Bird feeder contains lead!

16 years ago

I just purchased a copper plated bird feeder and found the following warning on the inside:

PROPOSITION 65 WARNING

This product contains lead, a substance known to the State of California to cause cancer, birth defects and other reproductive harm. To reduce the risk of exposure, wash your hands after handling.

Um - wouldn't that make it bad for the birds?? Of course my initial reaction is to return it, but I thought I'd see if anyone knows for sure whether the birds can safely feed from it.

Thanks,

Patti

Featured Answer

spedigrees z4VT

16 years ago

This is the inevitable result of extending permanent normal trade relations (PNTR) to China back in the late 1990s, combined with generations of continuing de-regulation in our own country.

40,000 pets were poisoned with melamine by an estimate of a California veterinarian. I have not fed commercial petfood to my pets since April of 2008, and never will again as long as components of every brand on the market are made in China. (US law does not require that countries of origin for wheat gluten and other such composite ingredients be disclosed on labels.)

The scarey part is that many more birdfeeders, kids toys and other items probably contain lead and other toxins. Good for your state for their stringent disclosure law, but a pity they allow these products to be sold. My state (Vermont) has cracked down on some products from China with lead, but I'm sure many more products have escaped their oversight. I worry about the plastic hummingbird feeders and petfood bowls (to say nothing of dishware for human use) that I am using, but not sure what I could replace them with that might be safer.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

Elly_NJ
16 years ago
Return it.
bbcathy
16 years ago
Absolutely and then shame them for selling it!!! Gees
Cathy
Related Discussions
Adding a Bird Feeder to Vegetable Garden: Brillance or Stupidity?
Q
Comments (27)
I feed em and bathe em. Took a while to find the right place for the feeder. I hang mine off a tall skinny metal pole and there is a horizontal 5 foot piece of skinny bamboo that is stuck on there for a landing perch. You want a place where they can sneak up on the feeder through branches and cover and where such branches and cover are so thick down low that it makes it nearly impossible for a cat to get at them. And you want a place where any fallen seed cannot germinate. Seeds fall onto shaded ground with lots of overhead competition. A bath you can put anywhere. My favorite is just a 12 inch plant saucer that sits on a bench and is visible from the TV room. You can watch them fly down and jump in and out, especially when it gets hot outside. Pool party!
...See More
Help with ID of odd 'pellet's in bird feeder.
Q
Comments (18)
interesting sandy. i knew the vit k treatment but i didn't realize it was heparin! which leads me to my mystery, though i never would use poison bait. it is all this talk of rats and mice. someone is trying to move into my romeo's sleeping box in the shed. but my reason for posting is quite hilarious- he went to investigate why my 15 some pound bag of composted manure was moving. i am standing at the back door and hear "SQUEEK!" i wish i saw it, but alas i had only my tshirt and undies on and it was still daylight. hey, i work midnights, ok? :) i had a mental picture of it jumping in the air and squeaking at the same time. the big oaf ran out of the shed, belly to the ground, and wanted back in the house. that surprised me. my old man at romeo's age would have had his whiskers twitching in anticipation. so, my mystery continues....though maybe in the process we have discouraged our visitor. i also took the top off his sleeping box to make it less inviting. i have found no rear projectiles. i am also considering leaving the feeders empty for awhile. i would hate to do that. just sharing a story. i didn't want to start a thread just for it. it almost applies.
...See More
Plants below bird feeders?
Q
Comments (19)
Hey there eye- just give them the yank- pull them the old fashioned way- As for under the feeder plantings- I have my feeder in the shade and have tried many things under there in hopes that something may take- alas- for many years- nothing has done well directly under the feeders- 6-10" aside of them- all is well- but there is so much traffic under the feeders- and up the poles that I have yet to find the plant that will stand up to the problem area. I guess I will have to rethink my plan- and come up with an equally pleasing solution- maybe a low bird/kritter bath/watering station- or a found rock sculpture.... Let me know if you find the answer to the under the shade feeder empty bed syndrome. Julie
...See More
Birds at Feeders
Q
Comments (14)
Because the others are females and they are his harem? Maybe all the other males are out buying beer for Super Bowl Sunday? Maybe all the other males are sleeping off their pre-Super Bowl party celebrations last night? I don't know why you only have one male, but here at our house the females always outnumber the males. Often the males eat early in the day and the females eat later. Female redwings don't really look that much like the males, so it is easy to tell that you have more females than males. Lots of people don't even realize the females are female redwings and think they are something else. Yesterday, in a rather odd form of behavior, the males were going mad over the cattail seedheads, and the females weren't. I have no idea what that means. I see a pretty similar gender segregation with the cardinals too. The males come in big groups of 10 or 12 or 15 to eat. Later on, the females come in smaller groups of 2, 3, 4 or 5. I wonder why. Finally, how about the deer and the way they feed. Our does and fawns, even the young males, come together in a group. They eat first. The minute our really big buck shows up, all the others scatter. It isn't that the buck is aggressive and pushes them away from the food. In fact, he stands in the neighbor's pasture about 20' from where the deer are feeding and waits patiently. He never comes to the food and nudges them away from it. However, from the moment he shows up, all the others are antsy and nervous and hungrily snatch a few more bites before quickly leaving together as a group. Respect for the buck's superior size and strength? Fear? Who knows what it is, but it is interesting to watch. Dawn
...See More
lisa11310
16 years ago
And don't forget to give the manufacturer a good thrashing too! Was it made in China?
pkthomas
Original Author
16 years ago
Yep, it was made in China. I guess if they're okay with poisoning our kids (lead-tainted toys) then we can't expect them to care about our birds.

I'm sending an email to the MN DNR and to Lowe's. I think they should recall them.

Patti
sowngrow (8a) G
16 years ago
Good for you for checking the label. We need to be vigilant as many products out of China contain lead. Wouldn't think so in this day and age, but it's happening...
catherinet
16 years ago
Its really, really hard to find many things NOT made in China.
I never buy things I eat off of from China.
And its hard to trust any manufacturer/supplier anymore, about being honest about anything!
:(
sowngrow (8a) G
16 years ago
When stories about lead in products made in China, started coming out, I bought lead testing kits at Home Depot and checked the plastic plates and a couple other things I already owned, for lead. None were positive. If you have any other bird feeders you're not sure about, the lead testing kits are an option.
User
16 years ago
Proposition 65 ... one of the biggest wastes of label space I can think of.

"While the intent of Prop 65 was to "inform" consumers, the impact of warnings under the Act has been a proliferation of meaningless warnings. Virtually every business has some sort of Prop 65 warning sign posted, and innumerable products are labeled with the warning. From gas stations to hotels, from grocery stores to hardware stores, consumers are deluged with warnings that they are being exposed to unnamed carcinogens and reproductive toxins. They are not told either the degree of exposure or the likelihood that they may actually be impacted by it. Moreover, because the risks to business of not providing a warning, many provide a warning even though they donÂt actually know whether an exposure is occurring, or even if the exposure is trivial, further diluting the meaning of warnings to consumers."
chinamigarden
16 years ago
Brass has lead in it. Virtually all of your plumbing fixtures are brass. Virtually all of them have prop 65 warnings.

Lazygardens has it right

Bird feeder contains lead!

spedigrees z4VT

Comments (10)

Elly_NJ

bbcathy

Related Discussions

lisa11310

pkthomas
Original Author

sowngrow (8a) G

catherinet

sowngrow (8a) G

User

chinamigarden

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Bird feeder contains lead!

Comments (10)

Related Discussions

pkthomasOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

pkthomas
Original Author