Let's see: Black Shutters and Black door (semi-gloss shutters and high-gloss for the door) Black Shutters and Plum/Purple/Eggplant Door Black Shutters and Red Door Dark Green shutters and Bright Yellow Door Black Shutters and Pumpkin Door And if possible -- a great knocker (okay, no jokes LOL!) for the door! LOL! Jan at Rosemary Cottage

This is a recommended color from SW for Mindful Gray…homburg gray. I would do this on the shutters and the garage doors and leave the wood door as is. The two middle windows shouldn’t have shutters as the won’t fit appropriately, but you are not painting the siding and the darker outlines of the shutters will show if you don’t replace what was there. Personally, would like the house with out shutters and would probably paint the siding and garage doors and have no shutters at all.

Love your inspiration photo. Can you remove your storm door or replace it with a full view one? Painting your door won't have much effect if you can't see it!

The style of your shutters means they look better stained. If you want to change colors you should get new shutters, but I agree with the other commenter who said they shouldn't be on the arched window. Does your house face south? If so, this could be the cause of the premature aging of the front door. See if your painter has a recommendation for a finish that will hold up better over time. Or maybe the amount of sunlight your front door gets means you will always have to paint or refinish it more frequently. If you decide to go with paint and think black is too severe, how about charcoal gray?