Roses and paniculata hydrangeas in the same bed, anyone?

15 years ago

I am in the process of creating a new flower bed in a a full sun area. Originally, I was going to have just a mixture of paniculata hydrangeas (Limelight, Little Lamb, Pinky Winky, Pink Diamond, Quick Fire) with some colorful perennials. However, the more I think about it, the more I thought that it would be great to have roses in there, to provide the bed with some much needed early and long-lasting colors, since these paniculata hydrangeas bloom later in the summer and their blooms are mostly white and pink.

Here's the kidney-shaped area in question (it is still full of grass yet but will be converted into a bed soon!):

I wonder if anyone has successfully created a bed with such a mixture of paniculata hydrangeas and roses? Are they good companions? I already have a Julia Child, Day Breaker and Pink Knockout Rose in pots and I can easily plant them into the bed.

I would very much appreciate your opinion please!

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (6)

dublinbay z6 (KS)
15 years ago
If the roses will get at least 6 hours of sun and those are the type of hydrangeas that can be grown in that much sun (I always forget which ones can), then I see no problem. I have some Annabelle hydrangeas (white) in part shade not too far from William Shakespeare 2000 and some other Austins which get sun, and the look is great.

My memory is that the late summer hydrangeas can get very large with time. Don't know about the ones you selected, but you might double-check mature sizes on everything so you don't have a tangled mess on your hands later.

Let us see pics next year--I'm looking forward to them.

Kate
ostrich
Original Author
15 years ago
Thanks, Kate!

Yes, these paniculatas are the hydrangeas that can tolerate full sun in the north (where I am) and they do grow quite big without pruning!

I should get sufficient sun there for roses. If I put in roses, I will reduce the number of hydrangeas in the bed, so that I will have enough space for everyone...

I wonder how big Day Breaker, Pink Knockout and Julia Child can get? Different websites list different sizes so it's hard to tell which one is correct! Does anyone have any idea please?
Related Discussions
Hydrangea paniculata 'Big Ben'
Q
Comments (14)
I gather the seed in Nov/Dec and usually sow in January in the greenhouse. One flower head will produce way more seed than you will ever use as the seed is about the same size and texture as dust. Prepare a seed flat and I use Metromix360, but about any soilless mix should work and dampen the media, sprinkle the seed like salt and pepper, pat it down, keep warm and moist, and germination usually occurs in 10 days. I transplant as soon as a couple sets of true leaves have emerged into 2.5 inch pots using a compost:pine bark:perlite mix and gradually move up in pot size, eventually going into a trade 1 gallon #300 in mid summer. First years growth can be as much as 15 inches and I pinch stems to promote more branching. If you need to wait till warm weather occurs for seeding, your growth will be considerably less. These can be planted out the second year and some may bloom, third year for sure. I do only corrective pruning 2nd and 3rd year, and the 4th year prune to get the size plant I want. Give it a try and Good Luck I did find a picture of that Little Lamb bed you were asking about. Go the website I linked, scroll to the bottom of the first Photo page and click on page 3. Image DSC6517 is the Little Lamb bed and 6505-6516 are some of the 4 year old seedlings grown form seed collected from Pink Diamond. Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Gallery Photos
...See More
Hydrangea Paniculata Great Star
Q
Comments (10)
It sure is a lanky plant and has been a bit hard to tame. But I like it anyway. Mine's about to pass 6' in height and buds are beginning to form at different rates. Some tips... It does need some pruning. Keep the main stems no more than 3' in height. The new and old stems are on the flexible side and even just rain on the leaves will begin to weigh down the branches. New stems seem to grow 2-3' before blooming, so you know they're going to bend a bit in rain, especially once it has flowered. I also get rid of the small stems that grow out and lay along the ground. They don't really get any thicker or bloom down there. This promotes fuller growth up top, and allows space to grow stuff underneath Great Star's canopy. I've got two dwarf macs under mine. :)
...See More
Hydrangea paniculata 'Bombshell' is no bust
Q
Comments (41)
No, a color change suggests that the bloom is mature and spent. After several weeks, a white paniculata hydrangea bloom begins a progression of color changes that ends in a brown bloom, similar to the color changes observed in roses. If you lived in a southern location, you could try deadheading the bloom after it begins to change and see if you get new bloomage. Some paniculatas do that in the South but I have not seen anyone confirming that VS "reblooms" for them. Reblooming white mopheads (H. macrophylla) will produce new blooms if you deadhead the spent blooms but, I am not sure if they can grow in your zone/location because you do not have this information displayed. Normally, they have winter hardiness issues when planted in very cold zones. An experiment that just occurred to me: you might be able to lengthen the amount of time that it stays white if the shrub is relocated to a spot in brights full shade with no direct sunlight. Maybe. Just maybe that may lengthen the whites. The reason I say this is because of my Little Lime. Paniculatas Limelight and Little Lime have blooms that start green then turn white, a shade of pink and eventually end brown. My LL is located in bright, full shade so it never gets direct sun. As a result, I have noticed that the blooms stay green for a very, very long time. If Limelight is exposed to full sun conditions, the blooms turn white faster. But my LL did not get a-n-y whites the last two years (or maybe they appeared near the end of the Fall and I did not notice). My LL blooms went from green directly to a shade of pink. This year it seems to be going in the "same trajectory". The blooms opened in late June and, as of today, they remain green. So, I wonder if -maybe- VS blooms may stay white longer if not exposed to direct sunlight. You could try that and see what happens. Or maybe someone who already has VS in bright but full shade can chime in with their observations of how long it stays white under those conditions..
...See More
Hydrangea paniculata fall blossoms
Q
Comments (18)
I have noticed that the Annabelle leaves appear here more tired or flimsy by the end of the growing season in December. Like the had a rough time with the hot summer and-or the pooches chasing squirrels around Anna. Hee hee hee! I know what you mean with hailstorms. Very frequent events down here in Spring, Summer and Fall. As a matter of fact, I had a mophead protected by a Crape Myrtle in the back when a hailstorm hit and broke the branches that shaded it. I did not think anything about that until, weeks later, I noticed that the plant look like it had yellow and green leaves! Like green-yellow poinsettias sold at Walmart. Turned out the hailstorm hit in the summer and the leaves were no longer being protected and were getting sun 6am until 3-5pm. The leaves in contact with that much sun then got bleached, which forced me to build a contraption to provide temp shade until the cooler weather showed up in October. Lord. I like the cooler weather in the NE too. I used to visit my mother in law Aug-Oct for that reason and I found it funny when "locals" would gasp about how hot it was and then I remembered why I went to visit at that time (it is so much cooler... ha!).
...See More
redsox_gw
15 years ago
Hi, I have the paniculata Limelight. It came with our house and I must say it is huge! You are in a very different zone, but Ohio is our neighbor here in KY. This year was a drought year for us and the limelight looked great for a while but in the past 2-3 weeks, not so good. But the season is over...and this was not a typical year.

I don't mean to hijack but are you very familiar with Limelight? Do you cut it to the ground in Fall? Or just prune it lightly? I have heard if you cut back at the right time, you get fewer flowers, but larger ones. Like roses, I guess.
ostrich
Original Author
15 years ago
Hi Redsox,

It's OK - I don't mind talking about Limelight here, but then it's the Rose Forum!!! LOL!

Anyway, I did not really prune my Limelight last year (it was planted just last year). However, though there were many blooms, the stems were weaker. I am going to prune it next spring, so that there will be fewer blooms, but the stems will be stronger and the blooms will be larger.

If you search in the Hydrangea Forum, you will find some interesting and helpful information there. Some also recommended pruning some of the branches only, leaving the stronger ones behind, so you will have a nicely balanced plant that will be full and maintain a vase shape. I think it will grow back if you cut it to the ground, but the goal is to maintain a nice vase shape so you should prune it in such a way to achieve that. I also understand that with paniculatas, you should aim to achieve a strong, single-trunk structure too in order for it to look its best.

Now, do you have roses as companion plants next to your Limelight? How tall and wide is your Limelight? How old is it?
redsox_gw
15 years ago
Ostrich, sorry for the errant post! I will send you an
e-mail about the Limelight but these GW e-mails don't always work so if you don't receive it in a day or so, let me know over here.
ostrich
Original Author
15 years ago
Hi Redsox,

Guess what? The e-mail did you come through! You may want to just use this address:

ostrich_001@yahoo.com

I look forward to hearing from you soon!

Roses and paniculata hydrangeas in the same bed, anyone?

Comments (6)

dublinbay z6 (KS)

ostrich
Original Author

Related Discussions

redsox_gw

ostrich
Original Author

redsox_gw

ostrich
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Roses and paniculata hydrangeas in the same bed, anyone?

Comments (6)

dublinbay z6 (KS)

ostrichOriginal Author

Related Discussions

redsox_gw

ostrichOriginal Author

redsox_gw

ostrichOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

ostrich
Original Author

ostrich
Original Author

ostrich
Original Author