Red Sunset Maple pruning help

11 years ago

I have a Red Sunset maple that's been in the ground a few years. I want to do the first major prune and it really needs some help. I'll be hiring someone, but I was hoping for some feedback so I don't sound like an idiot when I talk to him.

My first question is, is it ok to prune now? Or should I wait til June or so when the sap is done? It's buds are swelling but not yet open; it's been unseasonably cold.

The second question is, as you can see by the pictures it lacks a central leader. I understand that is normal for maples but it has WAY too many branches crowded together around the central portion of the trunk. Which would be best to thin out? Thanks.

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (10)

soitgoes
Original Author
11 years ago
Here's a picture of the whole tree. I can't get a background that's not busy. Sorry!
soitgoes
Original Author
11 years ago
A closeup from another angle.
Related Discussions
Red Sunset Maple loosing leaves
Q
Comments (6)
If the trees were in pots, the mixture they would have been planted in would be one to allow good drainage - in the nursery, pots are watered daily with an automatic system, usually, even twice daily on the hottest days, and good drainage in the pot is a must. Since the trees MAY have had enough or even too much water in the first few days/weeks, it may also be that the leaves were dried out too much before they were planted, in transport, especially if that entailed travel on highways - wind and sun are very drying. When planted, the root ball usually needs to be watered daily, or every other day, for the first few days, until the roots have a chance to grow out of the root ball and into the surrounding soil. After that, the frequency of watering can slowly be cut back, as the dryness of the soil/root ball dictates, until watering takes place weekly. Do NOT water on a schedule but according to the dictates of your soil. Right now, soak the root ball, in a LONG, SLOW watering - you want the water to get to the very bottom of the root ball. Test by sticking a finger up to the second knuckle into the soil (into the root ball for now, and for the next month), and water again when it is dry at that distance down, about 2 inches. If the root ball is very dry, then water, even if the surrounding soil is moist. If it is very sunny, hot or windy, you may need to water daily, if it is cool or shady, then less frequently; if you have clay, it may be once a week, if in sand, every other day - I don't know your soil nor your weather. If the leaves wilt in the heat of the day, don't worry as long as they perk back up in the evening or by morning - it's a normal physiological reaction to heat. If they stay wilted, WATER! I would suggest that you speak again to the nursery, and speak to the manager or owner, as the advice given you was less than helpful. If they aren't accomodating, I suggest you avoid that nursery in the future, at least for advice and planting services! Ask for a guarantee, since they advised you on the care of your tree. It MAY pull through, going into early dormancy, and it may not, having become too dry in the hottest part of the summer. If you try a scratch test on a twig/branch - lightly scratch through the outer bark and see if the cambium layer is still green - and it is green, then with care, the tree should be OK come spring. Even if it loses all its leaves, keep watering as indicated - the roots will continue to grow until the ground freezes. Another possibility is that the trees were planted too deeply - take a look and if the trunk goes straight into the ground like a telephone pole, then it may be planted too deeply. Dig around at the base of the trunk until you come to the root flare, which should be at or slightly above ground level. If it is only an inch or so down, you can gently scrape the soil back, as widely as possible, and keep it clear. If it is more than that, then it is too deep, and I would ask that they come back, re-dig them and reset them a few inches high, since the soil put into the bottom of the hole will settle. There should be no or a nominal charge for this, since it is their mistake, but..... If you, or the installers, did not mulch, I would do so - it keeps the roots cooler, more moist, limits weed/grass competition and keeps weed-eaters and lawn mowers away from the trunk. Mulch as widely as possible, at least 3', no deeper than 4", and put NO mulch in the inch or so next to the trunk. Of course, if the trees were planted deeply, then wait to mulch until after that has been rectified.
...See More
Red Sunset Maple vs. Willow Oak...Opinions
Q
Comments (16)
"Would you? Could you?" From my childhood memories, squirrel is very tasty but so many have to die to feed me a meal (I'm a big eater) that I can't really get behind it. Not a fairly advanced mammal, that looks so cute. Now, 1 chicken could feed me a meal. A cow would feed me a number of meals. One squirrel is an appetizer. Your ethics may vary. Richard.
...See More
dead bark on Red Sunset Maples
Q
Comments (1)
Well, I'm not sure that you can upload images to this site. However, I would upload the file to a site like you-send-it, then paste the image's URL in the Optional Link URL box.
...See More
Red Sunset Maple
Q
Comments (2)
About the watering, that also depends allot of the soil, climate, and what it's been doing lately. Where are you located? i.e. I'm in Northwest Arkansas. For here, at this time, 2-3 inches a week would be way too much water, probable even for a red maple that likes water.
...See More
ja-gardener
11 years ago
It is kind of hard to see what exactly is going on here, but YES you have WAY too many branches going on there.

I attached an image with my suggestions for what I think I see. Basically remove that middle little branch as soon as the spring sap flow slows. I think that other smaller one should go, but it might be alright.

There are at least two there that look pretty big and you should probably reduce them drastically and keep them from getting any thicker while the rest of the tree grows. You can then remove them next year or maybe the following.

Again, I can't see everything there, but that gives you at least an idea of what somebody might do. A good arborist actually there to see it will probably make better decisions.
soitgoes
Original Author
11 years ago
Thank you ja-gardener. That is pretty similar to where my very uneducated eye was going too; I know that the one branch is too low and has to come off, but I figured the stuff in the middle was more critical as it could effect the integrity of the tree. I'll let the lower branch on for another year or two.

I am thinking that if it is carefully pruned as it matures it will end up with two to three main branches coming off the trunk.

It was not perfect when we bought it, but not nearly so crowded! Other than taking off too very thin low limbs I've mostly let it go. It went in the ground nearly four years ago, but the first year ended up being terribly dry. We watered it diligently but it was stressed so I wanted to give it several years to make food for roots before taking anything off the top. This will help me start the conversation with the arborist and I'll see what he says.

I might have him out to look at it before it leafs so he can get a good idea of the structure, then have him prune it this summer.
ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
11 years ago
ja mentions reducing certain branches.. google :

SUBORDINATION PRUNING ....

to get yourself a bit more up to speed on that ...

and shall we presume you are aware.. that every guy with a chainsaw is not an arborist .... or shall we discuss that???? .. in fact.. this isnt really a chainsaw job ....

and to be very honest.. i hope you dont mind.. i see some very problematic included bark problems.. as well as crotch issues ... i really dont know if this tree is worth paying some guy a hundred or 200 dollars to prune for you .... we could also discuss this.. if you are interested ...

it might be cheaper to get a new tree ... [probably not what you wanted to hear.. i am sure] ....

ken

ps: in fact.. what might be the best idea.. is for you to buy a saw.. and do this yourself .. to learn.. and if the tree collapses .. then go spend the money on a new one ....
whaas_5a
11 years ago
Another vote for one of these two options.

it might be cheaper to get a new tree ... [probably not what you wanted to hear.. i am sure] ....

ps: in fact.. what might be the best idea.. is for you to buy a saw.. and do this yourself .. to learn.. and if the tree collapses .. then go spend the money on a new one ....
soitgoes
Original Author
11 years ago
Ken, yes I know that everyone with a saw is not an arborist. :-)

The bark ridges are raised, not sunken... I will let the arborist decide. Maples are notorious for developing multiple leaders so if I start over I will quite possibly end up with the same problem again. It is in full sun with no competition which of course tends to cause this problem to happen. I should have had it pruned last summer, which is totally my fault but last year was crazy.

I'm no expert but I don't fancy starting over unless it's the only option. The diameter of most of the branches is still very small. Thanks for your input.
soitgoes
Original Author
11 years ago
So on my way home from work I looked at the dozen or so 15-year-old maples planted by our parking lot, and then I went through the park and looked at bunches more, and I must say that fully half of them have very similar branching patterns to mine. I'm not saying it should not be addressed, just saying that cutting down the tree and starting over seems fairly radical.

Moreover, I looked at the 75 year old mature maples lining the roads, and almost all of them developed multiple leaders further up as they matured and could no longer be so easily pruned.

Seems like the normal growth habit, which speaks to the importance of pruning but again makes it seem like hacking the tree down would be radical.

Some of the wild ones by me split as low down as a foot from the ground. I would not want that, of course, but the also have 18-inch diameter trunks. One is growing entirely at a 45 degree angle with three leaders, one of which split again into two. We've had 60 mph gales and it's never dropped a limb...
ja-gardener
11 years ago
I agree I would hate to spend $200 trying to rehabilitate a tree that could be replaced for $250.

I included a link to booklet that is from the author of a great book on pruning (Gillman) that is very expensive. That pamphlet might give you some further guidance on pruning your tree.

And YES pruning those middle branches (especially on a maple with thin bark) will be a surgical procedure requiring a nice small saw.

Here is a link that might be useful: Developing a preventive pruning program: Young trees
soitgoes
Original Author
10 years ago
I just wanted to bump this thread to say that I saw the arborist today and he will remove the funny little branch right in the middle and then do reduction pruning on some of the co-leaders, with the idea of coming back over the next few years to gradually get it in the right shape.

The cost? $75. He seemed to think there would not be any problems. ja-gardener, you were pretty much right on the money with your advice, so THANK YOU! :-) He wants to wait til early September (because we have very hot summers and it's in full sun) to avoid scald; that should still give it time to heal before it goes dormant.

Red Sunset Maple pruning help

Comments (10)

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

Related Discussions

ja-gardener

soitgoes
Original Author

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

whaas_5a

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

ja-gardener

soitgoes
Original Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

Red Sunset Maple pruning help

Comments (10)

soitgoesOriginal Author

soitgoesOriginal Author

Related Discussions

ja-gardener

soitgoesOriginal Author

ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5

whaas_5a

soitgoesOriginal Author

soitgoesOriginal Author

ja-gardener

soitgoesOriginal Author

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author

soitgoes
Original Author