Not sure which way to turn, H-E-L-P!! (xpost to Home Dec)

11 years ago

The good news is I have a new roof (hail storm last May). . .the bad news is that on the back side of the house the roofing company had taken everything off (1 layer of composition, 1 layer shake, felt, and decking) leaving only the framing "slats". They "tarped" the open area, but we had an unexpected storm blow in (60 mpr winds and I had an inch of rain in my rain guage). In my bedroom, the rain came in through the top of the window, the ceiling fixture in my closet, completely filled the globe in the ceiling fan at the end of my bed and collected about 4 inches of water in a trashcan. There are water spots all over the ceiling. Biggest one is about 3 ft x 3 ft. . . almost all of the ceiling where it meets the wall on the back side where the rain came in and there are several dinner plate sized ones, plus the area around the ceiling fan. The next morning they pulled the wet insulation out of the attic over about 2/3 of the bedroom and recommended that I not sleep in the bedroom. They agree it is their problem and are coming out this next week to see what needs to be done. The guy that removed the insulation the following morning said he thought they would probably have to replace the ceiling as the drywall has sagged enough to see the seams in some places. The ceiling has dried out pretty much (this happened Tuesday nite/Wednesday am), but the "setback" at the top of the window is still damp today (I peeled back the wallpaper) and the light in the shower has been out (I thought the bulb burned out, but it cam back on the next day) and it still smells kind of musty in my closet.

My question/concern is how to tell how much damage was "really" done" and what should I fairly expect the roofing company to repair? A friend said she didn't see how they could replace the all/part of ceiling without messing up the top of the walls and she thought I should get either new wallpaper or new paint job.

Since the roof was an insurance replacement, I notified my local agent who said he would notify the adjuster on the roof claim.

Any recommendations on how to make sure the roofing company doesn't gloss over the damage (they are a reputable local company, but still. . . .). I don't want more than is fair, but I want to make sure there is no "hidden" damage that won't show up until a few months/years down the line. Maybe have the insurance company send out an adjuster?? I thought about having a remodeling contractor come out, but not sure how "interested" they would be since it would be just a "consulting" job.

While I am far from helpless (:), it's just me. . and I don't have a background in construction!!

Thanks for any advice you can offer.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (9)

User
11 years ago
Have the insurance company send an adjuster to take a look at the additional damage. Frankly, your roofing company is being MORE than generous because it really is not their fault. They weren't negligent and can't control the weather so I'm surprised they are accepting any responsibility at all. This is what insurance is for.
brickeyee
11 years ago
" Frankly, your roofing company is being MORE than generous because it really is not their fault."

They failed to adequately protect the house.

It IS there fault.

It is what THEY have insurance for.
Related Discussions
pH and Alkalnity
Q
Comments (38)
Alkalinity is a measure of a waterÃ¢ÂÂs capacity to neutralize acids. It is the concentration of soluble alkalis in a solution. It should not be confused with pH. If your water is high in alkalinity (usually measured in ppm of CaCO3), it will require more acid to lower the pH. I had to study up a lot on this during the growing season for my container pawpaw production. Pawpaws are much like blueberries--they like low pH--close to 5.0. I am not a chemist--just a studious grower. Here are two websites you need. The first is a great article from NC State about alkalinity. The second is the ALKCALC, an invaluable calculator to help you determine how much acid you need to add to your water to bring down the pH. NC State Alkalinity article ALKCALC As an example, my well water has high alkalinity (280 ppm CaCO3), and the pH is 7.5. To get the pH down to 5.5, I must add 2.055 ml of sulfuric acid (battery acid) to a gallon of water. My container blueberries also thrived on this solution. However, water that has been treated with acid may not be able to overcome the problems in the container mix. Most of my containers were made up with 5-1-1 or a mix of pine bark and compost. It worked great. In other containers I experimented with mixes containing sand. Here, the plants did poorly. I later did a pour-through test and learned that the pH of these containers was 7.0, despite the acidic irrigation water! Have your water tested. Use test strips to confirm your pH changes. Best of luck with your plants. Marc
...See More
Cheapest way to test soil pH using red cabbage
Q
Comments (42)
I don't put any sulfur in the holes of the roses pictured. The other holes with sulfur didn't bloom well. My heavy clay is very retentive, there is no leaching here. Here's a quote from Nutrient Stewardship site: "Phosphorus is the nutrient most affected by pH. ..Nitrogen, Potassium, and sulfur are less affected. At alkaline pH values, greater than pH 7.5, phosphate ions tend to react quickly with calcium (Ca) and magnesium (Mg) to form less soluble compounds. At acidic pH values, phosphate ions react with aluminum (Al) and iron (Fe) to again form less soluble compounds." It's good to test if one's tap water is alkaline, some cities add lime to water so pipes won't corrode. Calcium in lime will bind with phosphorus, and less is available. In my 12 years of growing flowers in pots, the year that I got continuous MOST blooms despite my pH 8 water was when I used high phosphorus SOLUBLE fertilizer, and low nitrogen. Granular phosphorus like bone meal and 46% superphosphate are useless in the planting hole here in alkaline clay. My results confirmed what University of Colorado stated "bone meal and rock phosphate can only be utilized at or below pH 7". My pH 7.7 soil was tested most deficient in phosphorus. Here's a quote from David Neal, CEO of Dyna-Grow Plant Nutrition in CA: "There is some evidence to believe that low N helps to convince a plant to stop its vegetative growth and move into its reproductive phase (flowering), but environmental factors are probably more important. P is typically 5th or 6th in order of importance of the six macronutrients. There is little scientific justification for higher P formulas, but marketing does come into play ...." He's right, just a tiny bit of SOLUBLE phosphorus made more blooms and more roots - but beyond that is wasteful. The site, Robert Morris NOBLE plant foundation, rated the mobility of NPK: "Let's compare the mobility of NPK on a scale of 1 to 10. Nitrogen is a 10 ... extremely mobile and can be lost to leaching. Potassium is a 3. It has limited movement in the soil. Phosphorus has a rating of 1. It is immobile in the soil and is likely to stay wherever it is placed." Here is a link that might be useful: Soil pH and availability of plant nutrients
...See More
H-E-L-P ... apprehension about buyer & non-refundable deposit
Q
Comments (19)
"Getting a little off topic, but are all house sales by guardians subject to the control of a guardian judge? Or is this a unique situation because of the foreclosure?" Oh - actually, it's part of a Guardianship as set by our particular Judge. It is not related to foreclosure - but the Judge wanted to be quite involved in overseeing the sale. My attorney has insinuated she is unique in her involvement. The original "Order to List and Sale" would have allowed it to be (obviously) listed and sold within the constraints which was identified in the order (i.e. range of sale price). This particular Judge lined out the "and Sale" - thereby giving me authority to list the house, but not sell it. Now, a separate "Order to Sell" needs to be petitioned when a contract is received that meets the list price range. I'm so frustrated by this situation - the house is being sold ASAP due to dwindling funds of the Ward. And, to petition the court for approal to "list and sell" has cost about $1000. By the Judge excluding the "to sell" stipulation, it costs an additional $500 for the additional petition/order. How is this fair? I am trying very hard not to have significant distrust and aversion to attorneys - but between this and some unfair dealing with divorce proceedings (of another family member), I am gaining suspicion of our legal system. Oh - and I hope I wouldn't reap penalty from giving my card number to another employee --- especially it was suggested that I do that by HR for another's travel/lodging reservation! Ha. Off topic --- how do you itallics or quote prior posts?
...See More
Not sure which way to turn, , H-E-L-P! (xost to Home Disaster)
Q
Comments (4)
For an insurance claim, you usually have up to 2 years to report any additional damage found as a cause of the initial claim, without paying an additional deductible, but your policy may be different. Get a reputable contractor (preferably 2 or 3), along with YOUR insurance adjuster, and the roofing company adjuster to take a look and determine the best course of action. I agree completely with the photos-of damage, during repair process, and after repairs are completed. Keep a copy for yourself-hold on to them for a minimum of 2 years, possibly longer, if you should decide to sell the house, you have proof that the repairs were done correctly and to code.
...See More
User
11 years ago
And what temporary system would have protected the house during a storm with 60 mph winds?
cherigw
Original Author
11 years ago
called the insurance company and adjuster on the roof claim and while they are "very interested", this is a separate issue that is between me and the roofing company. I'm having a water mitigation company come out tomorrow to assess the damage as I have disovered the sheetrock on the wall is wet underneath the window (vinyl wallpaper, so it didn't show throught until I pulled back a little corner).

Re: responsibility of roofing company. They didn't hesitate to accept responsibility. I live in "tornado alley", so they are quite accustomed to securing damaged roofs for severe weather and wind. . .after the round of tornadoes in spring 2010, there were people who didn't get their roofs repaired until the following fall and lived for several months with "tarp roofs" over a good portion of their homes.
millworkman
11 years ago
Bingo, brickeye was and us 100% correct!!
toxcrusadr
11 years ago
It sounds pretty good so far, replace all the wet attic insulation.

It seems like some wallboard is going to have to come out in order to repair the known wet insulation inside the wall around the window. AND elsewhere to assess where else water may have gotten. You *must* make sure there is no moisture left in the walls, because mold will grow and you'll have serious problems.

Elec. fixtures should be turned off, opened up and checked for moisture AND corrosion, and replaced if necessary.

Other than that it sounds like they're doing the right things.
brickeyee
11 years ago
"And what temporary system would have protected the house during a storm with 60 mph winds?"

Adequate tarps with nailed down battens.

The tarts become single use, and off to the landfill from the nail holes used for the battens.

It might cost more than drywall, but is far less than plaster repair.
User
11 years ago
Well, clearly I was mistaken on this one. Good luck with your repairs.
lafdr
11 years ago
My friend had a similar thing happen and was able to redo her entire bathroom and put in recessed lights through out the damaged ceiling areas (some of this was at her expense since it was upgrades from the original). The roofing company's insurance stepped up and made all the damaged areas better then they were. I say this as reassurance since hers turned out great. But yes it was a huge stress. They need to prove to you they have allowed proper drying and mold testing.

Not sure which way to turn, H-E-L-P!! (xpost to Home Dec)

Comments (9)

User

brickeyee

Related Discussions

User

cherigw
Original Author

millworkman

toxcrusadr

brickeyee

User

lafdr

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Not sure which way to turn, H-E-L-P!! (xpost to Home Dec)

Comments (9)

Related Discussions

cherigwOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

cherigw
Original Author