Need Recommendations for replacement lawn Tractor

12 years ago

Hope I can get some help here. My old lawn tractor - a 1995 Simplicity Regent with a 14hp motor, a 38" deck & hydrostatic trans - which I've had for around 10 years (I bought it used) - is finally dying. The steering has more or less given out/gotten destroyed and the mower has been abused shamelessly. For the record, we have around 1/2 to 3/4 of an acre of even but rocky land which has weeds, obstacles, stones, and all manner of mower-destroying crap lying around. The Simplicity handled most of it well...but has been gradually falling apart for years. Also out here in Oregon it's virtually impossible to get replacement belts or anything else for it - as Simplicity's aren't sold on the West Coast. So buying another Simplicity isn't in the cards.

Also, my budget is limited right now. Ironically, I can afford to spend more for a new mower/tractor than a used one - because (duh) used equipment is a cash purchase - while buying new I can put it on credit, get deals, payment plans, etc. But that said, I've narrowed my current choices down to a small handful of possibilities and want feedback or suggestions. Here are the current possibilities -

1. a used 1999 heavyduty Craftsman with a 50" deck, a 25hp Briggs & Stratton V-Twin and a lot of bells & whistles. This mower/tractor has been used but very very well maintained by a caring owner; the asking price is somewhere around $750 which sounds reasonable....except for the age.

2. a 2009 "Professional" Craftsman with a 24 hp B & V-twin (with 'low' hours - only 22) & 42" deck. Basically a newer and slightly smaller version of #1 (though still larger than my old Simplicity) - asking price somewhere around $900

3. a used model 145 Deere, 22hp engine, 48" deck, approx $1100 (not sure what year)

4. Buying a NEW mower/lawn tractor which allows me to charge it and/or finance it. I realize that generally you can't get something inexpensive (aka cheap) and have it either last or have quality - but right now I'm cash/finance challenged so the idea of paying less is appealing. The two possibilities that interest me the most are -

4.a) a dirt-cheap 6 speed 42" 17.5 HP Ariens from Home DeSpot for "only" $999

4.b) one or two Craftsmen, including one with a 42" deck, hydrostatic trans, 21 hp B & S engine, discounted from around $1800 down to 'only' approx $1400

Hmmm...what else should be on the list?

I like Snappers - the old RER's - and would consider buying a newer Snapper lawn or garden tractor if the price and financing deal/s were right. And unlike Simplicity's (which aren't available on the West Coast, or in Oregon where I live) Snappers are plentiful - and have a good reputation.

I'm also fond of the older Ariens which had a local rep for being indestructible - but they're hard to find and the newer (and cheaper) ones which Home Despot sells seem tinny in comparison

Last but not least there is a local Deere dealer - but buying a Deere around here seems close to buying a Mercedes in the car world - you get quality but you have to pay through the nose for it.

So - there I am. I'd love some help in making up my mind - and as you can see from reading this - I'm all over the place.

Ideas? Suggestions? Reality checks?

Thanxxxx

Miguel

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (3)

tomplum
12 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
The $999 Ariens HD has sold for the past several seasons and , in past promotions included free blades every year. I don't see it on the HD site currently. If this year is the same as the preceding models, it is made by Husqvarna, a fair enough entry level tractor. If it had a Kohler Courage single, I would probably leave it in the store. Tho they say that they have addressed the block cracking issues this year. Sears riders were predominantly made by Husqvarna until the last few years. look under the seat of a Sears and you see the model # starting in 917- it is built by them too. The Briggs Intek twins were not bad, but enough of them ingested dirt which killed the engines. So, if you see a "suitcase" type (like a handle on top of a rectangle) air filter element, look carefully down the throat and look for signs of ingesting dirt. 2 or 4 thumbscrews to remove and have a look. They eventually went to a canister type that seems to be performing OK. The entry level Deere's and Husqvarn built tractors are a good place to be for something that is serviceable and dependable.
rustyj14
12 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
Well, if ya aren't going to go thru yer yard and clean up the rocks, sticks, and other debris, ya might as well go buy a used farm tractor with a brush hog already on it, and mow for a year! Eventually, you will have tossed everything that would harm a good lawn tractor into the lawn next door. then you can go and buy a nice, well built lawn tractor/ mower, with a hydro tranny, large engine, etc. and mow safely!
Just be aware that yer neighbor doesn't buy the same kind, and toss it all back into yer yard!
Related Discussions
replacement lens for John Deere lawn tractor
Q
Comments (5)
Are you wanting to replace because they are broken? Or because they have become weathered and cloudy in appearance? I presume broken, but just in case it's the other........there are products on the market now to restore clarity to plastic headlight "lenses". (Just wanted to make it known if anyone has that problem, maybe on the family car?) Check your favorite automotive parts center for these products and/or kits.
...See More
Need help choosing lawn tractor/riding mower please!
Q
Comments (11)
Heather, I have a Craftsman DSG 6500 garden tractor that I really like. This is a garden tractor as apposed to a lawn tractor so it is able to use "ground engaging" equipment. It has a 54" cutting deck. I put a Johnny Bucket attachment on the front of it which acts like a front end loader so that you can use it to plow, move dirt, compost, etc. I have the manual transmission but the auto is easier to use. I use it to haul either with the Johnny bucket on the front or I have a dumpable cart that I haul around. You mentioned that you'd like it for a bigger place some day so this tractor would do everything you want and more. The tractor is right around $2200.00 give or take and for another $1000.00 you can get a 2-stage snow blower for the front which should help with your weather. I purchased the 3 yr. at home service agreement that covers pretty well everything for about $300.00 but I've never had to use it. This tractor is made by Husquvarna. My only concern is that if you have a dealer right in your neighborhood, that may be the better way to go. Craftsman 26 hp 54 in. Deck, DGS 6500 Garden Tractor Sears item# 07128750000 Mfr. model# 28750 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Availability of home delivery for this product varies by location Eligible For Store Pick Up Other colors available: Protect this purchase with a Protection Agreement see options Price Match Policy No Interest, No Payments until September, 2008, with your Sears Card. Sears Card. Add a Tractor Bumper (07124598) for Free. Offer ends 05-Sep-2007 See Details Overview Specifications Options Reviews(14) This is a Garden Tractor capable of using ground engaging attachments. Powered by a Briggs & Stratton 26 hp ELS (Extened Life series) V-Twin engine (includes oil filter) with overhead valves for cooler running and longer life. Match the speed with the job that needs to be done with our Extra Heavy Duty EZ Drive hydrostatic/automatic transmission . A 54" Precision Cut Plus deck system with four gauge wheels and more air flow for better cutting and bagging. Capable Of Using Ground Engaging Attachments Powerful 26 hp B/S Els (Extened Life Series) V-Twin Engine Exclusive 54" Precision Cut Plus Deck System W/ 4 Adj. Gauge Wheels Spring Loaded Deck Lift System Extra Heavy Duty Ez Drive Hydrostatic / Automatic Transmission Foot Pedal Drive For Added Convenience Large 23" Rear Tires Handy Cup Holder Wider Step Thru Area Automotive Type Slide Seat System 2 Year Limited Warranty __USERID__ Overall Rating 4.7 5 13 of 14 (93%) customers would recommend this product to a friend. Read all reviews Write a review Number of reviews: Number of reviews with ratings & comments:12 Number of reviews with ratings-only:2 Write an online review Product Reviews Product Reviews Review This Product Choose a sort order Featured Reviews First Buyer's Reviews First Staff Reviews First Top Reviewers First Date - Newest First Date - Oldest First Rating - High to Low Rating - Low to High Helpfulness - High to Low Helpfulness - Low to High Length - Long to Short Length - Short to Long FEATURED REVIEW Overall Rating: 5 5 April 28, 2007 By ChasfromBenld from Benld,Illinois Performance: 5 5 Value: 5 5 Features: 5 5 Reliability: 5 5 "I give this Tractor a 10 on scale of 1-10. The 26 HP Briggs and Stratton has plenty of power and very smooth operation, I love the hydrostatic drive. It is very convenient and simple to use. I have been mowing my property with a old mower and decided it was time to upgrade, This is my first experience with a Craftsman Garden Tractor. I can honestly say this is the best garden tractor I have ever owned. The price was right and the sales and delivery experience from Sears was outstanding. Prior to using this Tractor, I read and studied the owners manual, I work in the Heavy Duty Truck Industry and can honestly say this Tractor is put together really well. And you can get any part you need very easily from Sears. The Tractor came with an illustrated parts manual and every part used on the tractor can be ordered which impressed me greatly. I will be ordering both summer and winter accessories as this tractor can be used year round. I would expect this Tractor to last 20 years. Now I need to convince my wife to let me buy her one so we can have a his and hers tractor. :)" Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report Inappropriate Review) Overall Rating: 5 5 Upgrade from LT1000, August 21, 2007 By AFChief from Crestview, FL Performance: 4 5 Value: 5 5 Features: 5 5 Reliability: 5 5 "Had a great Craftsman LT1000 for 4 years without a problem, but needed something bigger that would take attachments. Researched different options and the DGS6500 met all the needs for a 1.5 acre yard, there is no greater capability for the price. Bought the scoop attachment for scraping and hauling, works great on flat surface but the mower deck can cause some drag on uneven ground. Starts easy, runs great, but I wish the reverse had better response, it's rather slow for going back and forth with a scoop. To get the full engagement you need to pull up on the accelerator pedal rather than press down on the reverse pedal--no reasonable adjustment option available. Relatively quiet for a 26 HP tractor with impressive power. Multiple attachment options avaialble--gets the job done, it's a keeper!" Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report Inappropriate Review) Overall Rating: 5 5 Little Workhorse, June 6, 2007 By Atliberty from Petaluma, CA Performance: 4 5 Value: 5 5 Features: 5 5 Reliability: 5 5 "This garden tractor is being used for mowing grass, lawn and field. It does well at all jobs. The only difficulty is if the terrain gets uneven and then I may need to push it by hand, I'm learning to use the reverse feature to get me out of certain situations. It seems to be very safe, easy to start, reliable and a little workhorse. I didn't buy the mulcher and don't think that my needs indicate it." Was this review helpful to you? Yes No (Report Inappropriate Review) Overall Rating: 2 5 WAS GREAT....AT FIRST, June 6, 2007 By thunderbolt from Virginia Performance: 5 5 Value: 2 5 Features: 5 5 Reliability: 1 5 "For the first 4 hours i loved this machine.at 4 hours the main drive belt came off front pulley.I called the service center,June 11th was as soon as someone could look at it,This was may 28th.The guy on the phone talked me through getting the belt back on track.Everything was fine untill it had 7 hours on it,the belt broke.I had to tow it to my shed.I went to the store Monday June 4th they got a guy to come out today the 6th to "fix it".He didn't have the belt with him.I have to wait 2 days for the belt to arrive then call them again.He said it was "to new" for him to have it,called the store 5 miles away they have it in stock,but can't have service people have it. I believe the belt broke because it wasn't properly set up at the store or the factory.Be sure if yout tractor has any problems go to store and make sure the service guy has the part .My problem is probly not the norm for this machine,I'm writting this to warn others incase it happens to them."
...See More
Need advice on new lawn tractor
Q
Comments (3)
I think if it's just a broken cable on your present mower, you have a new deck on it so if it was me I'd take a chance and save a lot by just having the cable replaced., If there are other existing issues then that would be a different story.
...See More
Need help choosing lawn tractor vs. Kubota BX tractor vs ZTR
Q
Comments (2)
It is a matter of exploring your needs. Mowing acres you would want to go at least with something like a large X series Deere or larger Kubota GT. Both make heavy duty zero turns as well. A better investment would be a sub compact or compact tractor , both on what you can do with it and resale market. I'm told that baggers on like the BX are really meant to be left on and can be a big deal to change. I might suggest a forum like tractorbynet and ask the folks there how they like their mowers. Where in Washington are you? Much success for your upcoming business.
...See More
twelvegauge
12 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago
With such a relatively small area to mow, and considering that there are Snapper dealers in your area, I would shop those dealers for a Snapper rear-engine rider - good, sturdy equipment.

Need Recommendations for replacement lawn Tractor

Comments (3)

tomplum

rustyj14

Related Discussions

twelvegauge

COMPANY

BUSINESS SERVICES

GET HELP

CONNECT WITH US