Abraham Darby or Sharifa Asma in PNW
rivercat773
16 years ago
Featured Answer
Sort by:Oldest
Comments (12)
John (PNW zone 8)
16 years agoLindyB
16 years agoRelated Discussions
Any changes to this long list of fragrant roses?
Comments (20)You're welcome! It's not odd that cooler zones will report more fragrance from many than warmer areas. Those in the cooler places are probably smelling them when the oils and alcohols are most volatile and smell the most. We in the warmer areas often miss out because they evaporate faster as the heat increases. Also, as aridity increases, the scents burn out faster. The various components of each rose's fragrance evaporate at different rates, so one may smell very Damask at first, quickly morphing into orris or citrus, finishing a completely different scent before losing any detectable trace for the day. Any user can access the Advanced Search, but Premium Membership permits you to specify multiple traits and types, where basic membership only provides Advanced Search using one criteria. Kim...See MoreBest Austin English Roses for PNW climate
Comments (10)I'll echo others' comments, I think most Austins do fairly well here. The only one that did horribly was Ludlow's Castle. (It's a dog-I've never heard anyone praise that rose!) An aside-Many of the soft colored roses are myrrh scented (e.g. Ambridge Rose) which is a love it or hate it scent for some people (it unfortunately makes me feel sick) so you might try to smell one before you fill a garden with Austins. That said, for me, here are the best I've grown (all have good disease resistance no spray, I tolerate some blackspot as long as they don't defoliate and 2/3 of leaves look okay) Objective Best: Molineux and William Shakespeare 2000. Subjective Best (because I prefer the fragrance/color/larger flowers:) Pat Austin, Jude the Obscure, Golden Celebration, The Prince. Molineux: always in bloom, excellent disease resistance manageable, bushy shrub (not an octopus/wannabe climber) individual blooms are short-lived/not a good cut flower light musky/tea fragrance William Shakespeare 2000: looooong-lasting flowers on bush; good cut flower strong damask "true rose" fragrance wider than tall/spreading Pat Austin: dazzling large copper colored flowers with medium fruity tea scent arching shrub, poor cut flower Jude the Obscure: excellent disease resistance romantic soft colors, strong grapefruit based fragrance poor repeat bloomer, ok cut flower IF cut as bud opens octopus/wannabe climber (it sends out waving 8'+ tall canes by end season) Golden Celebration: large blooms, strong fruity fragrance, good cut flower arching growth more blackspot problems than others I've listed The Prince deepest color, damask/old rose fragrance, good cut flower manageable bushy growth, Hope that helps! Dawn...See MoreRose buying self control
Comments (18)I just put eight more in the ground a couple of weeks ago, adding up to 103. That's a total of 30 new ones this year to replace/add to my gardens this year. The only way for me to control myself is to just not go to the nursery.(I only buy from a local nursery). Everytime I have went to just get one or two, I come out with four, five, six! At the beginning of the year my goal was to get to a hundred, and I made it. But I will be going back to the nursery this w/e with my mother, and I already know that I won't be able to come home empty-handed! (Actually, I can't wait to go!! Yippeee!!) Shelly...See Morethinking of replacing Abe Darby
Comments (4)Papi Delbard has wonderful large flowers similar to AD's. The plant has good resistance here so far (2nd year). It is a bit more climberish, but most short climbers can be pruned into good large shrubs. Also I love Clair Matin as a shrub. It is a tremendous bloomer, and has an extraordinarily good plant habit and foliage. Sorry I can't help with teas....See MoreJohn (PNW zone 8)
16 years agopacnwgrdngirl
16 years agorivercat773
16 years agoJohn (PNW zone 8)
16 years agopatricianat
16 years agorobin_d
16 years agoJohn (PNW zone 8)
16 years agojerijen
16 years agorivercat773
16 years ago
rivercat773Original Author