Down to Final 2 Heat Pump Bids - Lennox vs. Bryant/Carrier

11 years ago

Thanks in advance for any and all advice provided by HVAC professionals and homeowners with firsthand knowledge on the proposed Heat Pump packages. I've posted in the past on the kitchen and bathroom forums, but this is the first time on the HVAC forum.

My family and I bought a 1986 built brick/minimal wood siding house in Austin, TX 78746 in Nov 2010. The all electric house was mostly original as far as energy conversation measures. It does have decent doors, insulated windows throughout, and a good number of shade trees blocking direct sunlight on each side and some of the roof. After moving in I took advantage of the tax rebates by quickly jumped on having open cell foam blown in the attic in part to provide additional storage space that didn't reach 120 degrees in the summer.

The two story house has 3,400 square feet and two HVAC zones. The ground floor has 9' ceilings and is 1,900 square feet with a separate one story 8' ceiling bump out for a guest suite. That heat pump was installed in Sept 2010 and is a 3 ton Bryant with a 15.0 SEER and 12.5 EER. It runs well and makes the ground floor plenty comfortable year round.

The second floor (three bedrooms, two baths, and one open area office is a different story. The attic located air handling unit is original (26 years old) and the outdoor 2HP Trane XE 1000 was installed in 1998. The system works but it has a hard time keeping the temperatures comfortable and their is a decent return air vacuum in the master suite when the door is closed. With the wife liking to sleep under a decent weight of covers even in the summer and setting the thermostat to 73 and 72 on occasion, we have power bills that have topped 3,100 KWHs and $310 (top tier summer rate is $0.03615 per KWH and we're bracing for a marked increase within the next year). That price is even with digital thermostats and setbacks. I should add that we have a pool with a single speed 1 1/2 hp pump. I'm going to swap that out for variable speed pump once I get my AC figured out.

I've solicited bids from five different contractors for Carrier, Lennox, Bryant, Amana, Trane, and American Standard equipment. All the companies have good reputations as shown in Angie's List and Yelp. I've narrowed it down to these two bids:

Bid #1 - Cash price of $7,926 after taxes, $1,000 manufacturer rebate, and $600 City of Austin rebate

* Lennox Signature (AHRI 5269230)

* 2 Ton XP21024

* CBX32MV024030IC air handler

* ECB405CB coil

* 25,000 Cooling BTU

* 25,000 Heating BTU

* SEER/EER 18.2/13.0

* HSPF 9

* Evacuate/flush existing 5/8 and 3/8 diameter lineset roughly 35 feet

* Heat Strip - Need to ask

* Healthy Climate - media air cleaner

* iComfort Control - thermostat (color touchscreen and Internet enabled)

* 10 year warranty both parts and labor

* Additional return air run to master suite

* Extra dampers two help balance rooms

* Includes 2 tune ups/cleanings

Bid #2 - Cash price of $7,747 after taxes, $1,000 manufacturer rebate, and $600 City of Austin rebate

* Bryant Evolution (AHRI 5226627)

* 2 Ton 289BNA024

* KFCEH2901N09 air handler

* FE4ANF003T coil

* 24,800 Cooling BTU

* 25,400 Heating BTU

* SEER/EER 18.0/13.5

* HSPF 10

* Evacuate/flush existing 5/8 and 3/8 diameter lineset roughly 35 feet

* Heat Strip - 9K

* Aprilaire with 2 extra media - air cleaner

* Communicating digital - thermostat

* 10 year warranty parts, 1 year warranty labor

* Additional return air run to master suite

* Includes 2 tune ups/cleanings

* Willingness by contractor to go with Carrier equivalents for no extra charge

* EXTRA CHARGE -> $1,090 for 10 year warranty that includes labor

Note that the Lennox contractor was the first bid I got and this Bryant contractor was the last and had an inquisitive sales rep who sweetened his bid more than once after learning generalities of the first bid. The first contractor was incredibly responsive when I submitted online to qualitysmith.com. They returned my call at 10:00 PM on a Sunday. I have not asked them if the given price is their best offer.

Thanks again for any and all help here. I hope to make a decision on Monday and have the system installed Friday.

Appreciative,

Trevor in Austin

P.S. I've included a pic of how nice a 26 year old AHU looks!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (4)

tigerdunes
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Describe your typical winters for your location/climate.

Has it ever crossed your mind that a 2 ton system might be borderline undersized for upstairs?

Existing lineset if flushed and reused must be the correct size to the manufacturer's spec. Close doesn't count.

What thermostat for the Bryant quote? It should be the Evolution
controller.

I like HPs to have electronic demand defrost. You might want to dbl check but I believe the Lennox has that feature, Bryant does not.

I would want the heat strip to be staged. Discuss with dealer.

Prices are very frisky. I would consider a sgl stage model like Trane's XL15i or XR15 HP models.

IMO
mike_home
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
"top tier summer rate is $0.03615 per KWH"

Is this rate correct? If so can I buy some power from you? I pay about $0.18 per KWH!

Did anyone do a load calcualtion? I also think 2 tons is marginal. The extra insulation in the attic is helping, but it's difficult to say if it enough for summers in Austin.

All the prices seem very high. Is this due to a very hot summer?
Related Discussions
Geothermal heat pump vs air source heat pump vs gas
Q
Comments (27)
Air source heat pumps don't make sense in areas where winter temps frequently fall below 32 degrees. Once you get below freezing, you will be running the auxillary heat a lot. If you decide to go the air source route, you will want a second stage gas fired auxillary heat. I live in the mid-atlantic region in the mountains and selected GT. That choice was coupled with a blown cellulose insulation package. My other choice was a propane heat/electric AC with a foam insulation package. Both options were roughly the same install cost. Both would have provided similar energy efficiency. At the time we selected, propane was 3.75 a gallon and rising (with no end in sight) so we went with GT. The delta cost for the GT system (above the cost for a HE propane heat and electric AC system) was $15,000 for the heat pumps and loop plumbing (including pumps) plus $17,000 for digging the pit. The pit excavation should not have cost as much as it did but it is a 12 ton system and the hole was gigantic (120' x 48' x 6'). We live on a mountain and hit a bunch of boulders that required special equipment to get out. Rocky soil also required a 1' base of stone dust to cover the loop piping. The total cost for the GT HVAC system including all ducting was $50,000 plus the pit excavation cost of 17K. It is a large investment and I would only recommend it if you plan to live in the house a very long time. My heating bills are great - maybe 300 dollars maximum a month during peak winter for an 8500 square foot home (5900 living and the rest a condiitoned but unfinished basement). Make sure that whatever equipment you choose can be maintained by more than 1 very qualified HVAC company who has many years of GT experience. In my area there is only 1 GT company who has over 20 years of experience but I am stuck with them for maintenance. There have been times when I wanted to fire them but cannot. Local competition is a good thing. Also - if you build a tight home make sure that you consider ventilation and dehumidification in the HVAC design. I wound up adding both a whole house dehumidifier and energy recovery vent after we moved in becuase we had basement moisture issues as well as stale air in the winter. Tight homes are great for energy efficiency but can create health issues too. It is easy to deal with as long as you plan for it. Good luck with the build.
...See More
York vs. Lennox vs. Carrier
Q
Comments (10)
I appreciate the feedback so far. Based on what I'm learning, I think we'll go with a single stage for the a/c but still trying to decide if it would be worth it to have the heat pump on it or not. What's funny is that two of the contractors I've talked to tell me not to get the Heat pump b/c it will be the first thing to break, no matter what brand or what line, because the reversing valves always are the first things to die. The nice thing with the SMART devices is we can tell it how low it can go before switching to the furnace, we're thinking the H/P will only be used down to 45 degrees and then it'll switch to the fully modulating furnace. Our gas rates aren't bad around here, but this is a long term investment and no one knows what things will cost in 5-10 yrs or longer... Another way to look at it is the H/P can be a backup heat supply should the furnace have any problems. I've confirmed with two of my contractors that I can use the more basic a/c or h/p with the SMART communicating furnace because the furnace is what regulates all the flow (inducer, blower, modulating... and anything else) and just tells the a/c or heat pump when to run. So I can use a regular 'dumb' ac or hp. Also I learned that the York has the brains of the system in the furnace and the Lennox has the brains in the thermostat ... so when using the York - almost any thermostat could be used and the furnace's high-end features will keep working. When using a Lennox - the high end features get dumbed down if you ever use a basic thermostat with it. At least that's how I understand it... any takers on that? Thanks!
...See More
Lennox XP14 vs Trane xli15 heat pumps
Q
Comments (11)
trucker first of all, I will assume you are sized correctly. I always recommend that lineset be replaced as long as there is reasonable accessibility. But you should first verify that existing lineset is the correct size for new system and then weigh flushing cost vs new lineset. The Trane air handler you were quoted is the new Hyperion 5 series mdl. While high eff, it is not variable speed. Here are the performance/eff numbers for quoted system. 4151234 Active Systems XL15I WEATHERTRON TRANE 4TWX5042A1 GAM5A0C42M31 44000 12.50 15.25 43500 8.50 27800 good numbers but mediocre HSPF efficiency. If that's an issue or concern, then upgrade to the *AM7A0C48H41 air handler. Do you have a whole house air filter? if not, I recommend you install one. At the very least I would want HW 8321 thermostat. If you go with a true var speed air handler, then consider HW VP IAQ that has dehumidify on demand feature. It's difficult to make an informed comment on existing ductwork system but I find the $3K price questionable at best. Can you provide more details as to specific problems rewgarding your system other than leaks? Have you asked if repairs can be made? What exactly does dealer propose for new ductwork system? Do you have any hot/cold spots in your home? Adequate number of returns? For Florida, you want R8 insulation at the very least. For heat strip size, I would go with the 7.5K module. What size do you have now? You would rarely if ever use it unless you have breakdown on outside condenser. You could save some bucks if you went with the XR15 HP. IMO
...See More
5-Ton Trane vs Lennox Heat Pump w/ Furnace Questions
Q
Comments (6)
daffer I think your strategy is right on target. The only question is whether you want dual fuel(var spd furnace backup) or an air handler(with strip heat backup). With an air handler and strip heat, you would need to check electric panel/service to see if you have capacity to handle backup strip heat. If not, cost to upgrade electric service. Here are three best configurations with var speed air handler. I like the numbers of the Carrier Infinity 16 HP with Infinity controller best. It has better BTU numbers both heating and cooling. 552846 Active Systems XP19 SERIES LENNOX INDUSTRIES, INC. XP19-060-230* CBX32MV-068-230* 58500 12.05 16.30 53500 8.25 32800 1481762 Active Systems XL19I WEATHERTRON TRANE 2TWZ9060C1 2TEE3D65A1 56000 9.90 15.75 51000 8.50 31400 1250425 Active Systems INFINITY 16 PURON HP CARRIER AIR CONDITIONING 25HNA660A30 FE4ANB006+UI 60000 11.10 15.30 57500 9.00 34200 You know 5 ton is correct size? I would check Duke Power and see if they offer any rate incentive for HP heating. 410 refrigerant is the way the market is moving. IMO
...See More
dtwinters
Original Author
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Wow, you gentlemen respond very quickly. Thanks for that. And apparently, I'm not at my sharpest in the middle of the night. That power rate was incorrect. I only provided the fuel charge. Adding all the pieces together comes to $0.11579 (.0782 summer rate, .00144 transmission rate, and .03615 fuel charge).

As for the other questions/comments:

* I did worry about the lineset diameter and confirmed for the length, turns, and elevation change online for the Lennox. It won't even have a 1% drop in efficiency. The Bryant salesman with 17 years experience told me the lineset works. All the contractors told me the lineset works for a 2 ton but not a 3 ton. Additionally, replacing the lineset adds roughly $1,000 to each bid.

* Only one of the contractors specified a 3 ton unit and there expected the unit to always run in the low speed except during extreme circumstances.

* The Bryant does come with the Evolution controller t-stat.

* Demand defrost - I couldn't find any mention of this for the Lennox online, so I will pose the question to the contractor. I did find this text on the Bryan installation instructions -> "The control board accumulates compressor run time. As theaccumulated run time approaches the selected defrost interval time,
the control board monitors the coil temperature sensor for a defrost
demand. If a defrost demand exists, a defrost cycle will be initiated
at the end of the selected time interval. A defrost demand exists
when the coil temperature is at or below 32_F (0_C) for 4 minutes
during the interval."

* I will ask about the staged heat strips. Austin generally only has 24 hours or less below freezing and maybe two months where heating is used.

* Tigerdunes - what do you mean when you say the prices are "very frisky"?

* We certainly are having more and more hot summers. It struck me that at least a couple of the contractors were eager for the business as they were ready to do the work within a day or two. How over priced do you think these prices are for premium equipment?

I am leaning toward the Lennox due to the 10 year warranty for labor and the Internet enabled thermostat that allows me to adjust it from my iPhone when I realize we are out of the house for a while. Additionally, the salesman was more pleasant to my wife and helpful to me without the constant adjustments in what he is selling me.

Thanks again for all the advice. It is invaluable in making sure I get my money's worth.

Regards,
Trevor in Austin
tigerdunes
11 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Frisky=expensive

The single stage HPs come in 1/2 ton increments. That's why I suggested the Trane models and perhaps a 2 1/2 ton size.

Bryant/Carrier HPS do not have demand defrost. I believe the Lennox mdl does. Demand defrost eliminates/reduces nuisance, unnecessary, and expensive defrost calls. Not to mention the wear and tear to the
condenser.

Then for your winters and if heat strip is not staged, I would stick to a 7 1/2 KW heat strip. No more. Any idea of existing size?

Here is my HP checklist.

Obviously correct sizing is important. If you are unsure, then request a load calculation or even perform it yourself for a nominal fee online.

there are three equally important components-quality HVAC, the install by dealer, and probably the most overlooked and disregarded is the ductwork
system.

these are my minimum specs for a new HP system. both outside and inside units should be replaced to have a properly matched system.

15 SEER, 12.5+ EER, 9 HSPF
best matching VS air handler
full BTUs in both cooling and heating for your rated size
R-410a refrigerant(same as Puron)
scroll compressor preferred
electronic demand defrost preferred
thermostat with "dehumidify on demand" feature
staged backup heat strips
new and correctly sized refrigerant line set

you want a thorough inspection of your ductwork system. size, overall condition, supply and return lines, insulation qualities, leak test, etc.

any hot/cold spot issues in your home should be addressed.

I would only use authorized dealers for the various brands that provide quotes. See mfg websites.

I would look at Trane/AmStd,Rheem/Rudd,Carrier/Bryant.

Depending on your location, I would not purchase a new HP system that
did not have electronic demand defrost.

Post back.

IMO

Down to Final 2 Heat Pump Bids - Lennox vs. Bryant/Carrier

Comments (4)

tigerdunes

mike_home

Related Discussions

dtwinters
Original Author

tigerdunes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Down to Final 2 Heat Pump Bids - Lennox vs. Bryant/Carrier

Comments (4)

tigerdunes

mike_home

Related Discussions

dtwintersOriginal Author

tigerdunes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

dtwinters
Original Author