oriented. My dog will go for a good day without eating, being stressed - longer. So I would not worry to much about that part. Next - this dog is probably not eating its normal food, so it is taking time to adjust to the new diet. My first action would be to take the dog to the vet. Make certain there is no physcial issues with the dog, pain and or eye problems. You might want to go out and get yourself some rescue remedy to help your pup through the first week or so of adjustment. I would recommend that you take your dog for leash walking a couple of times a day, make certain it is not the same person each day. This leash walking is very important, it establishes you as the top dog in your dogs world. You might also check out a dog training class. Socialization will be good for your pup, training will help all involved especially your dog, DOXIES have a tendency to try and take over everything, they want to be the boss. I dont know where you live, but if you can locate an organization which provides terriers with trials on what ethey are famous for, theat would be a great assest to your pups life. These organizations have a yard where they have created tunnels they actaully create like an underground maze, at the end of one of the tunnels is a caged rat or rabbit or other prey animal. The dogs are timed when they go down the tunnel, and are clocked when they have located the caged animal and when they have gotten back to the start. It is a fascinating obstable course to watch. Most all terriers are encouraged to join. And of course nobody is hurt. The rats used are use to the dogs coming down this tunnel, sniffing them, giving them a bark and heading away again. 1 Any suggestions for anything that will make this transition easier for Diesel? Leash walking, taking this slowly, talking to the dog. Obviously calling him out of his crate for anything (you should always make the dog come to you anyway instead of going to the dog - in the dogs mind you are a lesser creature if you go to them) 2 He will not be allowed to bite, she let him by with it figuring its the first 24 hours and she knows he is frightened and its reflex when he is scared. How to handle it if it keeps up? Tell him no bite. If you get scared of your dog he is going to pick up on it and take advantage of it. If you need to put a choke collar and leash on him in the house, so you can control him. I suspect he will start using the crate as a safety zone and start refusing to come out. Get him out by lifting the back, and tipping him out and close the crate gate if you need to. 3 How long to wait for him to eat? He is drinking and pottying. She is a little concerned but knows it hasn't been 24 hours yet. Dont worry too much about this. good luck and post if you have any other concerns...
...See More
What do you feed your dog ?
Q
Comments (39)
Our 4 year old Eskimo eats Fromms Four Star "Salmon A La Veg" and "Duck and Sweet Potato" kibble. Fromms Four Star also makes a Chicken and a Whitefish Kibble - you can alternate the 4 food types due to types of grains used, without getting cannon butt. We live in Canada - Fromms is made in the U.S. so of course we pay too much for it and only a few retailers carry it - although it is showing up in more places now, perhaps because it wasn't on the recall list. He has been on this food since he was 9 months old - until then we are all thinking he might need a digestive enzyme - a smooth operator - but the Fromm's Salmon fixed that - and this past year we expanded to the Duck. Northern breeds like the Eskie seem to do well on Fish based diets. His cookies are also Salmon based. Hard to keep his weight under control and this from somone who managed to keep mini Dachshunds at a reasonable weight - and Dachshunds are the gourmands of gourmets.
...See More
Feeding dog 'meat only' diet
Q
Comments (23)
Thanks all. Sorry to take so long to get back. Lots of stuff going on and I don't get notifications anymore. Have no idea why. Annztoo, He doesn't tell me anything. I buy good dry food and cook chicken or whatever meat I find on sale. Had Rotts for many years and always cooked my own 'doggy stew.' He has no clue what to feed dogs and just buys canned dog food.Now he's decided she's fat and will feed her deer meat. But I fear in small amounts which could lead to nutritional problems (its happened before). Tete, you hit it on the head. You understand the dilemma I live with. The dogs owner is my next door neighbor. He is highly educated. Lives alone and is a very nice person, very interesting and friendly. I find it difficult to speak to him as a peer. Somehow, I find it intimidating and avoid telling him what to do with his dog. I don't want to lose her as I'm very attached to her as is my husband. We play with her and give her as much attention as we can when she's here. I walk a delicate balance. I do not want to do anything to have him take her away from me. I know if I presented some 'study' or literature about feeding all meat or about canine nutrition, he would read it. He has a fascination with butterflies and we work together raising them. I grow the plants and he raises them in his house. He a person who completely confounds me, but I can't find a way to teach him anything without proof. That was the reason behind my post. Thank you Tete, you get it. Thank you all very much, Jane
...See More
cal_dreamer
Original Author
14 years ago
Thanks for the feedback. I think she has gained some weight in the month that I've had her,(her ribs do not feel so bony) and I really do want to keep her lean and healthy since she may not get all the exercise she needs. Two walks a day (at my pace) are probably not what is optimal for her. My plan was to have some vigorous ball play, but she could care less about balls or toys. She loves to lay on my feet while I'm on the computer or watch TV. Having a small yard, I'm not sure how much activity she does while we are at work.

Just wondering what others do - and if you supplement, then how much do you cut back the kibble? I've read the dog food threads and about raw, barf, etc.

It's nice to hear what is working for the dog owners here, as I figure out what is best for Layla.
cindyb_va
14 years ago
We do not feed BARF, but I am considering starting after the holidays. I have heard many good things from owners who do that.

Currently, our dog gets high grade kibble, "Taste of the Wild" with a bit of canned food mixed in for extra flavor. Wellness is excellent food also, just harder for us to find.

We do give knucklebones as treats, but only very rarely and only when he has had a good day's workout, such as romping in the countryside, or a full day of doggie day care, running with DH, etc. He might get 1-2 bones per month. If he gets a bone, he does not get any other dog treats that day, but we feed him his normal meals.

Border collies tend to run on the lean side. Have you considered trying to find a "herding class" for her? There are some places that you can take herding breeds to actually do what they are bred to do, aka herd goats or sheep. That might be a fun weekend activity for you to try.

Dog feeding questions - Bones? Rotation?

Comments (4)

mazer415

michael_so_fl

Related Discussions

cal_dreamer
Original Author

cindyb_va

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Dog feeding questions - Bones? Rotation?

Comments (4)

mazer415

michael_so_fl

Related Discussions

cal_dreamerOriginal Author

cindyb_va

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

cal_dreamer
Original Author