Pratt & Lambert's Linen White #33-7,
or Frazee's South Castle #CLW 1017W or Grizzly Creek #CLW 1018W might be options.
Luck to you!

Benjamin Moore's Linen White is a good one also!
Good luck. I totally understand when you say you are losing it. I have painted 10 colors on my walls trying to pick for the family room. I make a decision, then I 2nd guess it... drives me crazy..

I'm in the process of painting all doors and trim Behr Eggshell Cream. It is beautiful and classic. I don't have time at the moment to list the colors that I have it paired with but they are shades of green, yellow and a brownish peach. It looks wonderful with all of them. I had 30-40 contenders hanging on the wall and this one was the winner.

Ben Moore's Acadia White is creamy.

Take a look at the white selection of Behr.. home depot's own brand. I have been very pleased with the quality and shade range.

I just painted our fireplace with EK Snow (velvet sheen)- and LOVE it!!!
It's a warm white - like melted french vanilla ice cream.

I'm not usually a fan of white (probably because "white" in our house was always a dingy greyish primer type white or bluer cool whites). I like this color enough that I think we may use it as the default white in our house for all the trim that we paint (but we'll probably use an eggshell/semigloss version).

Good luck picking your color!
Always ;-)
Hunzi

I agree with mileaday. Try Behr's eggshell cream. You can't get it as a chip sample cuz it is an older color. You have to ask them to make it. They can still formulate it for you and being a tinted color, is not returnable. I'm in the process of putting it on my kitchen cabinets and the trim. It is exactly the creamy shade I was looking for without being too yellow or too white or gray. After about 10 contenders, this is the one. Thanks mileaday, I'm glad I saw your post!

What's "creamy" to one is yellow or tan to another! Or even too white! I wish I could suggest a specific color but I really can't. Even though I probably have about 200 different chips of varying degrees of "off-white".

I'm not familiar with the wall colors you have except I strongly considered Laura Ashley gold 2 for my bedroom. I recall that it is a complex, muted yellow/tan with green undertone. A really beautiful color. I assume that gold 4 is the same but deeper. I was amazed to see how a trim color can bring out the undertone in the wall or play it down; make the gold look either very green or more yellow or even dirty. So focus first on what undertones you need in your trim color. You already know you don't want blue, gray, pink/peach. You need some yellow but there are so many degrees of it.

Take your wall paint chips to the color displays and hold them up--you will easily see which groupings of tones/shades don't work and you will be able to narrow down to the right family pretty easily. Wish I'd done that early on!
You might also try taking your paint chips to Home Depot to use their scanner that will analyze your color & suggest coordinating colors from their line. That can at least get you started & when you start to see which tones are appealing to you the most when paired with your walls, you can take those chips with you to Lowes or elsewhere to look for the "just right" selection.

Also, if you find a paint chip that has just the right tones but is just too light/white, (or the opposite, like if you wanted to use gold 4 but a lighter version of it) you can ask them to mix it with 150-200% of the colorant. Or cut it in half. I've done this with good success.

All that said, I've just done the upstairs hall trim in Behr Navajo White, which to my eye when looked at alone is a creamy, muted yellow-- but looks great (and not yellow) with the several colors it needed to play with. And it took me many visits to paint stores, and many chips on the walls, to settle on my choice, but I don't regret the time I took now. Neither will you! Good luck!