Is a service contract a good deal?

16 years ago

We replaced our central AC last year, and the heating/AC company that did the work offered a costly annual service contract that provides annual preventive maintenance.

We have not signed on. In the 17 we've lived in this house, we only occasionally had preventive maintenance done, and have not had any serious problems. We have a natural gas hydronic heating system which means that when the thermstat calls for heat, water from the hot water boiler is pumped into a heat exchange device (I think they're coils), and a fan blows air over the coils thereby heating the air and blowing it into the house. I believe this heat exchange system is also integrated into the AC, but I'm not sure how and what purpose it serves (Is it the condenser?). The system is very good for smaller size homes like ours (1600 square feet), although it is not the most efficient. We avoided the highly efficient gas furnaces (like Trane) (98% efficient) because they tend to dry the air too much, and using a humidifier to compensate for that can be problematic.

My question is: How often should I have a service technician do preventive maintenance on the system?

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (7)

tigerdunes
16 years ago
the contract is on just the AC or AC and hydronic?

what do you describe as costly?

what is age of the hydronic?

any problems with either AC and hydronic?

you are changing your filters regularly?
fandlil
Original Author
16 years ago
When the new AC was installed the heat exchange unit was also installed. As far as I can tell, the only thing that was not new is the gas-fired boiler, which is about 10 years old. The installers told us it was in "excellent" condition.

The price they want is $280 a year for labor and lubricants, but any parts would be extra. I really don't feel like shopping around for a maintenance contract. I like and trust this company, but I can't help feeling this is too much money. If I pass up the offer and let the thing go for a couple of years, what are the risks of my incurring a costly repair that could have been avoided?
Related Discussions
Is this a good deal?
Q
Comments (6)
3.5 for downstairs and 2.5 for up, it is a bit much but the load from all 4 contractors called for a little more than 5 1/4. I face the sun almost all day with very large bay windows in the front. The furnaces are Lennox, had a good friend that works for a large commercial HVAC company that said furnaces are great, rarely used here, and don't let them try to sell you new ones, and all 4 bids agreed furnaces are fine. New evap coils are included along with the other fluff I mentioned earlier.
...See More
Costco Lennox Unit a Good Deal?
Q
Comments (48)
I recently purchased the Lennox unit from Costco and it is not a good deal and also buyer beware. I was looking to have a 3-ton mini-split unit installed in my garage. One of my requirements was an external smart thermostat. Costco does not do the install and is a middle man. They sub contract the work out to my local HVAC contractor who said the unit would support an external smart thermostat of my choice. This was confirmed 3 times. After the install was completed, they were unable to support an external smart thermostat (not Lennox). I am now in a battle to get the unit removed and refunded and Costco is a total pain in the ass and refused to refund me even though the contract specifically states install customer provided smart thermostat. I'm working through other channels right now before suing them for the refund. Couple of lessons learned: 1. Lennox is dated and doesn't support external smart thermostats. This is important so you can control all your HVAC through a single app and also gives you added features from a tech company. 2. The "deal" itself is not a deal. After getting quotes for a new unit (that does support an external thermostat), I found that you are getting ripped off. Costco gives you a 10% rebate to buy stuff from Costco but even after all of that you can get units installed cheaper from others 3. Go buy a Mitsubishi or Fujitsu unit as they are more current with features and support of things. Everyone has been telling me that Lennox is the lowest end brand/units 4. Do not buy any contractor services from Costco because #1, they don't do the work and it's hard to get a refund if anything goes wrong. They are just a middle man taking a cut that you can get better pricing elsewhere.
...See More
Miele or GE extended service contracts For my W4842 & T9822?
Q
Comments (4)
MieleÃno contest. Miele enters your machines into its database where a history of service, parts, and hours of usage are logged. Miele will also, during a service visit, review your machine for revised parts and install them should the your machine exhibit symptoms that warrant the part is updated. Our experience with Miele's techs has been exemplary.
...See More
Deal Hinges on Appraisal But There Are No Good Comps
Q
Comments (44)
Thanks guys! Lirodendron, yes, we're supposed to close THIS Friday! Then we're going up to Jersey on Tuesday and will close on the next one on Wednesday. My buyers are letting me stay in here for two weeks after closing but with all the trips back and forth, it's really not a lot of time. We're moving ourselves to save money. In the beginning we were going to get movers but every time I lost a buyer and we put it back on the market, we put it back on for less money and so now I'm coming out with less. Therefore we're doing all the moving ourselves. As far as the hay, we're going to take one load in the horse trailer, close to 100 bales, and the buyer will buy whatever is left over. She lucks out. I'm selling it to her for the same price I paid but she doesn't have to get it and stack it! It's not the winery house. When we lost one of our buyers (I can't even remember now which one because this has happened so much), the seller of the winery house wouldn't give us a house selling contingency even with a kick-out clause. After we found another buyer, we went up there again to look at it and look at some others while we were at it. It looked horrible after going through the winter and we were so relieved she didn't lock us in! We felt like we were given a second chance! We found a better place, more suitable for the horses, with more acres and nice pasture. It's an old house too. Not grand like the winery house but I'll fix it and make it really cool. Thanks for asking! Check out my blog again for a real interesting update about this stress I'm under and the message I got. Here is a link that might be useful: Greener Pastures--A City Girl Goes Country
...See More
ryanhughes
16 years ago
When I got a service contract my price was $349.95 and it included most parts (excluding compressor, etc.), labor, and 2 annual cleanings/checkups. I hope this helps you evaluate your estimate.
ryanhughes
16 years ago
I've gotten great use out of this service contract. I've had a freon added (until leak was found), a capacitor, schraeder caps/valves, and a compressor replaced (under warranty), and I paid nothing for parts or labor. I can't imagine what the bills would have been like without this contract. Given, my system was problematic at the time, and yours may not be.
energy_rater_la
16 years ago
I think they are a good idea. One major repair and the
service contract cost is re-couped.
A twice yearly checkup for change of season is also
a good idea for prevenitive measures.
Best of luck to you.
heimert
16 years ago
Well, you can shop around for prices to determine whether the contract is reasonably priced. It's not a take it or leave it proposition--you could always go to them and say "Why shouldn't I go with the other guy for $180?"

Service contracts are a moneymaker for the company, but that's business. We have one anyway, although it's $140/year (air heat and hvac). We got it for two reasons--preventative maintenance is a good idea, especially on a system that is 12+ years old (as ours is). Second, it gives us priority response if something does break. And you know when things break--the first day of cold weather or the first day of hot weather. And that's exactly the same time that everyone else has problems. So for us we consider it cheap insurance against not having heat or cool.

We're moving in a few weeks, and I may reconsider. Our house will have all new systems so I'm less sure it needs an annual check up, at least for the time being.
ryanhughes
16 years ago
You guys got great deals on your service contracts. I paid around $350--but mine is a full service agreement (FSA). I've gotten great use out of it, though--the service tech recommended it for the problematic system, and it has been great to have. 24/7 emergency service, most parts covered, no charge diagnosis visits. I've been able to call the company on the weekend, have them come out and diagnosis it, then come back and install a part at zero cost to me.

Is a service contract a good deal?

Comments (7)

tigerdunes

fandlil
Original Author

Related Discussions

ryanhughes

ryanhughes

energy_rater_la

heimert

ryanhughes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Is a service contract a good deal?

Comments (7)

tigerdunes

fandlilOriginal Author

Related Discussions

ryanhughes

ryanhughes

energy_rater_la

heimert

ryanhughes

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

fandlil
Original Author