Thank you all for the comments and ideas. After seeing the pics that lukkirish posted, my idea of going redwood-ish is disappearing. I really like that green (3rd pic) with the white trim. Or the yellow. What to do??? Bonnie_ann are you near here? When I was a teen my parents had a cottage in the same community. Driving 'to the lake' was like leaving the state, it seemed sooo far. There was nothing out that way for miles. (The trip now takes us 45 minutes, going the long way.) At that time all the houses were strickly weekend cabins, now most are permanent residents. We are having an arborist out to check on the trees and educate us on the pros and cons of their location. People in this region of Florida are protective of their cypress trees. I am looking forward to napping on the screened porch while listening to the breeze through the cypress, a sound that really is different then most trees. (Sappy but true.) Thank you again, keep the suggestions coming. We have a few weeks before having to decide.

You're right Kevin. Also, I was paying some attention to the other old homes in the area and I noticed a few other colonials with the same verticak detail, and one house with the same door and tiny window set up...go figure, the house was all white. The more I think about it, I will not include the trim around the small vertical windows in the trim color. I will keep them the same color as whatever the house will be painted. I think it will be less distracting.

We just replaced our roof on our contemporary homes with black. I main body of the house is Garrett Grey (Sherwin Williams) . I feel the need to. Paint the trim a different color and add accent to the front door. What do you suggest?

I like the Kendall charcoal, on the house. However, it definitely does not go with your brown colored roof. I also like the garage door, painted the same color as the house, regardless of what color you use. I see you have some stone walls there. Pick a color from that stone for the house, that also goes with the color of your roof. What you actually have right now, looks very nice.